Balancing Act: The Mental Health Benefits of Limited Smartphone Use for Teens



In a recent study published on December 7, 2023, researchers at Korea’s Hanyang University shed light on the complex relationship between smartphone use and the mental health of adolescents.

Contrary to previous warnings about the perils of extended screen time, the findings suggest that limited smartphone use may actually benefit teenagers’ mental health.

However, the study emphasizes that this positive impact is contingent on a delicate balance, with excessive use potentially leading to a range of mental health issues.

The study, published in the journal PLOS ONE, involved surveying 50,000 Korean youth between 2017 and 2020. Two sets of extensive questionnaires were administered, one focusing on physical and mental health, and the other on smartphone usage.

The researchers analyzed the data, adjusting for factors such as age, sex, and socioeconomic status, to explore the nuanced relationship between smartphone usage and mental health outcomes.

The results revealed a “Goldilocks” scenario – a sweet spot of one to two hours of smartphone use per day. Adolescents falling within this range exhibited a lower risk of depression, suicidal thoughts, sleep issues, stress, and alcohol addiction compared to those who did not use a phone at all. The researchers noted that for social purposes, one to two hours of usage time appeared to be protective against suicide attempts.

Benefits of Limited Smartphone Use

The study suggests that small amounts of smartphone use can have beneficial effects on teens’ mental well-being. Social media engagement for two hours or less per day was linked to a range of positive outcomes.

Teens within this threshold were 30% less likely to experience stress, 27% less likely to have sleep issues, 38% less likely to be depressed, 43% less likely to have suicidal thoughts, and 47% less likely to abuse alcohol compared to those who did not use their phones recreationally.

Even slightly increased use, falling within the two to four hours per day range, continued to show positive effects. Teens in this category were 29% less likely to be stressed, 34% less likely to be depressed, 40% less likely to have suicidal thoughts, and 27% less likely to be addicted to alcohol compared to non-users.

The Dark Side of Excessive Screen Time

While the study highlighted the potential benefits of limited smartphone use, it also underscored the risks associated with excessive screen time.

Adolescents spending more than four hours on their smartphones faced higher rates of mental health problems and substance abuse, with up to a 22% greater risk than moderate users. Issues such as poor mental health, stress, obesity, depression, and suicidal thoughts were more prevalent in teens who engaged in four to six hours or more of daily phone usage.

This aligns with previous research indicating that excessive screen time can be detrimental to mental health. The authors of the study emphasize the importance of understanding this delicate balance, as the positive effects diminish once smartphone usage crosses the four-hour threshold.

As the average American adult spends over four-and-a-half hours on their phones daily in 2023, these findings have significant implications for both adolescents and adults. Recognizing the potential impact on mental health, the study encourages individuals to be mindful of their smartphone usage.

Teens who fail to establish healthy boundaries with their devices may face similar mental health challenges in adulthood. Moreover, as smartphone use continues to evolve, it becomes crucial for parents, educators, and health professionals to navigate the fine line between the benefits and risks associated with screen time.

In conclusion, the study provides valuable insights into the nuanced relationship between smartphone use and mental health among teenagers. While moderate use may offer benefits, excessive screen time poses potential risks, emphasizing the importance of finding a balanced approach to smartphone use in the digital age.


— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

Man’s Death from Vitamin D Overdose Sparks Warning About Supplement Risks

A tragic incident has reignited concerns about the risks associated with vitamin D overdose, as experts warn of the dangers of overdose following the death of an 89-year-old man in suburban London, England.

David Mitchener’s demise has prompted local medical professionals to sound the alarm, cautioning the public about the potential hazards of consuming excessive amounts of the common supplement. Mitchener had been taking high levels of vitamin D for nine months leading up to his passing.

Coroner Jonathan Stevens expressed concern over the lack of explicit warnings regarding the specific risks and side effects associated with vitamin D supplementation. In his official report, Stevens highlighted the absence of adequate labeling on the packaging, emphasizing the need for action to prevent future fatalities.


