Why Nice Guys Aren’t Good Men: The Difference Between Nice Guys And Good Men

 / 

, , ,
Why Nice Guys Aren’t Good Men

Do you find yourself attracted to “nice guys” but wonder why the relationships never seem to work out? The truth is, there’s a big difference between nice guys and good men.

If you’ve spent any time in the dating world, you’ve probably heard the phrase “nice guys finish last.” It’s an age-old adage that suggests that being too nice or too kind can actually work against you when it comes to finding love and romance. 

But what exactly is the difference between a nice guy and a good man? And why do nice guys often fall short when it comes to being the kind of men that women truly want?

Let’s explore why nice guys arent good men and why being a good man is essential for a happy and healthy relationship.

The difference between nice guys and good men

While being kind and considerate is certainly important, it’s not enough to make a man truly desirable as a partner. Too often we confuse being nice with being good. But there is a vast difference between nice guys and good men. Though initially they may seem similar, there are key distinctions between the two.

At first glance, it might be hard to tell the difference between a nice guy and a good man. After all, both types of men are generally kind, considerate, and respectful. But there is a crucial difference between the two. The primary difference between nice guys and good men is that the nice guys prioritize being liked over being respected, while all good men prioritize being respected over being liked.

Related: Why Nice Guys Lose In Dating

Nice guys are men who go out of their way to be kind and accommodating to others, often at the expense of their own needs and desires. They may be overly eager to please, and they may avoid conflict or confrontation at all costs. Nice guys often prioritize being liked over being respected, and they may struggle to assert themselves in relationships.

On the other hand, good men are men who are also kind and considerate, but who are also confident, assertive, and self-assured. They are men who can stand up for themselves and for others when necessary, and who are not afraid to take risks or speak their minds. The good men prioritizes being respected over being liked. They are more likely to be leaders in their personal and professional lives.

Now let’s dive in to know more about nice guys vs good men.

Traits of a nice guy 

Nice guys may be overly eager to please and accommodating to others, often at the expense of their own needs and desires. They may be passive and avoid conflict or confrontation. They may also lack confidence and direction in their lives. 

To better understand the difference between nice guys and good men, let us delve into some common traits of a nice guy:

  • Overly eager to please others, sometimes at the expense of their own needs and desires
  • Avoids conflict or confrontation
  • May lack self-confidence and self-esteem
  • May struggle to assert themselves in relationships
  • Prioritizes being liked over being respected
  • May lack clear direction or purpose in their lives
  • Can be passive or indecisive
  • May have trouble setting boundaries and prioritizing their own well-being
  • May struggle to take risks or try new things
  • May have trouble attracting or maintaining romantic relationships

Related: Are You A ‘SIMP’? 7 Signs Of A Simp And What To Do About It

Traits of a good man

All good men are confident, assertive, and self-assured. They have a sense of direction and purpose in their lives and prioritize being respected over being liked. Some good men are more likely to be leaders in their personal and professional lives, while the nice guys may struggle to assert themselves in relationships.

Here are some common traits of the good man:

  • Confident and self-assured, with a strong sense of self-worth
  • Assertive when necessary, but able to handle disagreements or conflicts in a respectful and healthy way
  • Prioritizes being respected over being liked
  • Has a sense of direction and purpose in their life, with clear goals and ambitions
  • Compassionate and kind, but also able to prioritize their own needs and boundaries
  • Takes responsibility for their actions and decisions
  • Reliable and trustworthy, with a strong sense of integrity
  • Able to communicate effectively and openly in their relationships
  • Emotionally mature and able to handle stress or challenges in a healthy way
  • Has healthy and fulfilling relationships with friends, family, and romantic partners

Understanding the traits of nice guys and good men can help us better understand the nice guys vs good men debate.

