The Pain Of Emotional Ambivalence


The Pain Of Emotional Ambivalence

Once, when I was in primary school, I saw a few words scribbled on a desk, in an older student’s handwriting: “I love you, and I hate you.” The sentence impressed me greatly. It had never occurred to me previously that one could love and hate somebody at the same time. I had not yet been introduced to the idea of emotional ambivalence.

I now think it likely that part of the reason the words written in ink on the desk in the classroom made such an impression on me was that I had already experienced emotional ambivalence. I just didn’t know that that was what I felt. The sentence at once illuminated parts of my own emotional life and informed me that I was not alone or different: other people—as evidenced by the author of the sentence—could feel that way too.

I already knew at the time that people—small children, especially—might make conflicting statements about their feelings for someone. A child upset that he or she is not getting his or her way might say to a parent or a sibling, “I hate you.” However, I think I grasped intuitively that such statements are often hollow and inauthentic, an expression of powerlessness and frustration.

Related: How To Let Yourself Feel Your Feelings

When we are very young, we don’t have many ways of securing for ourselves the things we want, and we don’t have the power to make other people give us those things either. We somehow learn that we might get our way if we persuade others that our love for them is conditional—that it depends on whether they do as we like. If they don’t, we say we hate them, hoping to inflict enough pain for them to change their minds.

We all, however, including children, may experience true emotional ambivalence. (Freud went so far as to suggest that all children are deeply ambivalent toward a same-sex parent.) We may have positive and negative feelings for the same object at the same time. What I would like to do here is discuss this phenomenon in more detail, focusing on ambivalent attitudes toward people. Why do we ever feel ambivalent?

Sometimes, people’s characters are complex. We like someone’s sense of humor but not her unreliability, or we appreciate a person’s courage but think he lacks compassion. At other times, however, the source of ambivalence is different: it has to do not so much with the other’s character but with the other’s relationship with us specifically.

Thus, you may love an uncle but have the feeling he has a tendency to compare you to his own son, and you find that off-putting, or you love your sister but think she is too flirty with your spouse or else is trying to “steal your friends.”

Emotional ambivalence is often painful, especially ambivalence of the second sort, having to do with your particular relationship with the other, not with the other’s character.

The Roman poet Catullus, who may have been the first author to document the state that interests me here, noted this pain.

In a poem for his lover, whom he called Lesbia (likely not her real name), Catullus wrote:

“I hate and I love. Why I do this, perhaps you ask.
I know not, but I feel it happening and I am tortured.”

An ambivalent relationship with a loved one may be more painful than a plainly bad one. A bad relationship is like cold weather we know how to prepare for—we may either not go out at all (read: cut contact) or else go prepared, dressed appropriately (that is, we activate our defense mechanisms). An ambivalent one is a bit like weather that changes on you. You cannot possibly know what to do or what to wear. Just as you relax, ready to take in the warmth, a cold wave engulfs you.

Related: 5 Signs Of Unhealthy Attachment In Relationships

For some, emotional ambivalence is so painful, that they don’t like it even in art and opt for fiction that does not require holding contradictory attitudes toward the same fictional character. Sometimes, movie directors purportedly set out to create emotionally complex fiction but do not go all the way.

For instance, the movie American Gangster tells the story of a criminal (Denzel Washington) portrayed so sympathetically that the audience is rooting for him instead of having mixed feelings. Perhaps, this is because director Ridley Scott experienced inner resistance at the idea of true ambivalence or perhaps, he did not trust the audience’s ability to entertain emotional complexities.

Still, for a person with a certain taste, emotional ambivalence in the art can give exquisite aesthetic pleasure, though pleasure mixed with some pain. Hardly anyone enjoys emotional ambivalence in real life, however.

Emotional ambivalence may be difficult to recognize in ourselves. It is an attitude that does not entirely make sense: do we love this person or not? We are not sure. We may reach different conclusions on different occasions.

When other people are ambivalent toward us, we may fail to acknowledge that too. Perhaps, we think that only those who have pure, unadulterated love for us have any love at all. When we detect any hostility, hatred, or envy on the part of the other, we may conclude that expressions of love and friendship are inauthentic and untrue. Or we try to explain away the negativity and persuade ourselves that we are imagining it.

Yet, we know from our own case that there are ambivalent attitudes that involve both love for and hatred of another. If we can have such attitudes toward others, it follows that they can have them toward us (unless we suppose that our own psychology is radically different from that of other people).

Related: Signs of True Love & True Relationships

What should we do about emotional ambivalence and the associated pain?

We may, sometimes, be able to free ourselves of it as when a person ambivalent toward a stepparent as a child comes later in life to see the situation from the parents’ point of view. Now an adult herself, perhaps with her own family, she is aware of the difficulties of being a parent, let alone a stepparent, and comes to sympathize with the people who brought her up. The ambivalence gives way to sympathy, appreciation, and love.

Unfortunately, this is not always possible. But something else, I believe, is: we can learn to accept our own ambivalence, without trying to deny either the positive or the negative feelings. I suspect that one of the main reasons emotional ambivalence can be so painful is that we try and fail to get rid of it.

We attempt to persuade ourselves that we have either only positive or only negative feelings toward someone, but that is simply untrue, and we are proven wrong every time. Things may be easier if, like Walt Whitman, we embraced the idea that we contain multitudes; and that others do, too.

