5 Dysfunctional Conversation Types When Delivering Bad News

 / 

Dysfunctional Conversation Delivering Bad News

Have you ever let emotion get the best of you in a difficult conversation?

How to remain calm.

One of the greatest challenges as a manager is delivering bad news. For many managers — especially first time, or novice managers — the experience of delivering bad news, during a layoff conversation or even a negative performance review — can be surprisingly emotional. People can feel sympathy for the victim.

They can feel confused or even frustrated or angry about the fact that they have to deliver the message in the first place, especially if it’s a message that they didn’t necessarily endorse in the first place. And they can feel nervous — sometimes exceedingly nervous — about doing something that they know is going to cause pain and discomfort to another human being.

Along with my colleague Joshua Margolis, I have studied these conversations for many years, and one thing we discovered in this work is that when managers fail to keep their emotions in check when delivering bad news, they can fall prey to five different dysfunctional conversation types.

1. Dysfunctional Conversation #1: Bargaining

This is when you allow the conversation to become a negotiation when it really can’t be one. When employees receive negative news, it’s the most natural thing in the world to engage in what one manager in our research study called the “but why?” conversation — — “But why do you have to do this?”… “But why is this necessary?”…

“But why does it have to be me?”. But assuming this truly is a message you have to deliver, you can’t as a manager fall into this trap of the “but why” conversation. You certainly can — and should be — compassionate with your delivery, but you cannot stray from your message.

Read 7 Ways To Tackle Difficult Conversations

2. Dysfunctional Conversation #2: Cushioning

You’ve probably seen or heard of an example of someone breaking up with a girlfriend or boyfriend and being so indirect and obtuse about the message that the person in question doesn’t actually even understand they’re being dumped!

That’s cushioning: where, as a person delivering a negative message, you soften the blow, but in doing so, you actually end up confusing the other person since they have no idea what you’re saying. You’d think this might be uncommon in the corporate world, but it’s not. In one organization we studied managers were told to mention termination within the first 10 seconds of the meeting in order to guard against this exact dysfunctional conversation type.

Read 7 Conversation Hacks That Will Help You Hit It Off With Anyone

3. Dysfunctional Conversation #3: Unloading

With unloading, the person delivering the message simply can’t control his or her feelings. And they unload: they deliver the message in a hurried, panicked way — freeing themselves of the emotional burden they had been carrying and unloading it onto the victim. And as you can imagine, the message delivered is often less than dignifying and interpersonally sensitive.

Read 3 Tips To Create Conversations That Are Worth Having In Your Workplace

4. Dysfunctional Conversation #4: Arguing

Sometimes people receiving negative news feel it’s unfair. They want to fight back and argue. And as a person delivering the message, you can’t let this happen. You need to control yourself in a way that diffuses a potential conflict instead of fueling the fire.

For example, one company we worked with told managers to: (a) listen, (b) allow employees to vent, but then to restate their message again, clearly and succinctly. It can feel impersonal, but such a method avoids arguing and enables you to actually deliver the message you were intending to.

Read 11 Conversation Killers To Avoid At All Costs

5. Dysfunctional Conversation #5: Mechanizing

Finally, the fifth and final dysfunctional conversational type is mechanizing — again, you let emotion get the best of you, but instead of arguing, you detach.

You distance. You go “robotic,” delivering the message in a stilted, awkward style that, just like the other dysfunctional conversation types is hardly dignifying, albeit for different reasons.

None of us wants to fail at delivering bad news. But unless we learn to control our emotions and recognize these dysfunctional conversation types, it’s unlikely we’ll be able to treat the recipients of our messages with the dignity they deserve.

Have you ever let emotion get the best of you in a difficult conversation?


Written by: Andy Molinsky 
Originally appeared on: Thrive Global
Republished with permission.
Dysfunctional Conversation Delivering Bad News pin
`

— Share —

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply



Up Next

Brunch Quiz: Build A Brunch Order And We Will Reveal What Your Personality Is Like

Fun Brunch Quiz: What Your Ideal Brunch Order Says About You

Are you tired of those serious personality quizzes that always claim that they know you better than you know yourself? Well, I have a got a fresh twist for you that’s as delicious as a stack of fluffy pancakes dripping with maple syrup! I have got a Brunch Quiz for you today!