Why nice guys arent good men

Nice guys aren’t always good men. While being nice is certainly an admirable quality, nice guys are often not necessarily what they seem. Here are a few reasons why nice guys fall short when it comes to being the kind of men that women want:

1. Nice guys lack confidence

One of the key differences between nice guys and good men is confidence. Nice guys may come across as insecure or lacking in self-esteem, which can be a turn-off for many women. Good men, on the other hand, are confident in themselves and their abilities, which can be very attractive. This is why nice guys arent good men.

2. Nice guys are often passive

Nice guys may avoid conflict or confrontation at all costs, which can be frustrating for women who want a partner who can stand up for themselves and for their relationship. All good men are not afraid to be assertive when necessary, and they are more likely to take charge in their personal and professional lives.

3. Nice guys prioritize being liked over being respected

While being liked is certainly important in any relationship, it’s not enough to sustain a healthy and fulfilling partnership. Good men prioritize being respected over being liked, which means that they are more likely to set boundaries and stand up for themselves and their relationship.

Related: Nice Guys Finish Last Because They Are Manipulative Liars

4. Nice guys may lack direction

Nice guys may be so focused on pleasing others that they neglect their own goals and ambitions. Good men, on the other hand, are driven and focused, and they know what they want in life. This sense of direction and purpose can be very attractive to women. This is another reason why nice guys arent good men.

5. Nice guys may be too eager to please

While being kind and accommodating is certainly important in any relationship, it’s possible to take it too far. The nice guys may be so eager to please their partner that they neglect their own needs and desires, which can lead to resentment and unhappiness over time. This is one of the biggest difference between nice guys and good men.

The nice guy facade

Nice guys put up a facade of niceness. They act nice to be seen as nice rather than because they actually care about others. They say the right things and perform the actions they think will make them appear kind. But beneath this superficial niceness often lurks resentment, manipulation and self-centeredness.

Nice guys are agreeable on the surface, telling you what you want to hear and performing nice gestures. But their external actions rarely reflect their internal character. Their “niceness” is conditional and motivated by a desire for praise, favors or romantic relationships in return.

Nice guys also have hidden, selfish agendas. They want something in return for being nice – attention, approval, dates, etc. Whereas all or some good men naturally seek to uplift others without expecting anything in return.

The true motives of the nice guys often only reveal themselves after they’ve been rejected. Suddenly the niceness evaporates and is replaced by anger, resentment and attempts to punish the perceived wrongdoer. 

Good men, on the other hand, are kind for its own sake, not because of hidden conditions and strings attached. This is a crucial difference between nice guys and good men.

Related: What Women Really Want In A Man: The Player Vs. The Nice Guy

Good men are authentically kind

In contrast, all good men are kind out of genuine care and concern for others. Their character and motivations are aligned. They act the same way whether people are watching or not because caring for and helping others is intrinsically rewarding.

Good men have well developed empathy that allows them to understand and resonate with other people’s emotions. They listen without judgment and try to put themselves in others’ shoes. Their actions arise from wisdom and insight, not shallow pretense.

Nice guys vs good men

Here are some other difference between nice guys and good men that you should know about –

1. Nice guys give compliments and do favors to boost their own ego, seek validation and gain approval. The good man uplifts others because they genuinely see the good in people.

2. Nice guys see women as prizes to be won through superficial niceness. Good men see women as full human beings deserving of respect.

3. Nice guys often have an external locus of control, blaming others for their problems. Good men have an internal locus of control and take responsibility for their own lives.

4. Nice guys follow a rule-based approach to morality, focusing on superficial actions. Good men follow a principle-based morality that focuses on cultivating good character.

Want to know more about nice guys vs good men? Read on.

5. Nice guys’ niceness is fragile and fleeting. The smallest setback can reveal their true selfish nature. Most or some good men exemplify consistency, stability and integrity.

6. Nice guys act out of insecurity and a need for external validation. The good man

 acts out of confidence in who they are and what they value.

7. Nice guys lack empathy, seeing women as objects to be possessed. Good men have true empathy and see others as ends in themselves.

