Online Dating Rejection: 4 Possible Explanations For This

Online Dating Rejection Possible Explanations

Even though online dating is a fun and interesting way of meeting new people, everything has a flip side. With online dating comes online dating rejection. And rejection always hurts, no matter what kind, doesn’t it?

“I’m looking for someone a little older.”

“I was trying to find someone who lives closer to me.”

Attempting to date someone using a mainstream online dating site can be frustrating if you continue receiving replies similar to these—or no reply at all. Whatever type of response you get, it’s important not to take things too personally, even though it may be a little tough to get over what might feel like constant rejection. This post examines some of the reasons why online rejection happens.

Here Are 4 Four Possible Explanations for Online Dating Rejection

1. Dating sites are a different environment.

In a face-to-face environment, we generally look for some verbal or nonverbal signals or indications of interest from someone before approaching them. In an online dating environment, such indicators are absent; all we have is maybe a couple of photos and some basic facts about the person we intend to approach.

There is no way to assess whether potential dates are interested other than to message them. Therefore, initial messaging in online dating serves a different function: It’s a test of interest. The consequence is that because messaging is the only way to test interest, more messages are sent — and ignored — and being constantly rejected may become disheartening.

Related: 6 Guys Women Meet When They Date Online

2. Disinhibition.

People behave in a far less inhibited way online than in face-to-face environments (Suler, 2004). This is known as the online disinhibition effect, and one reason it might occur is the feeling of relative anonymity online. Indeed the effect may be more prevalent in an online dating environment, where people have not met the person with whom they are communicating, compared to social media, where it is likely that people are already known to each other. 

Further, the asynchronous (non-real-time) nature of the communication may foster a feeling of distance between people online. One consequence of this feeling of distance is a lack of empathy between people, perhaps resulting perhaps in a lack of concern for others, which may lead to total disregard when someone replies to a message.

3. Online etiquette.

Ghosting, or breaking off communication with another person without notice, warning, or reason, is increasingly seen as quite normal. Following a brief exchange in online dating, a person may choose to just not reply to a message. While such behavior may initially appear rude or disrespectful, it now seems commonplace in online communication.

There is good evidence that ghosting has become extremely common: A survey from the Plenty of Fish dating site (Maclean, 2016) found that 80 percent of users between the ages of 18 and 33 had experienced ghosting, with many of those who reported having been ghosted likely having ghosted others themselves. 

Some possible reasons for ghosting may include the relative anonymity of people on dating sites and the fleeting, short-term nature of the hook-up culture, which ultimately results in a lack of empathy or concern for others. 

Related: How To Deal With Ghosting: The Dating World’s Vanishing Act

4. Decision-making differences.

In terms of mate choice, error management theory (Haselton & Buss, 2000) suggests that the inherent long-term consequences to females of making an error in mate choice are greater than the cost of making an error to a male. Consequently, females have evolved a tendency to perceive male interest cautiously (an under-perception bias), while males have evolved a tendency to perceive female interest as greater than is actually the case (a sexual over-perception bias).

So there are gender differences in what males and females interpret as being sexual interest. Applying this to online dating, the theory predicts that male users of dating sites should show far more sexual interest in females than females will show in males, resulting in more rejection for males than for females. 

The research certainly supports this in terms of which gender is more likely to make contact with another through online dating sites. Hitsch, Hortacsu, and Ariely (2010) found that males viewed more than three times as many dating profiles as females did; males were more likely to make contact with a female after viewing a profile, and males sent over three times more messages than females. 

In terms of responding to messages, Fiore, Taylor, Zhong, Mendelsohn, and Cheshire (2010) found that males replied to more first-contact messages than females (26 percent compared to 16 percent).

Related: Brain Research Shows Rejection and Physical Pain Are Almost Same

We are not suggesting that everyone shows a lack of regard when replying to a message from another via online dating, but if you perceive a reply in such a way, the above may explain why. The important thing is not to give up too easily. Don’t take rejection online in the same way as you may take it in a face-to-face context. Online dating is different and has different rules.

Visit my website and follow me on Twitter @martingraff007 and on YouTube.


Fiore, A. T., Taylor, L. S., Zhong, X., Mendelsohn, G. A., & Cheshire, C. (2010). Who’s right and who writes: People, profiles, contacts,and replies in online dating. Retrieved from
Haselton, M. G. & Buss, D. M. (2000). ‘Error management theory: A new perspective on biases in cross-sex mind reading’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78 (1), 81-91.
Hitsch, G. J., Hortaçsu, A., & Ariely, D. (2010). What makes you click? Mate preferences in online dating. Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 8, 393–427.
Maclean, K. (2016). ‘POF survey reveals 80% of Millennials have been Ghosted’ Retrieved from ; June 2017.
Suler, J. (2004). ‘The Online Disinhibition Effect’  Cyberpsychology and Behaviour,  7 (3), 321-326.

