What Determines Jealous Protective Behavior In Men

 / 

Determines Jealous Protective Behaviour In Men

“I was feeling insecure. You might not love me anymore. I was shivering inside,” are some of the lyrics to “Jealous Guy” by John Lennon. 

The song quite clearly conveys the idea of a man being afraid that his partner might be about to reject him. In reality, such jealous feelings might motivate men to engage in jealous behavior to ensure that their female partners are sexually faithful. Jealousy might manifest itself as mate retention behavior which may be displayed in two ways.

Firstly, there is cost-inflicting mate retention behavior, such as limiting a partner’s movements, taking up all of their time, or making derogatory comments about their partner in the company of other people. 

Cost-inflicting behavior may have the effect of reducing a partner’s feelings of self-worth and ultimately make them feel unable to find an alternative relationship. Alternatively, it may have the effect of making them start to consider the relative benefits of an alternative relationship, and in this way, it may be a risky strategy for a man.

Related: 7 Little Lies Jealousy Whispers in Your Ear

Alternatively, benefit-provisioning mate retention behavior — for example, buying partner gifts or giving them compliments — may have the effect of making their partner feel more satisfied with their current relationship, possibly reducing the likelihood of infidelity or their partner leaving the relationship completely. As such, benefit provisioning behavior is a less risky strategy for a man. 

Mate Value

Quite obviously, male mate retention behavior may be motivated in situations where the likelihood of infidelity is increased, such as when their partner is in the company of other men. However, male mate retention behavior may also be motivated when men are partnered with women who possess greater female mate value, for example being young and physically attractive, which are indications of genetic fitness and reproductive potential, valued by men.

However, it is not only female mate value that might predict male mate retention behavior. Such behavior might also be determined by male mate value also. For example, a male of low mate value (with limited money and resources) may be unable to employ benefit provisioning mate retention strategies, such as buying gifts, and consequently will resort to cost-inflicting strategies in order to prevent his partner from straying.

The extent to which it is female or male mate value that determines mate retention behavior was investigated by Emily Miner, Valerie Starratt, and Todd Shackleford (Miner, Starratt, & Shackleford, 2009). The researchers employed female participants who completed the Trait-Specific Dependence Inventory (TSDI), which analyses mate value in terms of the ease with which people think they can find an alternative partner equal to or better than their current partner on characteristics such as physical attractiveness, generosity, and ambition. 

Participants were asked to compare certain characteristics of their current partner with alternatives. For example, “If you and your current partner broke up, how difficult would it be for you to find another partner who is as (physically attractive/generous/ambitious)?” They also included another version of the TDSI to assess female participants’ assessments of their own mate value: “If you and your current partner broke up, how difficult would it be for him to find another partner who is (physically attractive/generous/ambitious) as you?”

The participants then completed the Mate Retention Inventory which assessed how often female participants reported that their partners engaged in cost-inflicting strategies:

  • Direct guarding (“did not take me to a party where other men would be present”)
  • Intersexual negative inducements (“pointed out the flaws of other men”)
  • Intrasexual negative inducements (“told other men I was not a nice person”)

And benefit-provisioning strategies:

  • Positive inducements (“bought me an expensive gift”)
  • Public signals of possession (“put his arm around me in front of others”)

Related: 12 Signs Someone Is Secretly Jealous Of You

What Determines Mate Retention Strategy?

Firstly, the researchers found that female judgments of their own and their partner’s mate value to be related, in other words, women who perceived themselves to be of high mate value judged their partners to be of high mate value also.

In terms of whether it was male or female mate value that determined mate retention behavior, they found that higher female mate value to be associated with greater use of male benefit-provisioning mate retention behavior. However, lower female mate value was not associated with male use of cost-inflicting mate retention strategies. The only exception being the association between low female mate value and male direct guarding behavior. Therefore, the female mate value only explains half the story. 

In terms of male mate value, the researchers found that high male mate value to be positively associated with benefit-provisioning mate retention behaviour and low male mate value to be associated with cost-inflicting mate retention behaviour. More specifically low male mate value was associated with male use of direct guarding and intrasexual negative inducements (pointing out the faults of other men). Therefore, it would seem that male mate value more than female mate value is the factor that determines male mate retention behaviour.

Indeed, when the researchers compared men’s or women’s mate value, in determining mate retention behavior, they found that it is men’s more than women’s mate value which more strongly determines both benefit-provisioning and cost-inflicting mate retention behavior. More specifically, men’s but not women’s mate value predicts the use of direct guarding and public signals of possession. 

The only exception was that it was women’s but not men’s mate value that predicted male use of positive inducements. The researchers explain this by saying that positive inducements are directly connected to a man’s appreciation of his partner’s attractiveness, which is one of the main attributes of female mate value.

Overall then, male mate value more than female mate value seems to determine the type of mate retention behaviour, with males of higher mate value performing more benefit-provisioning behaviour and males of lower mate value performing more cost-inflicting mate retention behaviour. 

Related: How To Stop Being Jealous

It is worth noting that in this study the researchers used only female reports of mate value of both themselves and their partners. Nevertheless, the finding is consistent with previous research on partner violence which has found that men of lower socioeconomic status or in low-status jobs and thus of lower mate value engage in more domestic violence than men of higher socioeconomic status or those in higher status jobs. 

The finding could be linked to an additional factor such as male feelings of self-worth, but either way, it is concerning. 

References:

Miner, E., Starratt, V. G. & Shackleford, T. K., (2009). ‘It’s Not All about Her: Men’s Mate Value and Mate Retention’. Personality and Individual Differences, 47 (3), 214-218.

Written By Martin Graff
Originally Published In Psychology Today
Determines Jealous Protective Behaviour In Men pin
What Determines Jealous Protective Behavior In Men

— Share —

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply



Up Next

“Why Do Men Never Express Emotions”? A Closer Look At Men’s Mental Health

Men's Mental Health: Where Are We At

Men’s mental health concerns are hardly brought out in the open. How often do you see men expressing their mental health struggles? Comparatively, men seek much less mental health treatment than women do.

If you look inside your family, you won’t spot a single male member who has ever expressed their emotions. Instead, you will find most males always maintaining a stoic posture, abiding by the general law of “ Manning- Up.”

In fact, men have been socially conditioned to make their mental health struggles seem invisible. Do men hide their



Up Next

Hermeneutic Labor: This Term Describes When You’re Struggling To Make Sense Of A Man’s Thoughts

Clear Stages Of Hermeneutic Labor: Emotional Work

Whether it means picking up hints in a text message or interpreting what isn’t said during an argument – many women find themselves doing “hermeneutic labor.”

Amid the confusing roads of romance, trying to understand secret messages or get through emotional minefields can seem like a full-time job. In recent years there has been an eruption of discourse surrounding feminists and emotional labor.

Let’s understand what hermeneutic labor really means and why most women ​take up emotional labor in relationships​!

Understanding Hermeneutic Labor



Up Next

8 Unmistakable Signs He Will Never Come Back: The Final Farewell

Glaring Signs He Will Never Come Back: No Second Chances

Ah, the bittersweet realm of love and heartbreak. We’ve all been there, hanging onto that tiny edge of hope that things might get better again, and we don’t have to go our separate ways. But let’s face it, sometimes it’s just not meant to be. Today, we are going to talk about the signs he will never come back. Yes, it’s going to get a bit heavy today.

If you are wondering whether he is ever going to make a grand return to your life or not, then let me tell you – you are in for some tough love, my friend. In this article, we are going to explore eight glaring signs that are repeatedly telling you that your ex is not coming back.

It’s time to face the reality and discover if it’s time for you to leave the past behind you and look forward to a better and brighter future.



Up Next

9 Tactics To Trigger The Hero Instinct In A Man

Hero Instinct In A Man: Ways To Trigger Their Inner Hero

Do you know there’s a hero instinct in every man? If you want to unlock that side of your man then you have come to the right place. Today, we are going to talk about how to trigger the hero instinct in a man, and do it the right way.

From understanding their innate drive to protect and provide, to unraveling the mysteries of their emotional landscape, we will explore what is the hero instinct, and what does hero instinct in relationships look like.

So, ready to know more about this side to men? Let’s go then.

Related: How To Make Your Man Happy: 25+ Last Minute Gift Ideas For Him



Up Next

Men’s First Love Theory: 7 Life-long Psychological Impacts Of First Love

Men’s First Love Theory: First Love Psychological Impacts

Can men never get over their first love? Men’s First Love Theory has blown up all over the internet, especially on TikTok. The theory’s first taste of romance sets every partner at an inevitable disadvantage.

When we fall in love for the initial time, this theory claims that it leaves a lasting impact. We tend to think and view our first love as “the one,” causing us to compare every individual we meet after them to our original partner.

The term “first love syndrome” explains how our initial encounters with emotion factor into what we consider to be true love. It’s almost like we’re biologically hardwired to search for that same feeling we had when we fell in love for the very first time.



Up Next

Masculinity And Mental Health: 12 Warning Signs of Depression In Men And What To Do

Signs of Depression in Men You Shouldn't Ignore

Do you often feel frustrated, irritable, and withdrawn? If you are a man and if you are frequently in a bad mood, then it’s likely that you have male depression. The shadows of masculinity can often hide the signs of depression in men.

Male mental health is a topic we rarely talk about as a society that is supposed to be fair and equal. Yet, societal expectations often silence the cries for help from men who suffer from depression. 

But let’s change that today! Depression affects millions of people worldwide, regardless of gender. However, men often face unique challenges when it comes to recognizing and addressing



Up Next

8 Body Flaws Men Find Irresistibly Attractive In Women

Body Flaws Men Find Irresistibly Attractive In Women

Today we are going to explore a topic that’s not just interesting, but honestly, a bit heart warming too! We are going to talk about the “imperfections” and “body flaws” which women feel awkward about, but men absolutely love!

You know what I mean; the tiny body flaws that we are convinced make us less attractive. As women, we often regard them as shortcomings or things that take away from our beauty, but they are the very things that many men fall in love with.

So, let us plunge into this and find out what are those “body flaws” that men really adore about us, and what men think about women’s bodies.