The Reality Behind the PCOS Diet: Study Challenges Assumptions on Weight Loss and Symptoms Improvement


For years, individuals diagnosed with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) and grappling with weight issues were often advised that shedding pounds through calorie-restrictive PCOS diets could alleviate their symptoms. However, recent research has cast doubt on this long-held belief, suggesting that dieting may not have the desired impact on PCOS symptoms after all.

A study published in Nature Metabolism conducted by researchers at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine delved into the efficacy of calorie-restrictive diets in managing PCOS.

Contrary to previous recommendations, the study found no substantial evidence to support the notion that a restrictive diet significantly improves PCOS symptoms in the long term. Moreover, sustained weight loss through dieting is challenging for individuals with PCOS, as it is for many others.

Weight Loss Due to PCOS Diet. Is It True?

Julie Duffy Dillon, a registered dietitian specializing in PCOS care, emphasized the lack of clarity regarding the link between sustained weight loss and symptom improvement in individuals with PCOS. This ambiguity prompted a reassessment of dietary guidelines by the International PCOS Network, leading to the abandonment of recommendations for caloric restriction in favor of a balanced and healthy dietary approach akin to the Mediterranean diet.

Dr. Helena Teede, an endocrinologist at Monash Health in Australia and lead author of the revised guidelines, highlighted the shift away from blaming individuals for their weight and health conditions. Instead, the focus has shifted towards promoting overall health through balanced dietary compositions.

PCOS is a hormonal disorder affecting millions of women worldwide, characterized by symptoms such as irregular periods, infertility, excessive hair growth, acne, and scalp hair loss. Despite its classification as a reproductive issue, PCOS can also impact metabolic health, including blood sugar levels, blood pressure, and cholesterol. Individuals with PCOS are at a higher risk of developing cardiovascular disease, endometrial cancer, and diabetes.

The complex relationship between PCOS and weight is underscored by bidirectional influences, as elucidated by Dr. Anuja Dokras, director of the Penn Polycystic Ovary Syndrome Center at the University of Pennsylvania. While PCOS predisposes individuals to weight gain, the exacerbation of symptoms with weight gain remains poorly understood.

The 2023 guidelines acknowledge the variability of obesity rates among individuals with PCOS globally and emphasize that not all individuals with obesity have PCOS. While some studies suggest that lifestyle-induced weight loss may improve certain hormonal and metabolic symptoms of PCOS, evidence regarding fertility outcomes remains inconclusive.

Dr. Dokras noted the challenging nature of researching the impact of weight loss on fertility, emphasizing the need for further investigation into optimal weight loss strategies and their effects on reproductive health. Notably, studies on bariatric surgery outcomes among obese women with PCOS have shown promising results, indicating improved menstrual regularity and hormonal balance post-surgery.

However, the prevalence of insulin resistance among women with PCOS poses additional hurdles to weight loss efforts, exacerbating symptoms and complicating treatment approaches. Despite ongoing research into potential therapies such as weight loss drugs like Ozempic, the intricate interplay between PCOS, weight, and metabolic health continues to pose challenges in clinical management.

In conclusion, the evolving understanding of PCOS underscores the importance of tailored, holistic approaches to managing the condition. While the promise of the PCOS diet may have faltered, ongoing research endeavors offer hope for improved outcomes and enhanced quality of life for individuals living with this complex hormonal disorder.

— Share —

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Up Next

British Study Investigates Potential Benefits of Outdoor Swimming on Depression Symptoms

In a pioneering effort, researchers in Britain are launching the first large-scale study to explore the benefits of outdoor swimming in reducing symptoms of depression. This initiative comes amidst a surge in mental health challenges, particularly during the Covid-19 pandemic.

Led by experts from the University of Portsmouth and Sussex Partnership NHS Foundation Trust, the study aims to recruit hundreds of participants across England to evaluate the potential therapeutic effects of open water bathing on mental well-being.

The decision to embark on this research stems from the growing recognition of outdoor swimming as a potential avenue for enhancing overall wellness. Previous studies have suggested a correlation between immersion in natural water environments and improved mental health outcomes.

