The Problem With Playing Hard To Get And The Benefits Of An “In Due Course” Relationship

Written By:

Written By:

The Problem With Playing Hard To Get 1

So you’ve probably heard about the whole playing hard to get thing when it comes to dating, right? But does playing hard to get work? What is the problem with playing hard to get? Let’s dive into why this tactic isn’t as foolproof as it might appear.

Key Points

  • The point of playing hard to get is that if we force our partner to make an effort over time, it will make them want us more.
  • The main problem of playing hard to get is its deceptive and manipulative nature, which prevents us from being who we really are.
  • The “in-due-course” approach is more optimal because it is sincere: It invests more time so that romantic profundity can be developed.

“Easy things are tempting, but only if they are forbidden to others.” — Ovid

“’Hard to get’ tactics are like candy — it’s best at the beginning but then it gets boring and nobody wants it.” — Erika Ettin

Playing hard to get, in which we pretend that we are less interested in someone than we really are, is a common dating tactic. But does it really work?

Here are several statements, picked at random, from women and men on playing hard to get.

Related: Men Don’t Like To Chase Too Much

Women

  • “Men like to hunt. The moment hunting becomes easy, they lose interest. We should play it hard, only hard.”
  • “There are all sorts of stories. I heard about a woman who said: ‘I know this man is going to be my husband,’ and so she had sex with him on the first date and in the end, married him.”
  • “We should go slowly; slowly is always deeper and worthier for both partners.”
  • “The best way is to be yourself, but with some toughness.”
  • “We don’t want to seem like we are SO available that we don’t have anything but time for you. We don’t want to be perceived as clingy. Obviously, there is a point where the game becomes stupid. There is a happy medium.”

Men

  • “We’ve got enough hardship in our life, so women, please be kind to mankind and don’t play hard to get.”
  • “If a girl plays hard to get, she isn’t worth the effort.”
  • “You should take the middle position. Too hard, and I’ll quit; too easy, I’ll be disappointed.”
  • “I don’t think canceling a date at the last minute is part of playing hard to get; that’s just rude.”
  • “Some ladies who play hard to get will eventually pray hard to get a husband.”

The main criticism: A deceptive, manipulative game

Playing hard to get can create various problems, such as the necessity of deception and manipulation, a lack of reciprocity, playing superficial games in serious matters, attracting the wrong kind of people, and increasing insecurity and uncertainty in the relationship.

I focus here on the main difficulty: the deceptive and manipulative nature of playing hard to get, which prevents us from being what we really are.

Sincerity and openness are indeed essential in romantic relationships. Yet balance and moderation are valuable as well. Complete sincerity and openness are not always beneficial to us.

It makes sense, therefore, that at the beginning of the relationship, our behavior should be quite tactful in order to prevent hurting one another. For example, it is not recommended to describe your entire sexual history in detail, on the first date.

Although both playing hard to get and withholding information about one’s sexual history is a deliberate concealing of information, the two cases are different. When hiding our sexual history, withholding information is done in order to not hurt our date.

When we play hard to get, it does not involve a passive withholding of information, but an active ongoing deception intended to benefit us. In both cases, withholding information may make the other person uncertain about us, but when we play hard to get, the connotation is more negative.

Our partner may naturally interpret our ambivalent behavior towards them as a sign they are being rejected. Accordingly, playing hard to get is more likely to backfire on us.

Playing hard to get

The value of effort over time

“Men love the seemingly unattainable girl. The worst thing you can do is make it easy for them.” — Leandra De Andrade

The point of playing hard to get is obvious: if we force our partner to make an effort over time, it will make them want us more. Generally, the more effort we invest in something, the more significant it becomes, and our emotions toward the object become more intense.

As the saying goes: “the more you pay, the more it is worth.” But the opposite is also true: when the stakes are higher, we invest more effort. The saying “easy come, easy go” refers to situations in which something we have gained without much-invested effort is of lesser significance to us, and hence, we may lose it quite equably (Ben-Ze’ev, 2000).

Peter Jonason and Norman Li (2013) emphasize the importance (for women, more than men) of playing hard to get, in order to manipulate one’s perceived availability. As in other aspects of life, when a product is difficult to obtain, people perceive it to be more valuable than if it is readily available.