8. Nice guys lack honest self-reflection, seen in their inability to consider others’ perspectives. Good men demonstrate self-awareness through active listening and considering multiple views.

Related: What Bad Boys Know That Nice Guys Don’t

Good men exhibit the virtues that arise from wisdom, self-mastery and true care for others. They act with authenticity, integrity and consistency, grounded in principles rather than superficial image. Nice guys, by contrast, often lack these deeper qualities that define what it really means to be a good human being.

How can you distinguish good men from nice guys?

Here are some traits that will help you distinguish most or some good men from the nice guys. All you need to do is be observant and open-minded. 

1. Assertiveness

Good men are not afraid to be assertive when necessary, while nice guys may avoid conflict or confrontation at all costs. 

2. Honesty

Good men are honest and truthful in their words and actions. Nice guys are often deceptive and manipulative to get what they want.

3. Integrity

Good men adhere to strong moral principles and act in accordance with their values. Nice guys lack consistency and integrity.

Related: 3 Steps To Kill The “Nice Guy” Syndrome

4. Selflessness

Good men consider the needs of others above their own desires. Nice guys are self-serving and only pretend to care about others.

5. Confidence 

All good men are secure in who they are and don’t need to prove anything. Nice guys are often insecure and seek validation through niceness.

6. Maturity

Good men demonstrate emotional maturity through self-control, patience and grace. Nice guys act immaturely when things don’t go their way.

7. Humility

Good men recognize their own flaws and limitations. Nice guys have an inflated view of themselves and feel entitled to praise.

8. Wisdom

Good men base their actions on wisdom, insight and principles. Nice guys act rashly without deep thought or understanding.

9. Authenticity

Good men act in accordance with who they truly are on the inside. Nice guys put on an artificial facade to gain approval.

10. Self-awareness

Good men understand their own motives, emotions and impact on others. Nice guys lack self-knowledge and insight into their own behaviors.

11. Empathy

Good men genuinely care about others and strive to understand them. Nice guys are primarily self-focused and lack empathy.

12. Kindness

Both good men and nice guys can be kind and considerate, but good men will not sacrifice their own needs and desires to please others. The good man is kind and compassionate, but also has healthy boundaries and is able to prioritize his own well-being.

Good men exhibit the inner qualities and virtues that arise from moral and psychological maturity, like honesty, integrity, wisdom and love. Nice guys, by contrast, often lack these deeper dimensions of character.

Being good is crucial, being nice is optional

The primary difference between nice guys and good men is confidence, assertiveness, and a sense of self-assuredness. 

Nice guys may seem kind on the outside, but often lack the internal character traits that define truly good men. They are motivated by self-interest, have hidden agendas, and lack emotional stability and strong virtues. Good men, however, are authentically kind and caring. Their goodness flows from wisdom, empathy, resilience and a desire for moral excellence. 

Learn to see past empty platitudes and performances of niceness to discern the difference between nice guys and truly good men.

Related: 17 Uncomfortable Signs You’ve Finally Met A Good Guy


Nice Guys Aren’t Good Men
Why Nice Guys Aren’t Good Men Pin

— Share —

— About the Author —

Responses

  1. Nick Avatar
    Nick

    A man is not gonna solve all of your problems. Remember only God is truly god or the universe or what have you.

Leave a Reply



Up Next

Hermeneutic Labor: This Term Describes When You’re Struggling To Make Sense Of A Man’s Thoughts

Clear Stages Of Hermeneutic Labor: Emotional Work

Whether it means picking up hints in a text message or interpreting what isn’t said during an argument – many women find themselves doing “hermeneutic labor.”

Amid the confusing roads of romance, trying to understand secret messages or get through emotional minefields can seem like a full-time job. In recent years there has been an eruption of discourse surrounding feminists and emotional labor.

Let’s understand what hermeneutic labor really means and why most women ​take up emotional labor in relationships​!

