Why Facts Don’t Change People’s Minds: Cognitive Dissonance

Written By:

Written By:

why facts dont change peoples minds 1

Why do many people staunchly defend their opinions and beliefs even in the face of overwhelming evidence that their ideas and views are totally incorrect? Why it’s hard to change people’s minds? Why even facts don’t change our minds?




One explanation is the common phenomenon of cognitive dissonance.

Cognitive Dissonance

What Is Cognitive Dissonance And Why It’s Hard To Change People’s Minds?

Cognition is simply thinking and reasoning. It is the mental process of acquiring knowledge and understanding through thought, reason, analysis of information, and experience. Dissonance is a musical term that means a lack of harmony among musical notes, but can also mean a tension or clash that results from disharmonious or contradictory components.



In psychology, cognitive dissonance is the mental discomfort experienced by a person who simultaneously holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas, or values. The discomfort is triggered by a situation in which a person’s belief clashes with new evidence introduced to that person. To reduce the psychological discomfort, the person will have to change either their mind or their behavior so that the inconsistency or contradiction is resolved, thus restoring mental balance and emotional harmony. That is cognitive consonance.

Hence, people continually reduce their cognitive dissonance to align their beliefs with their actions, thereby maintaining psychological consistency and feeling less mental stress.

This phenomenon, first described by Leon Festinger in 1957, helps explain why so many people will vigorously defend, excuse, justify, and keep their sacred beliefs even when confronted with irrefutable proof they are wrong.




There are several ways that people reduce their mental tension when their behavior and their available information clash. In psychology, it’s called “dissonance reduction.” Here’s an example that involves a person who is trying to lose weight and eat a healthier diet, yet is eating cookies they’ve learned are full of trans fats, sugar, and are high in calories.

Related: Why You Are Frustrated And Angry All The Time: 5 Psychological Reasons

What Can Change People’s Minds – Tips To Reduce Cognitive Dissonance

To reduce dissonance, the person can:

1. Change their behavior or belief so that it’s congruent with the new information. For example, “I’ll stop eating these cookies because they’re full of unhealthy fat and sugar and won’t help me lose weight.”

2. Justify their behavior or belief by changing the conflicting cognition. For example, “I’m allowed to cheat on my diet every once in a while.”

3. Justify their behavior or their belief by adding new cognitions. For instance, “I’ll go to the gym more often to work off the cookies.”




4. Ignore or deny information that conflicts with their existing beliefs. For example, “These cookies are not really that unhealthy, high in sugar or fattening.”

As a currently relevant example, consider that incontrovertible proof has been discovered that Donald Trump has lied, cheated, stolen, and committed very serious crimes that most people would face significant jail time for. What’s more, he has implemented policies that are hurting many people who voted for him.

Nevertheless, a great many people who voted for Trump vigorously defend their choice, despite the tremendous amount of credible, incriminating information about him that has come to light since November 8, 2016. Information that had they been aware of before then, might have dissuaded some from casting their ballot the way they did.

Related: Perception Vs Reality: 7 Things To Keep In Mind

In practice, here is how the people who voted for Trump reduce their cognitive dissonance when confronted with an ever-increasing amount of highly disturbing facts about him:

1. Change their behavior or belief by integrating the conflicting information into their worldview. For example, “I will no longer support our current leadership, and I will vote differently in the next election.”

2. Justify their behavior or belief by changing the conflicting cognition. For example, “The president is doing what’s best for the country and is the victim of a political witch hunt.”




3. Justify their behavior or their beliefs by adding new cognitions. For instance, “The president is a successful businessman and must know what he’s doing—he’s just too smart for most people to understand.”

4. Ignore or deny information that conflicts with their existing beliefs. For example, “All that stuff is just ‘fake news,’ and you can’t trust it.”

The Bottom Line

When there is a conflict between our attitudes and our behavior, we tend to change our attitudes to make them consistent with our behavior rather than change our behavior to make it consistent with our attitudes.

Ideally, people would be rational beings who consistently adjust their beliefs, attitudes, and behaviors to align them with new information that is essentially incontrovertible. But that is not the case. Indeed, there are many who still maintain that the earth is flat; or only 6,500 years old; that vaccines are a health hazard; that evolution is a falsehood; or that climate change is a hoax.

Unfortunately, many people are unwilling to change their worldview to account for new information that contradicts their cherished beliefs. Instead, they reduce dissonance by justifying their outlook rather than by changing their minds or behaviors. If science worked the way many people do, we would still be living in caves and dying in our 30s. But at least the planet’s ecological health would be vastly better—even if humans’ wasn’t.




Remember: Think well, act well, feel well, be well!