For more essays by Iskra Fileva, check out her column at Psychology Today: 

Written By Iskra Fileva
Originally Appeared On Psychology Today
The Pain Of Emotional Ambivalence pin

— Share —

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Up Next

How To Control Your Emotions And Thrive In Life

How To Control Your Emotions: Foolproof Strategies

Ever felt like your emotions are running the show, leaving you on a rollercoaster ride you didn’t sign up for? If you constantly find yourself swept away by a surge of emotions, then let’s explore how to control your emotions.

Emotions are a natural part of being human, but when they control us instead of the other way around, they can lead to impulsive decisions, strained relationships, and heightened stress levels. 

The good news is that you have the power to regain control and navigate the vast ocean of emotions that lie within you. Today, we will explore how emotions can control us, the importance of understanding and managing them, and practical strategies to help you regain the helm and steer your emotional ship towards calmer waters.

Up Next

“I Don’t Want To Work Anymore!”: 8 Reasons Why You Are Tired Of The Daily Grind

"I Don't Want To Work Anymore!": Reasons Why You Hate Work

Do you constantly say to yourself “I don’t want to work anymore!!”? Hey, we’ve all been there. Staring at our alarm clocks, dreading the sound that signals another long day of work. The thought of dragging yourself out of bed and getting ready to do the same everyday routine can be downright depressing.

In this fast-paced world, it’s no wonder that many of us have reached a breaking point when it comes to the daily grind. But the question is, why do we feel this way? Is it normal to not want to work anymore? What are the reasons for not wanting to go to work?

Well, grab a cup of coffee (or a glass of wine, absolutely no judgment here!), because we’re about to delve into eight relatable reasons why you might be telling yourself “I don’t want to work anymore”.

Up Next

The 10 Best Songs To Wake Up To For A Brighter Morning

Best Songs to Wake Up to That'll Jumpstart Your Day

Looking for the perfect soundtrack to jumpstart your day with positivity? From upbeat melodies to soothing tunes, we’ve got your mornings covered with the best songs to wake up to that energizes and inspires.

Waking up to the sound of blaring alarms often leaves us feeling groggy and disoriented. It can tick you off the wrong way and completely dampen your mood immediately after you wake up. There is no doubt that this can seriously affect the rest of your day as you start your day off in a bad mood.

But, fret not, because I have the perfect solution to kickstart your mornings on a positive note with the best morning playlist. Imagine waking up to the melodious tunes of your favorite songs, gently coaxing you out of

Up Next

From Triggers To Turmoil: What Causes Adjustment Disorder And How To Overcome

What Causes Adjustment Disorder And How To Overcome

Life is a journey filled with ups and downs, and each of us faces numerous challenges along the way. While most people find ways to adapt and cope with these challenges, some individuals may experience significant difficulties in adjusting to life’s stressors. This can lead to a condition known as adjustment disorder. But what causes adjustment disorder?

Today, we will delve into the intricacies of adjustment disorder, exploring what is adjustment disorder, its symptoms, causes, and available treatment for adjustment disorder in adults. So, let’s gain a better understanding of adjustment disorder and how it affects individuals in their daily lives.

What is Adjustment Disorder?

Up Next

When Sleep Becomes Deadly: What Is Microsleep And How To Stay Awake

What Is Microsleep? Tips to Stay Awake

Ever found yourself zoning out for a split second, only to jolt back awake? Curious about what exactly happens during these moments? Let’s explore what is microsleep and how to deal with it!

Most of us have often experienced a momentary lapse of consciousness, where our head begins to nod and your eyelids feel impossibly heavy. It’s that fleeting moment when you feel like you’ve suddenly dozed off, only to snap back to wakefulness, startled and confused. If you’ve ever encountered this bizarre phenomenon, you might have just experienced a microsleep.

In this fast-paced world that demands our attention and productivity, it’s crucial to understand the concept of microsleep, its symptoms, causes, and most importantly, how to deal with it effectively. 

So, let’s delve into this intriguin

Up Next

The Science Of Sleep Talking: What Causes You To Talk In Your Sleep And How To Stop

Nighttime Talking: What Causes You To Talk In Your Sleep?

Has your partner or family member ever told you that you talk in your sleep? Or have you ever woken up to the sound of your own voice, realizing you’ve been talking in your sleep? Sleep talking is a curious, intriguing and puzzling phenomenon. But what causes you to talk in your sleep?

Today, we will delve into the world of sleep talking, exploring the signs of sleep talking, its causes, the spiritual meaning of sleep talking, and delve into effective strategies on how to stop sleep talking. So, let’s dive deep into this nocturnal exploration.

What is Sleep Talking?

Sleep talking, also known as somniloquy, is a fascinating sleep disorder that can range from simple mumbling to full-blown conversations. It i

Up Next

What Is Sound Healing Therapy? How Sound Can Boost Your Mental Health And Improve Your Life

What Is Sound Healing Therapy? Mental Health Benefits

Have you ever wondered about the mysterious ways in which sound can affect our emotions and well-being? From the soothing melodies of a favorite song to the thunderous crash of ocean waves, sound has an incredible ability to move us, to touch our souls. But did you know that sound can also be harnessed for healing purposes? Let’s explore what is sound healing therapy?

Today, we will delve into the fascinating realm of sound healing therapy, exploring its benefits, how it works, and its profound impact on mental health. So, let’s embark on a journey of sound and discover the transformative power it holds.

What is Sound Healing Therapy?

Sound healing therapy is an ancient practice that utilizes the vibratio