The Guru Syndrome: Spirituality or Mindless Devotion?

The Guru Syndrome

We’re abounded by complex challenges in our lives, and we often require out-of-the-box solutions to address them. So, we tend to rely on gurus or anyone with a charismatic personality for guidance. And soon we begin to idealize them – this is known as the guru syndrome.

Let’s take a look into how we shouldn’t delve in mindless devotion.

When spirituality turns sour.

Psychology Behind the Guru Syndrome

Many years ago, I attended some meetings of a spiritual group whose ideas interested me. I liked the teacher and author who had started the group. I thought his theories were very clear and intelligent, encompassing a vast range of topics into an integrated whole.

But what I found strange was the attitude of other members of the group. Although the teacher had died many years ago, they worshipped him as an omnipotent god-like being. They believed that he had performed miracles and that he still controlled their lives.

I was also disturbed by their attitude towards me. They disapproved of the fact that I was interested in other approaches. When I mentioned to one member of the group that I also attended a local Buddhist group, he looked at me sternly and said, “Why do you need to go there? This group should be enough for you.”

After a while, the group’s unconditional worship of their leader and their exclusivist attitude made me feel so uneasy that I stopped attending their meetings. This was my first encounter with the guru syndrome.

The guru tradition has been a part of Indian culture since time immemorial. In that context, it is seen as an important way of transmitting spiritual teachings, and a way of supporting aspirants along the spiritual path.

Spiritual development can be a tricky process, with all kinds of pitfalls and dangers, so the guidance of a guru is helpful. According to Indian tradition, the guru can also “transmit” his spiritual radiance to his followers, providing them with spiritual sustenance. In addition, the devotion of the disciple to the guru has an important role. Indian spirituality places a high value on bhakti (devotion) as a way of transcending self-centeredness.

Related: How You Can Protect Yourself From Self-Proclaimed And Fake Narcissism Experts

Gurus In Western Culture

However, when the guru tradition is transplanted into Western culture, it often becomes problematic. (I’m sure it is sometimes problematic in Indian culture too, but probably not to the same extent.) There are countless reports of American or European-based spiritual leaders who have exploited and abused their followers, had promiscuous sex with their female followers, become addicted to alcohol or drugs, and so on.

In fact, there are so many cases of “gurus gone wrong” that it is not easy (at least outside traditional Indian culture) to find examples of “good gurus” who have avoided excess and immorality.

I don’t think this is wholly the fault of gurus themselves. There’s no doubt that some gurus have bad intentions from the beginning. As I explain in my book The Leap, some gurus may be narcissists who are attracted to the power and privilege (and perhaps the money and sex) that guru status brings.

Others may be self-deluded individuals who believe that they are spiritually awakened, when in fact they are psychologically damaged — and who leave a trail of further psychological damage behind them.

But some gurus do seem to start off with good intentions. Perhaps they don’t even intend to become gurus. However. followers gradually gather around them, and eventually they become the center of a “spiritual community.”

And this — the formation of a spiritual community — is usually the stage when things really go awry. Even if they weren’t corrupt to begin with, the gurus become corrupted by the power of their position and the unconditional devotion of their disciples.

The Need To Worship Gurus

Psychology Behind the Guru Syndrome
The Guru Syndrome: Spirituality or Mindless Devotion?

The key to understanding the guru syndrome is the psychological need of disciples. Although many disciples (at least initially) may have a genuine need for spiritual growth, this is usually combined with a much more unhealthy impulse: a regression to a childlike state of unconditional devotion and irresponsibility.

This is a very appealing state to be in. Think of how wonderful it felt as a young child, to believe that your parents were in complete control of the world, and could protect you from everything. There was nothing to worry about; your parents had it all covered. And you worshipped them so devotedly that you unquestioningly accepted everything they said and did.

Guru worship takes worshipers back to that infant state. As long as the disciple is in the care of the guru, all is well in the world. They feel safe and secure, just as children do in the presence of their parents. They give up responsibility for their own lives and pass it on to the guru, just as children do.

Related: The Problem With Faith: 11 Ways Religion Is Destroying Humanity

And the guru is a perfect being, who cannot behave unethically. He can accumulate millions of dollars, own 93 Rolls Royces, have his own armed security team, and regularly humiliate his followers, but they will always find some excuse for this appalling behaviour, in the same way that children will refuse to believe that their parents can do wrong. The disciples will claim that the guru’s abuse and cruelty is a form of “divine play” or a way of testing their followers.

Any initial impulse that the disciples may have felt to spiritually awaken is usually subsumed by this regression. The guru doesn’t lead them to enlightenment, but to infantile narcissism. They may feel a sense of oneness or bliss in the company of the guru, but his isn’t genuine enlightenment.

It’s more akin to the sense of oneness that a baby feels with their mother. In this way, the guru syndrome is a classic case of what Ken Wilber referred to as the ‘pre/trans fallacy’ — the mistaking of transpersonal spiritual states for regressive pre-personal states (or vice-versa).

And for the guru, this mindless devotion usually leads to disaster. Once they are surrounded by hundreds of adoring disciples, they begin to suffer from ego-inflation. They really believe that they are perfect, even that they are divine. They lose their moral compass, believing that the most unethical behaviour is acceptable. In the midst of unlimited power — and sexual temptation — they lose any sense of restraint.

