What Women Really Want In A Man: The Player Vs. The Nice Guy

the player vs the nice guy

When it comes to dating, most women prefer romantic, sensitive, well-behaved nice guys. However, the same women often fall head over heels for the arrogant, brutish, and rude bad boys. If women want nice guys, then why do they date “jerks”? What do women want in a man, really?

A reader wonders why women say they want nice guys and instead fall head over heels for players.


Women say they want nice, genuine guys—not players, and care about personality more than looks. So why is it that when nice, genuine, funny guys show interest in them they are never interested, but instead go for players with nice looks?”

Related: What Bad Boys Know That Nice Guys Don’t

Good question. Let’s talk about how women process attraction.

Wondering why it doesn’t seem like women know what they want from a relationship with a man?

This begins with understanding the one thing about women that most men have completely backwards: what women want in a man.

They tell you they want a nice man with good manners who knows how to treat a lady and who loves his mother. A man who’s sensitive and responsible and who opens the door for them, tells them how beautiful they are, and is a great friend.

But then…

They fall madly in love with players who are unrefined, obnoxious, cocky, a bit childish and who you just look at and wonder:

“What the hell does that guy have going for him?”

Meanwhile, here you are, being the nice guy with good manners who knows how to treat a lady and who loves his mother. A man who’s sensitive and responsible and who opens the door for her, tells her how beautiful she is, and is a great friend.

And where does that get you? A place in her life as either a “great friend,” or worse, she slowly writes you out of her life.

What in the world is that all about?

You did everything according to the book.

You were just the man that she said she wanted.

How come you ended up in the friend zone while watching her fall head over heels for that “other jerk”?

Related: Why Girls Hate ‘Nice’ Guys

It’s because what people want isn’t often what they really say and think they want. The sooner you accept this, the sooner you can stop getting stuck in the friend zone. Now, this shouldn’t really surprise you.

“Just because you are a nice guy, doesn’t mean you are a good man.” – Zyanya Torres

After all, doesn’t almost everyone say they want things that are totally contrary to what their behaviors reflect?

How many people do you know who want to be healthy but live on a steady diet of completely trashy junk food?

How many people do you know who want to be rich but spend their money on crap, are deep in debt and can’t wait to get off work so they can go home to sit and watch TV for the rest of the day?

In spite of how much people want to be rich and healthy, they are driven by deeper subconscious motives, which most average people don’t take the time to understand.

I don’t say this to judge people.

Most people are pretty clueless about the true motives behind their behaviors because they really believe themselves when they tell you what they think they want.

If you want to know the real story about what people want on a primal level, you have to look at their behavior. If you want to know what women find attractive, don’t listen to what she says…look at her behaviors.

“Being a woman is a terribly difficult task, since it consists principally in dealing with men.” – Joseph Conrad

Believe it or not, there is something that “jerk” has that most women are drawn to like a moth to a flame.

These “jerks” make women feel safe (in the moment at least), and they excite them. This is an irresistible combination because security and excitement are two of the primary emotional needs which ALL people seek out in romantic relationships.

What women want
What women want

When a man meets these two emotional needs for a woman, he ignites a powerful subconscious attraction trigger that overrides the “reason” and “logic” parts of a woman’s brain.

Sound hard to believe?

Related: 3 Reasons Why Women Love Bad Boys And Dump Nice Guys

Just think about the times when men you’ve known (ever done this?) have completely abandoned their reasoning because of intense physical attraction to a particular woman.

Men are biologically programmed to respond to physical attraction.

Think about how many people abandon logic and reasoning about “what’s healthy” and eat foods they know are bad for them because it tastes good.

Think of how many people spend their money on things they really don’t need and end up broke, then go buy lottery tickets because they “want to be rich.”

These are all examples of how our emotional drives beat our logical, reasoning minds into submission.

And… this is why “players” (we’ll call them bad boys) ignite subconscious attraction triggers that seem to contradict a woman’s spoken desires.

How do bad boys do this?

First of all, these “Bad Boys” make themselves immune to being controlled by a woman’s whims, and this makes them unpredictable…which is exciting.

Think about it, how exciting is it for a woman when a man responds to her by doing whatever she wants because he’s afraid of “making” her feel sad, upset, jealous, angry, pouty, insecure, stupid or some other dramatic emotional state?

As you can imagine, this is pretty boring.

The more of a catch a woman is, the more accustomed she is to men acting like complete doormats whenever she bats her eyelashes.

Frankly, she’s okay with most men doing this because it gives her more power in the exchange… she just doesn’t chase, date, and sleep with these men. This isn’t a conscious process– it’s just that by acting like doormats, these men count themselves out of the running for her attention.

She dates the men who know how to take charge and aren’t intimidated by her.

…And that’s where her needs for security and safety come in…

“A good man will want you to shine. He wants you to be your amazing self. A good man loves to show off his happy, intelligent, amazing, powerful woman.” – Anastasia Netri

Think about this: how secure does a woman feel to have a partner who she can easily bring into submission?

Does this suggest that he’s weak, insecure and submissive OR powerful and confident?

Related: 16 Things Women Want From the Man in Their Lives

Of course, most women would truly love for him to also be a nice man with good manners who knows how to treat a lady and who loves his mother. A man who’s
sensitive and responsible and who opens the door for her, tells her how beautiful she is and who is a great friend (Sound familiar?).

That’s why women say this. They really do want those things ALSO. Nice guys truly make great fathers and companions.

However, here’s where the misunderstanding lies:

Most men are either one OR the other: the nice guy who acts like a doormat, or the unrefined, (biologically sound) bad boy who dances to the beat of his own drummer.