Written By Martin Graff 
Originally Appeared In Psychology Today

Online dating can be a somewhat tricky terrain to navigate, and rejection will always be a possibility. But does that mean, it’s stupid, or you should just give up? Of course not! So many people have found their significant others on online dating platforms. Just don’t give up, and try to understand the differences between online dating and traditional dating. The better you understand this, the better results you will get.

Online Dating Rejection Possible Explanations pin

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

Dating With Low Self Esteem? 6 Tips For Navigating The Dating Scene with Confidence

Dating With Low Self Esteem? Tips For Being More Confident

Ah, the exciting universe of dating! Dating in the modern world can feel like a rollercoaster filled with thrilling emotions and fluttering hearts. But what do you do when you suffer from low self esteem? What does it look like, dating with low self esteem?

Dating with low self esteem can feel as difficult as trying to solve a Rubik’s cube with one hand tied behind your back. Interactions may be marred by negative self-perceptions which can make you doubt your worth and desirability. However, don’t let that scare you, because low self-esteem does not necessarily mean doom.

In this article, we are going to t

Up Next

Qixi Festival: The Intriguing Origins And Traditions Of Chinese Valentine’s Day 

Qixi Festival: Traditions of Chinese Valentine's Day

Love stories have always gripped our hearts, going beyond cultures and decades. In China, there is a special celebration of romance and love known as Qixi Festival- the Chinese Valentine’s Day.

This magical event has a unique place in the hearts of the Chinese people and can be traced back to thousands of years. So let us dive into the story behind Chinese Valentine’s Day and learn more about the Chinese Qixi festival.

Qixi Festival: The Chinese Valentine’s Day

Qixi (Qīxījié) Festival, also known as Chinese Valentine’s Day, is an ancient event celebrated in China on July 7 of every year, as per the lunar calendar. The occasion draws heavily from Chinese mythologies

Up Next

Who’s The Most Playful In Relationships? 3 Zodiac Signs With Golden Retriever Energy

Zodiac Signs With Golden Retriever Energy: Fun Signs

Are there any zodiac signs that have golden retriever energy? You know, the ones who are so outgoing, adventurous and silly. Fire signs are typically the most fun and playful, but some air signs also cut deep because of how naturally caring they are.

When it comes to a golden retriever, you think of them as the type to always wanna jump in a pool or chase after a ball. They’re like the cartoon characters of dogs with their “just happy to be here” personalities and lots of big energy.

In the human world, 3 zodiacs match that energy!

If you’re feeling down, they’ll immediately come over and hang out next to you while giving you those big shiny eyes.

Up Next

If 16 Famous Writers Wrote Valentine’s Day Cards For You

If These Famous Writers Wrote Valentine's Day Cards

Why settle for less when Kim Namjoon said, “It’s a long way from I to U.F–, JKLMN-O-PQRST. I crossed all the letters and I reached you.” Expression of love is perhaps the greatest asset of poetry and what better time to make dad jokes about it than Valentine’s Day!

Cheese is best served with food. However, Valentine’s Day is one exception. Because it’s the one day we go all out to celebrate the love we feel, the love we have, or don’t. Now imagine if your favorite authors took part in this

Up Next

Is He Into You Or Just Being Friendly? 20 Signs He Is Micro Flirting

Clear Signs He Is Micro Flirting With You

Ever ask yourself if that friend of yours is dropping subtle hints or just being their usual friendly self? We’re about to go over some signs he is micro flirting – the little gestures that could be signaling something more.

On TikTok, Gen-Z have shared some trends to spot micro-flirting, for instance, You have a co-worker who’s always quiet around everyone except for you. When it’s just the two of you they can’t stop being chatty, and they use micro-gestures like touching their neck or biting their lip when you’re talking.

Up Next

Love In Reverse: How Contra-Dating Can Rewrite Your Love Story

How Contra Dating Can Help You Find Love: Examples

When it comes to love, many of us have a pattern. We like what’s similar to us—interests, appearances. But what if there was another way? As the word ‘contradict’ suggests, ‘Contra dating’ is a departure from traditional relationship ideals, which could be just what we need to find true love!

‘Contra dating,’ was coined by the creative minds at a dating site called “Plenty of Fish”. It has the potential to reinvent how we look for true love. Because plain old dating is boring anyway.

Explore Contra Dating Meaning And Find Out If You Should Be Trying It.

Up Next

10 Subtle And Beautiful Signs of Being Madly In Love!

Subtle And Beautiful Signs of Being Madly In Love!

There’s a saying that goes, the world is broken into pieces and it’s our job to find them and put them back together again like the pieces of a puzzle.

Love is that colorful puzzle, and figuring out when someone is head over heels and really in love can be like solving it. People have their special ways of showing love, and you don’t always need to hear them say “I’m madly in love with you” to know it’s true.

It’s all about understanding the little signs of being madly in love—how they talk and what they do. In this article, we will explore these signs that tell us when someone is not just saying it, but truly feeling the love. 

So, let’s dive in and discover the sweet language of actions that show a deep and real connection between a guy and a girl.