Why We Need To Be Curious About Mental Illness

 / 

curious about mental illness

Are you critical of mental illness? Or curious?
Read on to know how an open-minded, non-judgmental attitude can eradicate mental health stigma.

At the outset of my conversation with Lily Cornell Silver for The Hardcore Humanism Podcast, we discussed her work as a mental health advocate and as host of the interview series Mind Wide Open in which she talks with guests about mental illness to shed light on this important issue. And she shared a story of how she was challenged by someone who claimed that she was not a mental health “expert” and, therefore, not qualified to host this type of show.

I felt my blood boiling right away. I did not know who this person was, why they said what they said, or where they were coming from with their opinion. I was simply angry because it violated my sense of what was right in this world. From my perspective, Silver is stepping up and having meaningful and difficult conversations about the tough topic of mental illness to help reduce stigma — end of the story. This is a service to us all and should not be questioned or judged.

We Never Actually Really Meet Other People At All
Why We Need To Be Curious About Mental Illness

Read The Meghan Markle Interview: Are We Still Not Ready To Talk About Mental Health?

Silver on the other hand was much more poised and reflective in her response to this person’s challenge. “I think that’s such an interesting response and something that I come at with curiosity. Because that’s part of the stigma that I want to shed… everyone is allowed to talk about mental health, everyone is allowed to struggle with mental health. And you don’t have to have a degree in order to talk about it,” Silver told me. “Makes me wonder what they’ve experienced or what they’ve been told in their life to come at it from that perspective.”

Well, that was humbling. I’ve been in this field for decades, in theory working towards building an open-minded, empathic approach towards understanding people and their unique perspectives. Turns out I have a lot of work to do. Silver’s reaction was the more enlightened one because in order to combat the stigma of mental illness we need to be curious, not critical.

On a personal level, my path to embracing a curious approach to mental illness started 25 years ago when a supervisor told me that as clinical psychologists, we should strive to be curious about rather than critical of our patients. But embracing a “curious rather than critical” ethos has not been an easy journey for me. Criticizing myself and others was practically a second language.

The Dark Side Of Criticism

I just assumed that’s how the world worked. If we wanted to get anywhere in life or make real changes, it needed to come from a place of criticism. Criticism and the negative feelings that inevitably arose from it were the motivation necessary to fuel progress. Curiosity was something we exhibited at times but in which we didn’t invest much time or energy. I always took to heart that life was 1% inspiration and 99% perspiration. Who needs curiosity?

In retrospect, this perspective feels cringeworthy. I neither did it intentionally nor meant any harm by it. It’s just that harshly evaluating myself and others was how I encoded, understood, and related to the world. I assumed everyone did! And it worked to a degree in some areas. I was terribly judgmental about my academic performance and routinely obsessed about my grades and professional future.

Read Ways To Reduce Stigma Attached To Mental Health

My self-criticism motivated me academically, fueling long nights of studying, often at the expense of my social life. I was horribly critical of my weight and shape, and that at times got me to eat healthier and exercise more.

But overall, this critical approach to life caused more harm than good. There was no joy to it. My life was split into brief moments where I felt relieved that I had met my goals and the rest of the time anxious about addressing the next perceived criticism. And I probably spent more time fretting over rather than working on my life goals – often sitting alone trying to be productive while managing overwhelming and crippling anxiety at the same time.

There was no real coping – just a harsh, shaming self-talk demanding I push forward.
I just felt like a person running fast because someone else had a gun to my head and was telling me to do so. And I often found myself being unkind to people who didn’t deserve to be judged harshly because I was so anxious and irritable, harming my relationships. I was miserable – trapped in an invisible prison of my own making.

Be mindful of your self-talk.
Why We Need To Be Curious About Mental Illness

Also read 13 Characteristics Of A Mentally Healthy Person

The inevitable consequence of my “criticize first, ask questions later” approach to life was emerging mental health issues. Despite being a psychology major and in training to be a clinical psychologist, when I started graduate school at the age of 22, I was terrified at the mere mention of not being 100% mentally healthy. Therapy was this distant academic concept.