This Brunch Quiz is the ultimate way for you to uncover your true personality, and also while you are scrolling through delicious foods and choosing your favorites. Sounds like a dream, doesn’t it?

Imagine you are sitting in your favorite cafe and looking at the menu and thinking about what to get. Little do you know that your brunch order holds the key to unlocking the mysteries of your inner self.

Related:



Up Next

Find Out What Your Favorite ‘Family Guy’ Character Says About You!

Favorite Family Guy Character Quiz: Reveal Your True Self

Do you relate to Peter, Stewie, Meg, or Brian? Take this fun quiz to find out what your favorite Family Guy character says about your personality.

Family Guy has kept audiences laughing for over 20 years with its irreverent humor and colorful cast. From Peter’s ridiculous exploits to Stewie’s brilliant plans, each of these characters brings something different to the table.

Therefore, let us get right into it and find out what your favorite Family Guy character reveals about you!

8 Favorite Family Guy Character Quiz: Reveal Your True Self

1.



Up Next

Dream Of Being Pregnant? 13 Hidden Things Your Subconscious Is Trying to Tell You!

Dream Of Being Pregnant? Hidden Pregnancy Dreams Meanings

Most people experience dreams about falling, flying or teeth falling out at some point. But have you ever had a dream of being pregnant? This kind of dream is special; it has a lot to say about what’s going on in your life. So, let’s explore more about this.

Dreaming has its own language that speaks to us and often unveils hidden thoughts, desires, and anxieties deep within our minds.

According to Lauri Loewenberg, a dream analyst, “Pregnancy dreams could mean there’s something in your life that is currently in the works.”

These dreams may mean something even if you are a parent or never conceived before. We will be scrutinizing your subconsciousness for 13 different



Up Next

Can You Find The 3 Hidden Words In This Vision Challenge Within 9 Seconds? Fun IQ Test

Fun Vision Challenge: Find The Hidden Words In Seconds

Attention puzzle enthusiasts and avid word hunters! We are back with another fun optical illusion with answers. This time it’s a vision challenge where you have to find the three words hidden in the picture.

But there’s a catch – you have to spot the hidden words in 9 seconds only! If you are able to do that, then congratulations, you have a powerful IQ, I must say. So, are you ready to take this vision IQ test? Let’s go then! But first, let’s talk a bit about optical illusions.

Related: Center Optical Illusion Test: The Color You See Reveals What Kind Of Genius You Are



Up Next

15+ Quotes From “Bridgerton” That Depict Obsessive Yearning

Best Bridgerton Quotes About Love And Romance

If you like romances and things from the Regency era, these Bridgerton quotes show how obsession can be a form of longing. This Netflix series features several love stories in which the characters experience intense desire and emotions.

Through eloquent dialogues and passionate interactions, “Bridgerton” powerfully reveals the aspirations that motivate its characters.

The series effectively frames the relationship between Daphne and Simon as an embodiment of smouldering attraction while at the same time conveying other major figures’ secretly yearning for each other.

Here are some Bridgerton quotes about love that perfectly sum up obsessive yearning.<



Up Next

Are You Seeing Pink Flags In A Relationship? 9 Signs You Shouldn’t Overlook It

What Are Pink Flags In A Relationship? Warning Signs

In relationships, we usually look out for red flags – those big signs that something is seriously wrong. But what about the less obvious ones? Let’s talk about what are pink flags in a relationship.

These signs don’t scream “danger” but still make you stop and think!

So, What Are Pink Flags In A Relationship?

Consider pink flags in relat



Up Next

4 Mutable Signs In Astrology: The Philosophers Of Duality

The Great Mutable Signs In Astrology: Are You One Of Them?

Did you know that Zodiac signs are classified by modalities or qualities, which describe their character and the stage they represent in a season? Mutable signs of the Zodiac signs are in a group which include Gemini, Virgo, Sagittarius and Pisces.

These signs signify the death of a season or the end of a cycle. For example, Gemini begins as spring is coming to an end; Virgo starts when summer has finished up its business; Sagittarius kicks off just as fall is wrapping itself off — finally! — around everything it can find; and Pisces starts when winter has almost said “uncle” but not quite.

Related: The 12 Zodiac Signs: