Online Dating Rejection: 4 Possible Explanations For This

Published on:

Online Dating Rejection Possible Explanations 2

Even though online dating is a fun and interesting way of meeting new people, everything has a flip side. With online dating comes online dating rejection. And rejection always hurts, no matter what kind, doesnโ€™t it?




โ€œIโ€™m looking for someone a little older.โ€

โ€œI was trying to find someone who lives closer to me.โ€



Attempting to date someone using a mainstream online dating site can be frustrating if you continue receiving replies similar to theseโ€”or no reply at all. Whatever type of response you get, itโ€™s important not to take things too personally, even though it may be a little tough to get over what might feel like constant rejection. This post examines some of the reasons why online rejection happens.

Here Are 4 Four Possible Explanations for Online Dating Rejection

1. Dating sites are a different environment.

In a face-to-face environment, we generally look for some verbal or nonverbal signals or indications of interest from someone before approaching them. In an online dating environment, such indicators are absent; all we have is maybe a couple of photos and some basic facts about the person we intend to approach.




There is no way to assess whether potential dates are interested other than to message them. Therefore, initial messaging in online dating serves a different function: Itโ€™s a test of interest. The consequence is that because messaging is the only way to test interest, more messages are sent โ€” and ignored โ€” and being constantly rejected may become disheartening.

Related: 6 Guys Women Meet When They Date Online

2. Disinhibition.

People behave in a far less inhibited way online than in face-to-face environments (Suler, 2004). This is known as the online disinhibition effect, and one reason it might occur is the feeling of relative anonymity online. Indeed the effect may be more prevalent in an online dating environment, where people have not met the person with whom they are communicating, compared to social media, where it is likely that people are already known to each other. 

Further, the asynchronous (non-real-time) nature of the communication may foster a feeling of distance between people online. One consequence of this feeling of distance is a lack of empathy between people, perhaps resulting perhaps in a lack of concern for others, which may lead to total disregard when someone replies to a message.

3. Online etiquette.

Ghosting, or breaking off communication with another person without notice, warning, or reason, is increasingly seen as quite normal. Following a brief exchange in online dating, a person may choose to just not reply to a message. While such behavior may initially appear rude or disrespectful, it now seems commonplace in online communication.

There is good evidence that ghosting has become extremely common: A survey from the Plenty of Fish dating site (Maclean, 2016) found that 80 percent of users between the ages of 18 and 33 had experienced ghosting, with many of those who reported having been ghosted likely having ghosted others themselves. 




Some possible reasons for ghosting may include the relative anonymity of people on dating sites and the fleeting, short-term nature of the hook-up culture, which ultimately results in a lack of empathy or concern for others. 

Related: How To Deal With Ghosting: The Dating Worldโ€™s Vanishing Act

4. Decision-making differences.

In terms of mate choice, error management theory (Haselton & Buss, 2000) suggests that the inherent long-term consequences to females of making an error in mate choice are greater than the cost of making an error to a male. Consequently, females have evolved a tendency to perceive male interest cautiously (an under-perception bias), while males have evolved a tendency to perceive female interest as greater than is actually the case (a sexual over-perception bias).

So there are gender differences in what males and females interpret as being sexual interest. Applying this to online dating, the theory predicts that male users of dating sites should show far more sexual interest in females than females will show in males, resulting in more rejection for males than for females. 

The research certainly supports this in terms of which gender is more likely to make contact with another through online dating sites. Hitsch, Hortacsu, and Ariely (2010) found that males viewed more than three times as many dating profiles as females did; males were more likely to make contact with a female after viewing a profile, and males sent over three times more messages than females. 

In terms of responding to messages, Fiore, Taylor, Zhong, Mendelsohn, and Cheshire (2010) found that males replied to more first-contact messages than females (26 percent compared to 16 percent).

Related: Brain Research Shows Rejection and Physical Pain Are Almost Same




We are not suggesting that everyone shows a lack of regard when replying to a message from another via online dating, but if you perceive a reply in such a way, the above may explain why. The important thing is not to give up too easily. Donโ€™t take rejection online in the same way as you may take it in a face-to-face context. Online dating is different and has different rules.

Visit my website and follow me on Twitter @martingraff007 and on YouTube.

References:

Fiore, A. T., Taylor, L. S., Zhong, X., Mendelsohn, G. A., & Cheshire, C. (2010). Whoโ€™s right and who writes: People, profiles, contacts,and replies in online dating. Retrieved from https://www.computer.org/csdl/proceedings/2010/hicss/12OmNy2agR7.
Haselton, M. G. & Buss, D. M. (2000). โ€˜Error management theory: A new perspective on biases in cross-sex mind readingโ€™ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78 (1), 81-91.
Hitsch, G. J., Hortaรงsu, A., & Ariely, D. (2010). What makes you click? Mate preferences in online dating. Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 8, 393โ€“427.
Maclean, K. (2016). โ€˜POF survey reveals 80% of Millennials have been Ghostedโ€™ Retrieved from ; June 2017.
Suler, J. (2004). โ€˜The Online Disinhibition Effectโ€™ย  Cyberpsychology and Behaviour,ย  7 (3), 321-326.

Written By Martin Graff 
Originally Appeared In Psychology Today

Online dating can be a somewhat tricky terrain to navigate, and rejection will always be a possibility. But does that mean, itโ€™s stupid, or you should just give up? Of course not! So many people have found their significant others on online dating platforms. Just donโ€™t give up, and try to understand the differences between online dating and traditional dating. The better you understand this, the better results you will get.

Online Dating Rejection Possible Explanations pin


— Share —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

This Simple 3-6-9 Rule Could Predict Your Relationshipโ€™s Future!

The 3-6-9 Rule: The Relationship Formula You Didnโ€™t Know You Needed!

The 3-6-9 rule is your secret weapon in the dating game. Itโ€™s a simple way to tell if your relationship has the potential to be something real or if youโ€™re about to get played. Curious? Well, buckle up because weโ€™re about to spill the tea!

Ever had one of those moments where you meet someone online, start texting non-stop, and you’re all โ€œThis could be it!โ€? You gush to your friends over brunch, your excitement practically spilling over your mimosa. Heโ€™s sweet, heโ€™s thoughtful, heโ€™s saying all the right things โ€“ it feels like youโ€™ve found your perfect match.

Fast forward a few weeks, and… well, letโ€™s just say things arenโ€™t looking as promising. Cue the brunch round two, but this time, youโ€™re venting about how this guy who seemed โ€œso perfectโ€ turned out to be anything but. Been there?

Up Next

What You Should Do If You Were Ghosted

How To Handle Being Ghosted? Simple Ways

If you’ve ventured into the wild world of modern dating, chances are youโ€™ve probably felt the sting of being ghosted. Donโ€™t feel bad, thoughโ€”you’re definitely not alone. A solid 82% of daters have been left hanging at least once, so itโ€™s practically a rite of passage these days. This spooky trend has become so common that we almost shrug it off, even though deep down, it still stings. So, what should you do when youโ€™re left hanging in the digital abyss? Today we’ll talk about how to handle being ghostedโ€”because you deserve better than to be treated like a forgotten text in someoneโ€™s inbox.

How To Handle Being Ghosted

1. Start by acknowledging how you feel

Gett

Up Next

Soft Ghosting Sucksโ€”Hereโ€™s How to Take Back Control

How to Handle 'Soft Ghosting': When They're Not Gone But Not Present

Youโ€™ve been seeing someone for a while, things are going great, and youโ€™re starting to feel like this could turn into something real. But then, one day, they start pulling away – they start soft ghosting you.

At first, itโ€™s smallโ€”maybe they take longer to reply on a random Monday or they seem a little short. You think itโ€™s no big deal, maybe theyโ€™re just having a tough day. But soon enough, their replies get shorter, and they start disappearing more often.

Theyโ€™re too busy for plans, donโ€™t ask about your weekend anymore, and you canโ€™t remember the last time they initiated anything. You decide to give them space, hoping itโ€™s just a phase, but the truth is: youโ€™ve been soft ghosted.

Soft ghosting is when someone slowly fades away without completely cutting you off. They still watch y

Up Next

7 Dreamy Date Ideas Straight Out of Your Favorite Rom-Com!

Romantic Date Ideas Straight Out of Your Favorite Rom-Coms

Valentineโ€™s Day is right around the corner, and we all know what that meansโ€”love is in the air, hearts are floating, and the pressure to come up with perfect date ideas is real.

If youโ€™re anything like me, youโ€™ve probably spent countless hours binge-watching romantic comedies (no shame). And guess what? Those iconic movie moments are not just for the big screen. Why not take a page out of your favorite rom-com and turn your date night into something straight out of a movie?

Here is a list of romantic date ideas inspired by our favorite rom-coms.

7 Romantic Date Ideas Straight Out of Your Favorite Rom-Coms

Up Next

What Is Nanoship? The New Dating Trend Thatโ€™s Taking Over in 2025

nanoship

In recent years, the world of dating and relationships has been full of new terms and trends, and the latest one making waves is something called a โ€œnanoship.โ€

Where Did the Term โ€˜Nanoshipโ€™ Come From?

The term “nanoship” was officially birthed by Tinder in their 2024 Year in Swipe report, and honestly, itโ€™s both a little genius and a little ridiculous. According to their study, which surveyed 8,000 singles aged 18 to 34 from the UK, USA, Canada, and Australia between March 3 and March 18, 2024, any interactionโ€”no matter how fleetingโ€”can carry meaning. Thatโ€™s how the idea of a “nanoship” was born.

Up Next

โ€˜Mostingโ€™ is the New Ghosting โ€“ And Itโ€™s Even Worse!

Ways to Dodge the โ€˜Mostingโ€™ Trap in Modern Dating

Mosting is the latest dating term to make waves, and itโ€™s basically a toxic blend of ghosting and lovebombing.

Like most modern dating trends that blow up on TikTok, mosting isnโ€™t exactly new โ€“ itโ€™s just finally got a name. Essentially, itโ€™s when someone showers you with compliments, makes you feel like you’re the one, then vanishes without a trace, leaving you confused and wondering why they even bothered. Basically, this new dating trend is ghosting with a twist.

Itโ€™s pretty much like lovebombingโ€™s evil twin. Lovebombing is when someone overwhelms you with affection and gifts early on, talking about soulmates and creating a deep emotional connection. Sounds romantic, right? Well, itโ€™s not, because itโ€™s often a tactic used to manipulate or control.

Mosting takes that intensity, but inst

Up Next

Why Slow Dating Is the Dating Trend You Need to Try

Why Slow Dating Is Dating Trend

When you like someone, you want to meet them in person, see if the phone chemistry translates to real life as well. You want to take your relationship to the next level, which obviously would be hard if all you do is text them. That said, thereโ€™s a silver lining to this slower pace, often called โ€œslow dating.โ€

Slow dating gives you the chance to take your time, actually get to know someone without the pressure. You can skip the awkward first-date jitters and build something real. So, while texting might feel like itโ€™s dragging on, itโ€™s actually laying the foundation for something goodโ€”if youโ€™re patient enough to let it unfold. Now, let’s understand what slow dating really is.

What is Slow Dating?

‘Slow dating’ is exactly what it sounds like: ta