In fact, I saw the world as those who were mentally healthy and those who needed help. And as an aspiring mental health expert, I was convinced that I needed to be one of the healthy ones – even if it meant ignoring some rather obvious counter-evidence. So, the more I ignored, avoided or suppressed what I was feeling to keep moving forward, the worse things got.

Predictably, this approach to my life soon blew up in my face. My unrelenting anxiety caught up with me and eventually transitioned into a depression where for the first time in my life I was having trouble getting out of bed. I didn’t become curious about what was happening to me because of an evolved epiphany about the benefits of curiosity over criticism.

I became curious because I had no choice. I couldn’t avoid questions that were punching me in the face.

  • Why was I anxious and irritable all of the time and constantly worrying?
  • Was it normal to literally never feel relaxed or fully “in the moment?”
  • Why did I never sleep through the night? Why did I binge eat and drink so often?
  • What made me feel entitled to judge others?

I couldn’t just be critical any longer – I had to be curious to figure out what was wrong with me.

Curiosity Is The Key To Connection

It was then that I sought out therapy and began to see things differently. I started to recognize that almost every negative interaction I had started with either my criticizing myself or someone else criticizing me. A harsh critical mindset means that it is right and wrong, winners and losers, righteous and fallen.

So, even if I won the argument, I still felt like I lost because the world felt so harsh and unsafe. In contrast, almost every interaction that worked out well for me started with curiosity. The reason is that curiosity is the beginning of a connection. It’s the start of a constructive dialogue in which I’m trying to figure myself out or understand someone else.

How Everyone Stigmatizes People Suffering From Mental Illnesses:
Why We Need To Be Curious About Mental Illness

Maybe it was a new activity I’d never seen that I was open to trying. Maybe it was my wondering why I was anxious about something and following that train of thought to an effective coping strategy. It is limitless in its potential. And I found that it was actually more motivating – I felt like I was moving towards something good rather than away from something bad. But where it’s served me the best is in the area of my work – treating people with mental illness.

Be Curious About Mental Illness

I have to keep in mind my supervisor’s lessons and Silver’s example as I try to create open-minded, non-judgmental, and constructive discussions with my patients. To be sure, it’s an ever-evolving effort and an ongoing journey.

mental illness
Why We Need To Be Curious About Mental Illness

And this is what we need to do as a field – mental health practitioners and advocates – and as a society comprised of people who struggle with mental illness, their friends, family, colleagues, and associates. We need to change the conversation from being critical of mental illness and stigmatizing those who suffer into one where we are curious.

We need to make that simple pivot of asking ourselves in a curious rather than critical way – what are we feeling, doing, or thinking? Do we need help? Are there ways that we can explore to cope more effectively? And all of the stakeholders need to come together to make this shift in the culture around mental illness so that people can see mental illness as the beginning of a curious and productive conversation with themselves and others, rather than the beginning of a nightmare of criticism and stigma.

Thanks, Lily Cornell Silver, for your leadership. I’m curious to see how we as a society learn this lesson.


Written by: Michael Friedman, Ph.D
Originally appeared on: Hardcorehumanism.com
Republished with permission
curious about mental illness pin
Why We Need To Be Curious About Mental Illness

— Share —

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply



Up Next

When Therapy Gets Intense: Exploring Negative Transference

Exploring Negative Transference: When Therapy Gets Intense

Have you ever heard of the term “negative transference”? Well, negative transference can turn therapy sessions into an emotional rollercoaster, and make them unexpectedly intense. Does your therapist suddenly feel like an annoying sibling or a strict teacher? Well, maybe that is what is negative transference.

KEY POINTS:

Transference is a psychological experience that originates in childhood and is revived in psychoanalysis.

Melanie Klein’s concept of envy is a major contribution to understanding negative transference.

Devaluing the analysis and showing indifference to the analyst can prevent a working alliance.



Up Next

What Is Irrational Guilt And How Can You Overcome It?

What Is Irrational Guilt And How Can You Overcome It?