Up Next

Exercise for Depression Shown as Effective as Medication and Therapy, Study Reveals

In a groundbreaking revelation, a new systematic review and meta-analysis suggest that physical exercise can yield similar benefits for depression as psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy.

The study, led by Michael Noetel, PhD, a senior lecturer in the School of Psychology at the University of Queensland, Australia, scrutinized 218 randomized controlled trials involving 14,170 participants diagnosed with depression.

The research team conducted a meticulous multilevel meta-analysis, comparing various forms of exercise with common treatments for depression. These exercises included walking or jogging, yoga, strengt

Up Next

Startup Success Takes a Toll on Mental Health Of Founders: Insights from Industry Leaders

The entrepreneurial journey, often glamorized for its innovation and success stories, comes with a hidden cost – founder fatigue and crippling stress. Recent revelations about Nithin Kamath, co-founder of Zerodha, suffering a mild stroke, have triggered reflections among founders on their mental and physical well-being.

Many entrepreneurs have shared their experiences dealing with high-pressure situations and the personal toll of navigating the rollercoaster ride that is entrepreneurship.

Mayank Kumar, managing director and co-founder of the edtech unicorn UpGrad, candidly shared his struggles with stress-related health issues. He recounted moments of intense stress leading to frequent hea

Up Next

The Hidden Mental Health Impact of Cultural Food Insecurity in the United States

In a nation known for its culinary diversity, the absence of culturally appropriate foods has a profound impact on mental health and well-being, a recent study reveals.

Carlos Colindres, a Honduran immigrant residing in Fairfax, Virginia, vividly recalls the frustration of transitioning from the familiar flavors of his childhood to the unfamiliar fare of his new home in Maryland. Despite witnessing an increase in accessibility to Honduran staples over the years, Colindres still longed for the taste of home that remained elusive.

His experience is not unique. Immigrants, refugees, Native Americans, and people of color across the U.S. are grappling with the challenge of obtaining culturally relevant foods. This struggle is exacerbated by rising levels of food insecurity, which heightens the mental health toll of the issue.

Up Next

Rita Ora Opens Up About Battle with Anxiety and Shares Coping Tactics

In a revealing discussion on the Brave New World podcast, British singer-songwriter Rita Ora opened up about her ongoing battle with anxiety disorder and shared helpful tactics to manage panic attacks.

Delving into the intricacies of her mental health journey, Ora spoke candidly about her experiences and the methods she employs for recognition and recovery.

During her conversation with Evgeny Lebedev, Ora spoke openly about the prevalence of anxiety within the entertainment industry, acknowledging that anxiety is a common struggle for individuals in her line of work.

Up Next

Unveiling the Impact of Microstress on Mental Health: Strategies for Coping

In today’s fast-paced world, feelings of exhaustion, burnout, and emotional depletion are all too common. While it’s tempting to attribute these sentiments solely to workload and external pressures, recent research suggests a more nuanced culprit: microstress. These seemingly minor stressors, accumulated from routine interactions, often fly under the radar but can collectively take a significant toll on mental well-being.

A study conducted by experts Rob Cross, Karen Dillon, and Kevin Martin sheds light on the concept of microstress, detailing its insidious nature and exploring potential coping mechanisms. Published in February 2024, their research challenges conventional wisdom surrounding workplace stressors and offers practical insights into managing microstress in professional and personal spheres.

Up Next

Rising Antidepressant Prescriptions Among Youth Prompt Concerns Amid Mental Health Challenges

In a concerning trend, a recent study published by the American Academy of Pediatrics sheds light on a sharp increase in antidepressant prescriptions among youth and adolescents. The study, spanning from 2016 to 2022, reported a staggering 66.3% rise in monthly antidepressant dispensing rates. Notably, this surge accelerated post-March 2020, coinciding with the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The research revealed that antidepressant prescriptions for female teens ages 12–17 and young adults ages 18–25 surged by 129.6% and 56.