5 Moments When You Are Most At Risk of Sibling Estrangement

Moments Risk of Sibling Estrangement

International siblings day 2023 is knocking at the door. The Minds Journal Brings to you a special post on sibling estrangement.

Sibling estrangement, just like parental estrangement can be very painful to deal with. Even if you are not particularly close with each other, emotional distance from them is bound to hurt, because you will always have that sibling connection. Let’s find out what causes sibling estrangement, and the main reasons for sibling estrangement.

Key Points:

  • Estrangement often occurs when a sibling’s life changes and he or she must redefine his or her role in the family.
  • To steer clear of a sibling cutoff, being mindful of the risk factors for estrangement can help.
  • Siblings renegotiate their relationship over time.

Certain moments are especially vulnerable for the sibling relationship, as brothers and sisters must renegotiate how they interact with one another over the course of a lifetime.

In fact, estrangement often occurs when a sibling’s life circumstances change and he or she must redefine his or her role in the family.

Here are some of the perilous turning points in sibling relationships.

5 Moments When You Are Most at Risk of Sibling Estrangement

1. Adolescence.

A teenage sibling, individuating and creating his or her own identity, leaves home for college or a job. He or she may challenge parental authority, changing the established sibling relationships and dynamics in the family.

When my older brother left for college, he wanted to leave behind the dysfunction and difficult relationships in our family. While he and I were never particularly close, we did have a sibling connection.

However, at this moment, he chose to leave the past behind him, and our relationship becomes a casualty of his desire to abandon the problems of the family.

Sibling estrangement
Sibling estrangement causes

Related: 30+ Hilarious Siblings Day Memes To Celebrate An Unbreakable Bond

2. Marriage.

A new in‐law joins the family and may want to control how much time the couple will spend with parents and siblings. The new in‐law may have values and beliefs that differ from those of the original family, although such issues aren’t essential to cause strife.

At one possible extreme, a sibling or child marries someone who turns out to be a narcissist. One reader wrote to me about how her new daughter-in-law removed her son from the family:

“It started slowly and in time the spouse has increased with more and more control, brainwashing, and gaslighting on our son. Our narcissistic daughter-in-law seems to have a calculated plan. She has completely changed our son and cut him off from the family. Nothing we do in his and my granddaughters’ lives seems to change this.”

Related: 7 Warning Signs You Have A Toxic Sibling

3. Birth of a baby.

As a sibling focuses on his or her new family, some family members may feel abandoned or betrayed. Often, sibling rivalry continues into adulthood; siblings may even compete with each other through their children.

At its worst, an estrangement occurs, and aunts and uncles may be heartbroken if they don’t have the opportunity to develop a relationship with their nieces and nephews.

Estranged siblings, when denied the role of aunt or uncle, also may find that their children suffer from not having the opportunity to know their cousins.

Indeed, children often are caught in the crossfire of sibling estrangement, with damage extending through generations. When her nieces were young, one woman said, she enjoyed a close relationship with them.

But when her sister cut her off, she lost relations with the entire family. Being deprived of the relationship with her nieces, she said, has been more devastating than the estrangement from her sister.

4. Divorce and marital problems.

The emotional and possible financial responsibilities of helping a divorcing family member—or one whose marriage is in trouble—may overwhelm one sibling, creating disagreements over how to handle the situation or resentment at an unevenly shared burden.

In an especially painful twist, one woman revealed the truth when she learned that her brother-in-law was cheating on her sister.

But the sister, far from confronting her husband, essentially “killed the messenger” by instead terminating her relationship with the sister who had shared the disturbing news.

Related: What Sibling Abuse And Bullying Looks Like

5. Parental illness, death, or inheritance.

Siblings may stage a last-ditch competition for power, love, and family loyalty. Difficult conflicts arise over who will make health care arrangements and payments for an elderly parent; who will pay for long‐term care, and who will inherit treasured family possessions.

Fights over money may become especially vicious as a parent approaches the last stage of life. Divisive topics, such as healthcare decisions and caregiving needs, may reignite old conflicts.

Often, caregiving falls disproportionately on one sibling. Caring for parents as they decline is a relentless, painful vigil that may cause unprecedented strain and stress.

A parent’s death may add to the pressure, rather than relieve it. Unresolved estate issues can entangle estranged siblings, and, in some cases, siblings who have had years of separation suddenly must interact again.

Previously, I identified risk factors for sibling relationships. These include:

  • Family trauma
  • Parental Favoritism
  • Sibling Jealousy
  • Poor Communication Skills
  • Family Values, Judgments, and Choices
  • Political differences
  • Alcoholism addiction and other mental health issues
  • Money
  • Narcissistic families and siblings

Those who hope to steer clear of a sibling cutoff should be mindful of the risk factors for a cutoff, as well as the perilous moments when a sibling relationship is most vulnerable.