There are so many people in this world who suffer from irrational guilt over things that were completely out of their control. It’s a heavy burden to carry and if you are one of them, then know that you are not alone. Living with irrational guilt is heartbreaking, but overcoming irrational guilt is not as impossible as it may seem.

KEY POINTS:

Many people suffer from irrational guilt, blaming themselves for things over which they had no control.

The guilt is based on the conviction that they had the power to control a terrible event or situation.

Self-forgiveness requires giving up illusion of omnipotence.



Up Next

The Zeigarnik Effect: The Reason You Feel Constantly Overwhelmed

The Zeigarnik Effect: Why You Feel Constantly Overwhelmed

Ever wonder why your to-do list seems to weigh you down, even when you haven’t touched it in hours? That’s the Zeigarnik effect in play! It’s the sneaky reason you can’t stop thinking about unfinished tasks and feel constantly overwhelmed. But don’t worry, we will discuss how to overcome Zeigarnik effect.

You know how having too many open Chrome tabs bogs your computer down?

The same happens to your brain.

Unfinished tasks keep “running” in the background.

It’s called the Zeigarnik Effect.

Here’s how it works and what to do about it…



Up Next

Panic Disorder Awareness: How To Recognize The Signs And When To Seek Help?

Panic Disorder Awareness: What To Do When Fear Overwhelms?

Panic disorder awareness is crucial for destigmatizing mental health issues and encouraging those who suffer to seek professional help.

Fear and anxiety are natural responses to certain situations and stressful events. But sometimes, these feelings can become overwhelming and occur without a clear cause or apparent danger. This may then be called a panic attack. When panic attacks become a regular occurrence, it could lead to what’s known as panic disorder.

So, let’s dive into what panic disorder is, how to recognize its signs and symptoms, and explore available panic disorder treatment options. By spreading panic disorder awareness, we can better support those affected and promote mental well-being.



Up Next

5 Mental Health Lessons From Inside Out 2: Helping Kids Understand Difficult Emotions

Powerful Lessons from Inside Out

Disney’s Pixar has captivated audiences once again with mental health lessons from Inside Out 2, a film that not only entertains but also provides insights into our emotional lives. 

While Riley experiences puberty, new emotions in Inside Out 2 join our old friends Joy, Sadness, Anger, Disgust, and Fear. Anxiety, Envy, Embarrassment, and Ennui create different difficulties for Riley and the viewers.

Why ‘New’ Emotions Emerge in the Teen Years?

According to research one of the more difficult emotional changes in adolescence is feeling your feelings very intensely. 

During puberty, changes in your body may lead to irritability, mood swings, and self



Up Next

10 Best Self Love Songs: Your Ultimate Playlist for Boosting Happiness

Best Self Love Songs to Boost Happiness

Feeling down? Need a boost of positivity? There’s nothing like listening to the best self love songs to lift your spirits and remind you of your worth. If you’re a music lover looking to affirm your love for yourself, this playlist of self-love songs is just what you need.

They say self-love is hard to achieve. But as a music lover, I’ve found comfort and inspiration in the melodies. These two traits have guided me toward personal growth and mental peace which are the basics of self-love.

Therefore, I want to share some unique self-love songs for people who are still struggling to love themselves. These songs will definitely refresh your mood and give you a boost of positivity.

10 Best Self Love Songs: Celebrate t



Up Next

15 Ways To Keep Your Child From Developing An Eating Disorder

Eating Disorders: Ways To Protect Your Child From This

Many of us, including our kids, struggle with unhealthy diets and lack of exercise. This worrying trend leads to children developing an eating disorder, leading experts to believe that our current generation may be less healthy than their parents. Let’s find out more about children and eating disorders.

In this culture, unfortunately, many of us eat diets that aren’t very healthy, and we don’t get enough exercise. That’s true for our kids, too. In fact, experts suggest that this is the first generation that’s less healthy than their parents.

Even worse, when you mix our cultural obsession with thinness with emotional immaturity and how disconnected we often are from our own bodies, it’s a perfect storm for eating disorders.

Guess how many kids growing up in the US today develop some kin