Similarly, Gurit Birnbaum and colleagues (2020) claim that people are more attracted to prospective romantic partners who are selectively hard to get (i.e., easy for them to attract but hard for others to attract) than to those who are uniformly easy or hard to get.

They found that perceptions of prospective partners as hard to get not only heightened their mate value and desirability but was also manifested in devoting more concrete efforts to further interaction.

I may add that in being polite, we refrain from revealing our authentic attitude in order not to hurt other people. However, as in the case of concealing our sexual history, it is done not to hurt other people, and not necessarily in order to benefit us.

Related: How To Get A Man To Chase You, Without Playing Games

The “in due course” approach

“I have never played hard to get. Sometimes I can be slow to warm up, but that isn’t an act. I do take some time to be comfortable with people. Playing hard to get implies that I am actually interested, but I pretend that I’m not. That is totally childish.” — A woman, on dating

Being selective is essential for our choice of a long-term partner. A valuable way of demanding our prospective partners to invest effort over time.

Is there a better approach than playing hard to get, that requires making an effort over time but avoids deceptive manipulation? I believe that such a way exists in the “due course” approach.

Both these approaches involve a cooling off in behavior. Yet playing hard to get is the only approach that requires deceptive manipulation.

In the in due course approach, both partners are aware of their genuine romantic attitudes, but decide to invest the required time in developing and enhancing their own feelings.

In both cases, love must be developed and “earned” over time, becoming more meaningful and profound by experiencing a torturous postponement of their authentic sexual desires.

The in-due-course approach is a more serious route. It does not necessarily cast doubt over the lover’s sincerity; rather, it involves investing more time so that romantic profundity can be developed.

The “in-due-course” method constitutes a kind of prolonged courtship. Indeed, marital happiness is positively associated with the length of the courtship period (Byrne & Murnen, 1988).

Concluding remarks

“A busy, vibrant, goal-oriented woman is so much more attractive than a woman who waits around for a man to validate her existence.” — Mandy Hale

Playing hard to get, in order to show that you are not desperate and clingy is indeed useful in many circumstances. However, it is done by deceitfully manipulating your perceived availability.

In contrast, in the more optimal “in due course” attitude, you show your value by genuinely indicating that you do not wish to rush and stumble on the bumpy romantic road. There is no one rigid prescription for an optimal point on the continuum between being easy and hard to get.

Related: Top 10 Things That Turn Men Off even when you are highly attractive

In most circumstances, this behavior consists of a sensitive balance between seemingly opposing factors. Achieving this balance is typically a matter of effort over time, and not merely lucky timing (Ben-Ze’ev, 2019).

References:

Ben-Ze’ev, A. (2019). The arc of love: How our romantic lives change over time. University of Chicago Press.

Ben-Ze'ev, A. (2000). The subtlety of emotions. MIT Press.

Birnbaum, G. E., Zholtack, K., & Reis, H. T. (2020). No pain, no gain: Perceived partner mate value mediates the desire-inducing effect of being hard to get during online and face-to-face encounters. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 37, 2510-2528.‏

Byrne, D. & Murnen, S. K. (1988). Maintaining loving relationships. In R. J. Sternberg and M. L. Barnes (eds.). The psychology of love. Yale University Press, 293-310.

Jonason, P. K., & Li, N. P. (2013). Playing hard–to–get: Manipulating one's perceived availability as a mate. European Journal of Personality, 27, 458-469.

Written By Aaron Ben-Zeév
Originally Appeared On Psychology Today
problem of playing hard to get

— Share —

Published On:

Last updated on:

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

How to Handle Valentine’s Day When You’re In a Situationship

Rules for Surviving Valentine’s Day with a Situationship

Valentine’s Day with a situationship can be a tricky balance to strike. You’re not quite in a full-fledged relationship, but there’s an undeniable connection between you and the other person. This makes the holiday feel like a bit of a gray area — neither here nor there. On one hand, you might feel the urge to celebrate it with gestures of affection, but on the other hand, you don’t want to overstep boundaries or create expectations that aren’t yet there. So, how do you approach Valentine’s Day when things aren’t clearly defined? I’m glad you asked because we are happy to help:

8 Rules for Surviving Valentine’s Day with a Situationship

1. Don’t Assume—Just Ask

Up Next

Unconventional Valentine’s Day Date Ideas: Skip the Dinner, Try These Instead!

Unconventional Date Ideas For Valentine's Day!