Want to know more about being estranged from siblings? Check this video out below!

Estrangement from siblings

To learn more, buy The Sibling Estrangement Journalhttps://www.amazon.com/dp/B0BLLTT6SJ#SalesRank

Written By Fern Schumer Chapman
Originally Appeared On Psychology Today
Moments Risk of Sibling Estrangement pin

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

When Someone You Love Suffers From Borderline Personality Disorder: 10 Ways to Work Through The Guilt You Feel

Borderline Personality Disorder: Ways To Deal With BPD Guilt

Loving someone with borderline personality disorder can feel exhausting sometimes. And then comes the guilt. So what is this connection between borderline personality disorder and the guilt you feel? This article is going to focus on the connection between BPD and guilt, and why you feel the latter.

Your phone rings; you look down and her name appears on your screen. Sadly, you dread clicking over…and then comes the guilt.

Your history with her rushes into your mind as you wait for one more ring. You’re reminded of all the times that you’ve rushed to her side, comforted her, and told her you’d be there for her, while realizing over time that your caring would never be enough to shore up her fragile self-worth.

Up Next

Only Child Syndrome: A Closer Look At The World Of An Only Child

Only Child Syndrome: Exploring An Only Child's World

What is the only child syndrome and how does an only child feel growing up without siblings? This article is going to talk about how it feels being an only child, and what it entails. So, let’s get started, shall we?

There is a stereotype that only children, children without siblings, fail to develop the ordinary social bonds and attachments that children with siblings do. The reality is more nuanced.

It does not follow that children with siblings are automatically more adaptable, more able to share, more able to understand group dynamics, but it is the case that only children didn’t grow up having to deal with

Up Next

8 Under-the-Radar Signs You’re Being The Black Sheep Of The Family

Surprising Habits Of Being The Black Sheep Of The Family

Being the black sheep of the family can be as clear-cut as a polka dot amongst a sea of stripes. It feels like while everyone is a part of a synchronized orchestra, you are marching to your own beat.

It could be anything from your unconventional career choices or vibrant tattoo collection to simply being good at stirring the pot at family reunions, being the black sheep of the family is not all doom and gloom.

Instead, it should be something that you look upon with pride because it shows how unique you really are. All right, let’s explore some of the subtle signs you are being the black sheep of the family.<

Up Next

How To Support Your Partner When They’re Hurt By Your Parents

How To Support Your Partner When Your Parents Hurt Them

Trying to be fair when your partner and parents have an argument can be a tough balancing act to master. Which is why, sometimes validating your partner is necessary. This article is going to talk about how to support your partner, and what’s the best strategy if you’re thinking about how to validate your partner’s feelings.


Troubles with in-laws are common in relationships.

It’s natural to want to keep harmony between your partner and your family member.

It’s important to try to understand why your partner’s emotions make sense and validate them.

Up Next

Child Parentification: The Cause, Signs, and Recovery

Clear Signs Of Child Parentification In Adults

Ever felt like you were the parent instead of the child? That might be child parentification. Let’s explore its causes, signs, and how to recover together.

The term child parentification was coined in 1967 by family systems theorist Salvador Minuchin, who said the phenomenon occurred when parents de facto delegated parenting roles to children.

It can happen when one parent is physically absent or when a dysfunctional family is under stress because a parent cannot perform their parental responsibilities.

Usually, this is due to a phy

Up Next

What Is A Devouring Mother? Overcoming A Narcissistic Mother’s Toxic Grip

What Is A Devouring Mother? Ways To Overcome Toxicity

Do you feel overwhelmed, smothered, or suffocated by all the love and attention your mother gives you? Perhaps you know people who feel trapped in situations where their mother’s love becomes an all-encompassing affair? This phenomenon is referred to as “The Devouring Mother Archetype.” Let’s explore what is a devouring mother and how to deal with the devouring mother archetype.

What is a Devouring Mother?

The Freudian devouring mother describes a controlling, overbearing motherly figure hampering a child’s development and independence. It is marked by possessiveness and narcissism.

As the term is not a literal description, a devouring Mother does not mean a mother who consumes her children ph

Up Next

Women with Daddy Issues: 3 Identifying Signs and Proven Strategies for Healing

Subtle Signs of Women With Daddy Issues and How To Deal

Are you dating a woman who seeks a lot of attention and validation all the time? Do they struggle with poor self-esteem? Is it difficult to form a secure and healthy attachment with her? Then she just might be struggling with daddy issues. Let us understand the psychology of women with daddy issues.

And the best way to do that is to explore what it actually means, identifying the signs of daddy issues in a woman and learning how to deal with daddy issues in a woman. This will enable you to help them heal and nurture a healthier relationship.

Understanding Daddy Issues

The term “da