Girlfriend Wants Him To Cut Off A Friend Over Past Crush! Is It Fair Or Too Extreme?


Unexpected: Man's Girlfriend Wants Him To Cut Off A Friend

A Man faces a dilemma as his girlfriend wants him to cut off a friend who had a crush on him when he saw him for the first time. This man sought advice from Reddit after getting into a fight with his girlfriend.

He enquired on the Reddit community r/AmITheA-hole whether his response to his girlfriend’s demand was appropriate or whether she had crossed the reasonable boundary. 

Reddit post of the man whose girlfriend wants him to cut off a friend.

Girlfriend Believes It Is A Reasonable Boundary

In the midst of an advice-seeking post, a 25-year-old man revealed that he and his girlfriend, Lizzie, also 25, recently spent time with his longtime college best friend, Jack, aged 26. Notably, the man mentioned that Jack identifies as gay.

Their friendship has spanned approximately seven years, starting from their first year at university, while the man’s relationship with Lizzie has lasted for nine months.

During a casual gathering at Jack’s apartment, the trio engaged in conversation about past romantic experiences from their college days. Lizzie inquired if Jack had ever harbored feelings for the man. Jack responded playfully with a smile, saying, “Well, who wouldn’t?”

As per the man’s account, Lizzie persisted in the topic, in a light-hearted manner. He sensed Jack becoming slightly uncomfortable, but Jack eventually revealed that he indeed had a crush on the man when they initially met, a fact the man himself was unaware of.

In response, the man made a casual remark about it being a shame that he was straight because they would have made a cute couple. Jack laughed and agreed, stating that he thought the man and Lizzie made an even cuter couple. The conversation swiftly moved on from there.

At the time, Lizzie didn’t display any signs of distress. According to the man, she responded by calling the situation “sweet.”

Girlfriend Wants Him To Cut Off A Friend, Controlling Behavior In A Relationship

In the aftermath of their evening, upon returning home, the man was informed that his girlfriend wants him to cut off a friend Jack due to Jack’s past romantic interest in him when they first met.

According to the man, Lizzie expressed her discomfort with him being friends with someone who had previously been attracted to him, believing it to be a reasonable boundary in their relationship and she is not showing controlling behavior in a relationship. Lizzie just wanted him to cut off a friend for the sake of their relationship.

Read more here: How To Deal With An Overly Controlling Partner

Feeling taken aback, the man countered by highlighting that Jack’s past crush from their 18-year-old selves did not imply any current romantic interest or inappropriate behavior. He defended their friendship, emphasizing that Jack was a close friend who had done nothing wrong.

Lizzie became upset and argued that severing ties with Jack was a basic expectation in a relationship, where prioritizing one’s partner over friends who had expressed attraction was customary.

Man's Girlfriend wants him to unfriend his friend who once had a crush on him.

Describing the subsequent circular conversation, the man recounted Lizzie discussing boundary issues in a relationship while he insisted that her reasoning lacked coherence.

Eventually, Lizzie proposed a compromise wherein he would never spend time alone with Jack but could still maintain their friendship.

However, the man refused, asserting that there was no need for supervision or chaperoning in their interactions. Lizzie retired to bed, expressing her disappointment that he prioritized Jack over her.

Read more here: Denial Of Bad Behavior: What You Can Do

The following morning, Lizzie left for work before the man woke up, which was a usual routine. As of now, they have not had a chance to speak about the matter.

Reflecting on Lizzie’s uncharacteristic behavior, the man questioned whether he might be the one displaying unreasonableness, considering Lizzie had never exhibited signs of jealousy before and she knows her reasonable boundary.

Boundary issues in a relationship

— Share —

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Up Next

Companies Exploring Psychedelic Drug Therapy Coverage for Employees, Citing Mental Health Benefits

A recent report highlights a growing trend among companies to consider offering psychedelic drug therapy coverage for their employees as a cost-effective and potentially impactful solution for mental health treatment.

This emerging approach is fueled by recent research indicating the therapeutic potential of substances like MDMA, psilocybin, and ketamine in addressing various mental health issues, including depression, anxiety, and PTSD

Jorge Yant, the founder of Plexis Healthcare Systems, shared his perspective with The Wall Street Journal, revealing his decision to provide psychedelic-assisted therapy coverage to employees through the benefits startup Enthea. Yant’s motivation stemmed from an internal report revealing a high prevalence of prescription drug use, particularly antidepressants, among his staff.