Related: 10 Spiritual Principles to Heal Your Life

Of course, this doesn’t apply to all gurus. Certainly, in the Indian tradition, there have been many examples of gurus — such as Ramana Maharshi and Ramakrishna — who have behaved with integrity, and supported the development of thousands of followers. This also doesn’t mean that there is anything wrong with spiritual teachers per se. It is perfectly possible to be a spiritual teacher without being a guru — that is, without having a community of disciples around you, offering you unconditional devotion.

In fact, the best thing a spiritual teacher can do is to avoid guru worship. And the best thing a spiritual seeker can do is to avoid gurus.

If you liked this, check out my book The Leap: The Psychology of Spiritual Awakening.

Have you witnessed mindless devotion? Share your thoughts on the guru syndrome in the comments below.

Written by: Steve Taylor Ph.D.
Originally appeared on: Psychology Today
Republished with permission
The Guru Syndrome pin

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

Philosophy And Depression: Does Studying Philosophy Make You Depressed?

Is There A Connection Between Philosophy And Depression?

Ever thought about the purpose of life? Or maybe about the nature of reality? If so, you may be curious about the fascinating realm of philosophy. However, most people believe that philosophy and depression are closely related. 

So is it true that studying philosophy makes you depressed? Can being philosophical lead to a state of existential angst and melancholy? 

For centuries, this field of philosophical study has been a source of curiosity and reflection. Whether it’s the deep thoughts of ancient Greek philosophers or contemporary philosophical musings, philosophy has molded our beliefs & understanding of the world around us and how we fit into it.

So today let us find the answer to the age old question – Does studying philosophy make you depressed? 

Up Next

What Does It Mean To Be A Stoic? 19 Common Stoic Personality Traits And Characteristics

What Does It Mean To Be a Stoic? Stoic Personality Traits

Have you ever wondered how some individuals manage to stay calm and composed even in the face of adversity? How do they navigate life’s challenges with a serene sense of inner peace? The answer lies in possessing stoic personality traits. Let’s explore what does it mean to be a stoic and what is a stoic person like.

The philosophy of Stoicism is an ancient school of thought that has endured the test of time and continues to inspire countless individuals today. Let’s understand who is a stoic person, explore stoic personality meaning and what makes a person stoic.

What Does It Mean To Be a Stoic?

Up Next

25+ Lord Krishna Quotes That Will Revolutionize Your Perspective on Life and Love!

Positive Krishna Quotes on Life | Radha Krishna Love Quotes

Discover the timeless wisdom of Lord Krishna quotes, and lessons from the Bhagavad Gita. These insightful teachings have transcended time and culture, offering guidance on life’s most profound questions. 

The Bhagavad Gita, an ancient Hindu scripture, encapsulates Krishna’s dialogues with the warrior Arjuna on the battlefield of Kurukshetra, serving as a doctrine of universal truth.

Translating these verses into English is a delicate task, aiming to convey the depth of spiritual knowledge while retaining the essence of Krishna’s teachings.

Up Next

What Is Antinatalism? The Philosophy of Not Having Children

What Is Antinatalism: Is it Morally Wrong to Procreate?

Are we morally obligated to bring new life into this world? Antinatalism, a philosophical concept gaining traction, argues that we shouldn’t. Let us explore what is antinatalism, its arguments, and its implications for society.

What is antinatalism?

Antinatalism is a philosophical position that holds that it is

Up Next

What Is Fatalism And 10 Reasons Why You Should Let Go Of This Mindset

What Is Fatalism? Ten Reasons To Let Go Of This Mindset

Fatalism has been a topic of debate among philosophers, theologians, and scholars for centuries. While some see it as a comforting belief in the face of uncertainty, others view it as a defeatist attitude that undermines human agency and responsibility. 

Additionally, it can also be a source of frustration and resignation, as it implies that your efforts and intentions are ultimately futile. 

Some scholars have argued that fatalism can be seen as a coping mechanism for dealing with uncertainty and stress,

Up Next

From The Father Of The Atomic Bomb: 30+ Famous J Robert Oppenheimer Quotes And Sayings

J Robert Oppenheimer Quotes: From The Father of Atomic Bomb

When exploring the genius of scientific minds, one name stands out among the stars: J. Robert Oppenheimer. Much like the atomic bomb he pioneered, Oppenheimer quotes are explosive. 

Igniting profound insights and provoking contemplation on the very essence of our existence, J Robert Oppenheimer stands as a true legend in his own right.

Brace yourself for an intellectual supernova as we uncover the gems of wisdom embedded within J Robert Oppenheimer quotes, illuminating the path to scientific enlightenment and the intricate tapestry of human nature. 

Prepare to be captivated by the brilliance that defined an era and discover the extraordinary legacy of Robert Oppenheimer

Up Next

What Is Nihilism Philosophy: Unveiling the Philosophy of Life’s Pointlessness

What Is Nihilism Philosophy: Is Anything Really Worth Doing?

Have you ever questioned the purpose of your existence? Wondered if there is any meaning to life at all? If so, you may have encountered the philosophical concept of existential nihilism. Let us explore this intriguing idea and its implications for individuals and society.

What is nihilism philosophy?

Nihilism is a philosophy that denies the existence of any objective meaning or value in life. Nihilists believe that there is no God, no soul, no free will, and no purpose to existence. They believe that all of our actions are ultimately meaningless, and that there is no point in trying to achieve anything in life.