If you’re looking for date ideas for Valentine’s Day that go beyond the typical dinner out, you’re in the right place. While a restaurant meal is a classic choice, it often comes with its own set of challenges—long waits, high prices, and rushed service. It’s easy to feel like you’re missing out on the true meaning of the day when you’re focused on logistics instead of enjoying each other’s company.

Luckily, there are plenty of creative alternatives to celebrate in a way that feels special, relaxing, and memorable. Whether you’re staying in or trying something new, these ideas will help you make the most of the day without all the usual stress.

Read More: 11 Valentine’s D

Up Next

Singles’ Survival Guide: How to Have the Best Valentine’s Day Without a Date

Single on Valentine’s Day? Here Are Simple Ways You Can Make the Most of It!

Being single on Valentine’s Day can be a mix of emotions. While being independent has its perks, it’s hard to ignore the endless displays of love all around—flowers, chocolates, and romantic posts flooding social media. It can feel like the whole world is in love except you.

But listen, Valentine’s Day doesn’t have to be a reminder of what’s missing. Instead, it can be a celebration of self-love, friendship, and the things that bring you joy. Whether you spend the day pampering yourself, hanging out with friends, or simply ignoring the hype, remember—you’re not alone in this. And love, in all its forms, is always worth celebrating.

Read More: 9 Reminders

Up Next

This Simple 3-6-9 Rule Could Predict Your Relationship’s Future!

The 3-6-9 Rule: The Relationship Formula You Didn’t Know You Needed!

The 3-6-9 rule is your secret weapon in the dating game. It’s a simple way to tell if your relationship has the potential to be something real or if you’re about to get played. Curious? Well, buckle up because we’re about to spill the tea!

Ever had one of those moments where you meet someone online, start texting non-stop, and you’re all “This could be it!”? You gush to your friends over brunch, your excitement practically spilling over your mimosa. He’s sweet, he’s thoughtful, he’s saying all the right things – it feels like you’ve found your perfect match.

Fast forward a few weeks, and… well, let’s just say things aren’t looking as promising. Cue the brunch round two, but this time, you’re venting about how this guy who seemed “so perfect” turned out to be anything but. Been there?

Up Next

What You Should Do If You Were Ghosted

How To Handle Being Ghosted? Simple Ways

If you’ve ventured into the wild world of modern dating, chances are you’ve probably felt the sting of being ghosted. Don’t feel bad, though—you’re definitely not alone. A solid 82% of daters have been left hanging at least once, so it’s practically a rite of passage these days. This spooky trend has become so common that we almost shrug it off, even though deep down, it still stings. So, what should you do when you’re left hanging in the digital abyss? Today we’ll talk about how to handle being ghosted—because you deserve better than to be treated like a forgotten text in someone’s inbox.

How To Handle Being Ghosted

1. Start by acknowledging how you feel

Gett

Up Next

Soft Ghosting Sucks—Here’s How to Take Back Control

How to Handle 'Soft Ghosting': When They're Not Gone But Not Present

You’ve been seeing someone for a while, things are going great, and you’re starting to feel like this could turn into something real. But then, one day, they start pulling away – they start soft ghosting you.

At first, it’s small—maybe they take longer to reply on a random Monday or they seem a little short. You think it’s no big deal, maybe they’re just having a tough day. But soon enough, their replies get shorter, and they start disappearing more often.

They’re too busy for plans, don’t ask about your weekend anymore, and you can’t remember the last time they initiated anything. You decide to give them space, hoping it’s just a phase, but the truth is: you’ve been soft ghosted.

Soft ghosting is when someone slowly fades away without completely cutting you off. They still watch y

Up Next

7 Dreamy Date Ideas Straight Out of Your Favorite Rom-Com!

Romantic Date Ideas Straight Out of Your Favorite Rom-Coms

Valentine’s Day is right around the corner, and we all know what that means—love is in the air, hearts are floating, and the pressure to come up with perfect date ideas is real.

If you’re anything like me, you’ve probably spent countless hours binge-watching romantic comedies (no shame). And guess what? Those iconic movie moments are not just for the big screen. Why not take a page out of your favorite rom-com and turn your date night into something straight out of a movie?

Here is a list of romantic date ideas inspired by our favorite rom-coms.

7 Romantic Date Ideas Straight Out of Your Favorite Rom-Coms