The init

Up Next

Recognizing Signs of Maternal Burnout and Strategies for Recovery

In today’s fast-paced world, mothers often find themselves juggling multiple responsibilities, leading to increased pressure and stress. Recognizing the signs of maternal burnout and implementing strategies for recovery is crucial for maternal well-being. Jess Harris delves into this important topic, shedding light on the challenges faced by mothers and offering practical tips for coping with burnout.

The pressure to “do it all” can take a toll on mothers’ mental and physical health. Dr. Sheryl Ziegler, psychologist and author of “Mommy Burnout,” emphasizes the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on parental stress levels.

With limited support during lockdowns, parents faced unprecedented challenges, exacerbating feelings of burnout and exhaustion.

According to a survey by Ohio State University, a staggering

Up Next

Researchers Share 5 Strategies to Complete Stress Cycle and Prevent Burnout

In a recent article published by The Conversation, Theresa Larkin and Susan J. Thomas, both associate professors at the University of Wollongong, shed light on the significance of completing the stress cycle to avoid burnout and depression. Chronic stress, they warn, can lead to severe health issues including heart disease, stroke, and diabetes.

The authors delineate the three stages of the stress cycle: perceiving the threat, experiencing the fight-or-flight response driven by stress hormones like adrenaline and cortisol, and finally, achieving relief which signifies the completion of the cycle.

While stress is an inevitable part of life, remaining in the heightened state of fight-or-flight can have detrimental effects on both physical and mental health.

Up Next

New Research Suggests Video Gaming Boosts Recovery from Work Stress

In a surprising turn of events, recent research published in Applied Psychology challenges the conventional wisdom surrounding video gaming, suggesting that it may actually aid in recovery from work-related stress.

The study, conducted by researchers from Istanbul Medipol University and Erasmus University Rotterdam, sheds light on the potential positive outcomes associated with gaming, particularly when coupled with a harmonious passion for the activity.

Despite previous studies often highlighting the negative repercussions of gaming, an increasing body of evidence indicates its potential to improve mood and facilitate relaxation after a long day at work. To delve deeper into this phenomenon, the researchers sought to explore the impact of gaming on employees’ recovery from work stress.

Recruiting partic

Up Next

New Study Suggests Link Between Cat Ownership and Schizophrenia Risk

In a recent study published by researchers from the Queensland Centre for Mental Health Research, an intriguing association has been identified between cat ownership and an increased risk of schizophrenia-related disorders.

The study, which analyzed 17 research papers spanning over four decades and involving 11 countries, sheds light on a potential connection that has long intrigued scientists.

The notion that cat ownership might influence the risk of schizophrenia-related disorders dates back to a 1995 study, which suggested a correlation between exposure to the parasite Toxoplasma gondii, commonly found in cats, and the development of these disorders. However, subsequent research has yielded mixed results, with some studies supporting this hypothesis while others do not.

Up Next

Beware: Overconsumption of Vitamins and Minerals Can Have Serious Health Consequences

Recent findings suggest that while vitamins and minerals are essential for maintaining good health, excessive intake of certain nutrients can lead to adverse effects on the body. Medical experts caution against the overconsumption of vitamins and minerals, emphasizing the potential dangers associated with their misuse.

Dr. Wendolyn Gozansky, a geriatrician and chief quality officer with Kaiser Permanente, highlights the importance of distinguishing between water-soluble and fat-soluble vitamins.

While water-soluble vitamins, such as vitamin C and B vitamins, are easily eliminated from the body, fat-soluble vitamins, like vitamins A and D, can accumulate and cause toxicity if taken in excess.

Overconsumption of Vitamins Can

Up Next

Impact Of Air Pollution: Understand How It Is Linked to Deteriorating Mental Health

In a significant revelation, the Delhi government has informed the National Green Tribunal (NGT) that exposure to air pollution is closely associated with worsening mental health conditions among residents of the national capital. The admission comes amidst growing concerns over the hazardous air quality levels that have plagued Delhi for years

The disclosure was made during a hearing before the NGT, where the Delhi government presented findings linking air pollution to a range of mental health issues. This revelation underscores the urgent need for comprehensive measures to address the dual crisis of air pollution and its impact on public health.

Impact Of Air Pollution On Mental Health

Delhi, one of the most polluted cities globally, g