A very few men are both, and since the bad boy meets her biological need for safety and for excitement, she chooses him over the nice predictable man.

Now in case you missed the secret formula is hidden in the last two paragraphs, let me make this as clear as possible:

Develop the bad boy’s immunity to drama and external control, then balance that with the manners, sensitivity, and chivalry of the nice guy and you’ll truly become what women want– the total package.

“People will sometimes find themselves attracted to others, that’s just who they are. It’s what they do with that attraction that defines them.” – Donna Lynn Hope

There are no statistics to support this, but based on my general observations and life experience, I’d guess that kind of man is about one in a thousand at best.

Do you have a burning question about love, dating, sex or relationships?

Written by Elizabeth Stone
Originally appeared in Attract The One
women want
What Women Want In A Man: The Player Vs. The Nice Guy
what women really want in a man
the player vs the nice guy pin

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

10 Things That Women Like To Hear But Will Never Admit It To Anyone

Things That Women Like To Hear But Will Never Admit It

Compliments have the ability to make someone’s day and make them feel valued. Women, like everyone else, cherish kind words and genuine compliments. While some compliments are universally appreciated, others may not be openly acknowledged. There are things that women like to hear, but they might not admit that.

In this article, we will unveil 10 things a woman loves to hear but may not readily admit. So, gentlemen, get ready to make the women in your life feel special with these sweet and heartfelt compliments.

Let’s explore all those compliments women love to hear from their better halves.

Up Next

8 Ways Smart Women Choose To Be Happy

Ways Smart Women Choose To Be Happy

Happiness is not just an emotion; it’s a choice, a series of deliberate actions and perspectives that shape the story of one’s life. For smart women around the globe, choosing happiness is akin to picking the finest attire for the day—it’s essential, empowering, and uniquely personal. So, what are the ways smart women choose to be happy?

As we navigate the complexities of modern life, where roles are as varied as they are demanding, finding joy becomes both an art and a science. So, the question is how a woman chooses to be happy? They do it by embracing strategies that are as pragmatic as they are profound, sculpting their lives with the finesse of a master artist.

Up Next

Are You The Ideal Woman? Recognizing The 12 Signs Of A Good Woman

Signs of a Good Woman: Must Have Qualities To Look For

What defines an ideal woman? Is it their physical appearance, their accomplishments, or their nurturing nature? In a world where societal norms and expectations constantly evolve, the concept of an ideal woman can be subjective. However, certain timeless qualities and characteristics resonate universally. Let’s explore the signs of a good woman.

What is an ideal woman like?

The concept of an “ideal woman” or the “perfect beautiful woman” is subjective and varies across cultures, societies, and individuals. It is important to recognize that there is no universal standard for what defines an

Up Next

Do Females Live Longer Than Males? Exploring The Science Behind It

Do Females Live Longer Than Males? Science Backed Revelations

Have you ever wondered why some grandmothers seem to have an uncanny ability to outlive their grandfathers? Or why it’s often said that women tend to outlast men in the game of life? Do females live longer than males? And who live longer men or women?

The topic of gender differences in life expectancy has long piqued the curiosity of scientists and the general public alike. Let’s delve into the intriguing question: Why do females live longer and how much longer do women live than men? 

We will explore the scientific evidence, unravel the contributing factors, and shed light on the complex interplay between biology, behavior, and societal influences.

Do females live longer than males?

Up Next

What Is Eldest Daughter Syndrome: 10 Key Signs and Lasting Impacts Of Being The First Child

What Is Eldest Daughter Syndrome: Ten Key Signs and Impact

Are you familiar with the term – Eldest Daughter Syndrome? It’s a phenomenon that delves into the emotional weight often placed on the shoulders of the oldest daughters in many families, right from a tender age.

From tending to their younger siblings’ needs and assisting with daily household chores to taking care of ailing parents or even handling mundane tasks like sorting online orders, eldest daughters frequently bear a substantial but often invisible load of domestic responsibilities from their early years.

Now, you might wonder, what’s the harm in this? Shouldn’t older children naturally lend a helping hand and look out for their younger siblings? Isn’t it believed that girls are inherently better at caregiving? These commonly held beliefs are so deeply ingrain

Up Next

What Women Wish Men Knew: 10 Biggest Turn Offs For Women In A Relationship

Biggest Turn Offs For Women In A Relationship

Ah, the age-old quest of understanding attraction! Just when you think you’ve cracked the code of what makes someone tick, a misstep might make it seem like you’re back to square one. While every individual has their unique preferences, there are certain universal and biggest turn offs for women, that are absolute no-nos. 

It’s like that one out-of-tune string on a guitar or a splash of too much cologne on a first date—some things just stand out. And often, it’s not the grand gestures or the overt mistakes that raise eyebrows, but the subtle nuances that can make all the difference.

Ready to dive into

Up Next

“I’m Not Like Other Girls”: 5 Telltale Signs of A Pick Me Girl

Toxic Signs of A Pick Me Girl And How To Stop Being One

Ever heard of “Pick Me girls”? These are individuals who go to great lengths to prove they’re “not like other girls.” Let’s dive in and explore this phenomenon!

In this article, we’ll dive into what is a Pick Me Girl and, how to spot her, and provide examples to help you better understand this phenomenon.

What Is A Pick Me Girl?

Pick Me Girls are individuals, typically women, who go to great lengths to be chosen by someone they’re interested in romantically. They often believe that by being overly accommodating, agreeable, and submissive, they can