Up Next

British Airways “Flying With Confidence” Course Aims to Alleviate Fear of Flying

British Airways has been offering its “Flying With Confidence” course for over 35 years, targeting individuals who experience varying degrees of fear when it comes to flying.

The program aims to provide reassurance and education to both mildly anxious and severely terrified flyers, equipping them with the knowledge and tools to overcome their fears and feel more comfortable in the skies.

Understand Flying With Confidence Course

The course takes participants through a comprehensive exploration of airplane mechanics and operations, including how pilots are trained to handle potential scenarios such as cabin depressurization, malfunctioning landing gear, and sudden gusts of wind during landing attempts. Led by experts in aviation, the prog

Up Next

Alarming Rise in Cancer Cases Among Young Adults Sparks Concern: Is Diet the Culprit?

In recent years, a disturbing trend has emerged across the United States, including South Florida, where an increasing number of young adults under the age of 50 are being diagnosed with cancer. The rise in Cancer cases has prompted experts to investigate potential causes, with a particular focus on lifestyle factors such as diet, environment, exercise habits, and substance use.

Natasha Mathias, who tragically lost her twin sister Natalie to colon cancer at the age of 42, serves as a poignant example of this trend. Natalie’s diagnosis came as a shock to her family, as they were unaware of the possibility of colon cancer at such a young age. Reflecting on her sister’s experience, Natasha emphasizes the importance of being vigilant about one’s health, especially when unusual symptoms persist.

Up Next

Experts Warn Against Viral ‘Black Cat, Golden Retriever’ Dating Theory as Potentially Toxic

A recent viral dating theory dubbed the “black cat and golden retriever” concept has sparked widespread debate among relationship experts, who caution against its potentially harmful implications.

The theory, popularized by self-proclaimed “mindset coach” Anna Kristina, suggests that successful relationships hinge on a dynamic where women embody the traits of a “mysterious” black cat, while men exhibit the characteristics of a “loyal” golden retriever.

This notion, which gained traction on social media platforms like TikTok, has garnered significant attention despite concerns raised by experts regarding its validity and impact on real-world relationships.

According to Kristina, women should maintain an air of mystery and independence, akin to a black cat, while men are encouraged to pursue and chase afte

Up Next

Jonathan Haidt Highlights Concerns Over Impact of Smartphone Usage on Youth Mental Health

A recent study spearheaded by Dartmouth College has reignited discussions on the role of smartphone usage in the mental health of today’s youth, particularly focusing on the vulnerabilities of Generation Z.

Renowned social psychologist Jonathan Haidt sheds light on the alarming trends observed in his newly published work, “The Anxious Generation,” raising significant concerns regarding the adverse effects of excessive screen time on young minds.

Haidt’s research underscores a social catastrophe resulting from the convergence of two prevailing phenomena: the pervasive culture of “safetyism” in parenting and the unchecked proliferation of smartphones, granting children unrestricted access to the digital realm.

This combination has led to what Haidt terms an “anxious generation,” characterized by heightene

Up Next

Drinking Habits and Relationship Longevity: Drinking With Your Partner May Lead to Longer Life

In a recent study published in the journal The Gerontologist, researchers delved into the intriguing link between drinking habits and relationship longevity among couples over the age of 50. Led by Kira Birditt, a professor and researcher at the University of Michigan, the study sheds light on how shared drinking patterns may impact not only the quality of romantic relationships but also life expectancy.

The study, which surveyed 4,566 married couples, aimed to examine the association between alcohol consumption within couples and its implications for mortality rates. Birditt and her team conducted interviews with the participating couples every two years to gather da

Up Next

Unraveling Havana Syndrome: The Mysterious Illness Linked to Russia’s Intelligence Unit

In a perplexing saga that spans international intrigue and medical mystery, the enigmatic phenomenon known as Havana Syndrome has captured global attention. First detected in 2016 amidst the corridors of Cuba’s capital, diplomats reported peculiar auditory experiences, igniting a cascade of symptoms ranging from bloody noses to vision disturbances.

As the puzzle deepens, recent revelations suggest a sinister connection to sonic weaponry wielded by Unit 29155 of the Russian GRU, thrusting geopolitical tensions to the forefront.

Origins of Havana Syndrome:

The genesis of Havana Syndrome traces back to a series of harrowing encounters reported by diplomats stationed in Havana, where shrill sounds reverberated through the night, leaving a trail of perple