Understanding Hermeneutic Labor



Up Next

8 Unmistakable Signs He Will Never Come Back: The Final Farewell

Glaring Signs He Will Never Come Back: No Second Chances

Ah, the bittersweet realm of love and heartbreak. We’ve all been there, hanging onto that tiny edge of hope that things might get better again, and we don’t have to go our separate ways. But let’s face it, sometimes it’s just not meant to be. Today, we are going to talk about the signs he will never come back. Yes, it’s going to get a bit heavy today.

If you are wondering whether he is ever going to make a grand return to your life or not, then let me tell you – you are in for some tough love, my friend. In this article, we are going to explore eight glaring signs that are repeatedly telling you that your ex is not coming back.

It’s time to face the reality and discover if it’s time for you to leave the past behind you and look forward to a better and brighter future.



Up Next

9 Tactics To Trigger The Hero Instinct In A Man

Hero Instinct In A Man: Ways To Trigger Their Inner Hero

Do you know there’s a hero instinct in every man? If you want to unlock that side of your man then you have come to the right place. Today, we are going to talk about how to trigger the hero instinct in a man, and do it the right way.

From understanding their innate drive to protect and provide, to unraveling the mysteries of their emotional landscape, we will explore what is the hero instinct, and what does hero instinct in relationships look like.

So, ready to know more about this side to men? Let’s go then.

Related: How To Make Your Man Happy: 25+ Last Minute Gift Ideas For Him



Up Next

Men’s First Love Theory: 7 Life-long Psychological Impacts Of First Love

Men’s First Love Theory: First Love Psychological Impacts

Can men never get over their first love? Men’s First Love Theory has blown up all over the internet, especially on TikTok. The theory’s first taste of romance sets every partner at an inevitable disadvantage.

When we fall in love for the initial time, this theory claims that it leaves a lasting impact. We tend to think and view our first love as “the one,” causing us to compare every individual we meet after them to our original partner.

The term “first love syndrome” explains how our initial encounters with emotion factor into what we consider to be true love. It’s almost like we’re biologically hardwired to search for that same feeling we had when we fell in love for the very first time.



Up Next

Masculinity And Mental Health: 12 Warning Signs of Depression In Men And What To Do

Signs of Depression in Men You Shouldn't Ignore

Do you often feel frustrated, irritable, and withdrawn? If you are a man and if you are frequently in a bad mood, then it’s likely that you have male depression. The shadows of masculinity can often hide the signs of depression in men.

Male mental health is a topic we rarely talk about as a society that is supposed to be fair and equal. Yet, societal expectations often silence the cries for help from men who suffer from depression. 

But let’s change that today! Depression affects millions of people worldwide, regardless of gender. However, men often face unique challenges when it comes to recognizing and addressing



Up Next

8 Body Flaws Men Find Irresistibly Attractive In Women

Body Flaws Men Find Irresistibly Attractive In Women

Today we are going to explore a topic that’s not just interesting, but honestly, a bit heart warming too! We are going to talk about the “imperfections” and “body flaws” which women feel awkward about, but men absolutely love!

You know what I mean; the tiny body flaws that we are convinced make us less attractive. As women, we often regard them as shortcomings or things that take away from our beauty, but they are the very things that many men fall in love with.

So, let us plunge into this and find out what are those “body flaws” that men really adore about us, and what men think about women’s bodies.



Up Next

The Cheaters’ Playbook: 3 Types Of Men Who Have Affairs

The Cheaters' Playbook: Types Of Men Who Have Affairs

Have you ever wondered why do some men have affairs? It isn’t always because they’re just looking for excitement or are bored. There’s usually more to it. There are actually 3 types of men who have affairs, and we are going to do a deep dive into that today.

In a perfect world, love would keep everyone on course, but the truth is we often have to deal with betrayal and heartbreak. We’re going to take a close look at the 3 types of men who have affairs, some of the glaring traits of men who cheat, and most importantly, why do men have affairs.

Let’s start with understanding the traits of men who cheat.