Related: 25 Amazing Psychological Facts That Will Boggle Your Mind

Copyright 2018 by Clifford N. Lazarus, Ph.D. This post is for informational purposes only. It is not intended to be a substitute for professional assistance or personal mental health treatment by a qualified clinician.

Let us know your opinions in the comments below!
Feel free to share this post with anyone who you may think will find it valuable and helpful.

References:
Festinger, L. (1957). A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance. California: Stanford University Press.
Written by: Clifford N. Lazarus, Ph.D
Originally appeared on: Psychology Today
Republished with permission 
why facts dont change peoples minds pinex
why facts dont change peoples minds pin


— Share —

Published On:

Last updated on:

,

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

Stuck In Crisis Mode? Here’s The One Thing You’re Missing!

Stuck In Crisis Mode? Here’s The Thing You’re Missing!

Constantly firefighting, feeling overwhelmed, and stuck in crisis mode? What if there’s one thing you’re missing that could change everything?

The surprising crisis tool you’ve been overlooking, and why it works.

Key points

Mentorship offers perspective to help you see beyond the immediate crisis.

A mentor provides emotional support, helping you feel heard and validated.

Mentors guide strategic problem-solving, offering clarity amid chaos.

Mentorship turns crisis moments into growth opportunities and resilience.

Up Next

7 Everyday Habits That Make You Look Unprofessional At Work

Worst Habits That Make You Look Unprofessional At Work!

Whether you’re a fresh Gen Z recruit on your first job, a Millennial climbing the corporate ladder, or a Boomer with decades of experience, the way you present yourself can significantly impact your professional reputation. Below are 7 habits that make you look unprofessional at work.

The workplace is competitive and professionalism isn’t just a bonus, it’s essential for your career growth and success. And believe it or not, we unknowingly engage in unprofessional habits that make us look bad in the eyes of our colleagues, managers, even clients.

So, what are these unprofessional habits, and how can you avoid them? Here are seven common workplace missteps to steer clear of…

Read More Here:

Up Next

The Story of That Thing You Loved Doing as a Kid—But Quit

That Thing You Loved Doing As A Child, But Quit

Remember that thing you loved doing as a child? The one that made you lose track of time? Why did you stop? Let’s learn more about reconnecting with passions from our past.

Personal Perspective: Reconnecting with a past passion helps shape who you are.

Rediscovering Something You Loved Doing As A Child

hobbies and interests or passions from our

Up Next

How To Avoid Suffering: 3 Transformational Steps to a Happier Life

How To Avoid Suffering: Transformational Steps

If you think that in order to avoid suffering you have to dodge life’s struggles, then you are not as right as you may think; it’s about handling them in a way that doesn’t drain you. This article is going to talk about how to avoid suffering and start living with more peace, power and joy.

Suffering is a natural part of life but it doesn’t have to be your entire life. In today’s Best Day Blog article, I’ll share three ways that can help you avoid suffering so you can live a happier, more fulfilling life!

How To Avoid Suffering: 3 Transformational Steps to a Happier Life

Step 1- Acceptance

Up Next

What Is Healthy Shame And The 3 Powerful Ways It Helps Us Grow

What Is Healthy Shame And Powerful Ways It Helps Us Grow

When someone begins to heal from their codependency and trauma, they are bound to feel moments of shame. Whether that’s about past behavior or past experiences, most people will view shame negatively. However, there is a dysfunctional shame, which impedes progress, and healthy shame, which helps us.

So today, I am going to be talking about how shame can be beneficial.

Shame can help us move forward for three simple reasons:

1. It clarifies our morals and values.

2. It helps us make amends.

3. It spurs us into action.

It is essential to understand the differences between healthy and dysfunctional shame to move forward feeling empo

Up Next

Are You Making The Same Mistake Over And Over? Here’s How To Finally Stop!

Are You Making The Same Mistake Twice? Ways To Stop!

We’ve all been there. You swear you won’t do that again, whether it’s sending a risky text, trusting the wrong person, overspending, or missing a deadline. And then, boom. You end up making the same mistake twice. 

The cycle repeats, frustration builds, and you wonder if you’ll ever learn. But guess what? You can break free from the loop.

Habits, unconscious tendencies, and emotional biases cause us often to make the same mistakes. Even if seeking familiarity has unfavorable effects, our brains are programmed to do so.

We remain trapped in repetitive cycles due to a lack of self-awareness, a fear of change, and a failure to properly learn from prior experiences. Rather than addressing the underlying reasons of mistakes,

Up Next

5 Ways To Find Peace When You Are Taking The High Road

Taking The High Road? Ways To Let Go And Find Peace

Taking the high road can feel like a challenge, especially when things get messy. But letting go of attachments can help you a lot in doing that. It’s also one of the best ways to maintain your peace and stay true to who you are.

KEY POINTS

Taking the high road means behaving in line with our moral and ethical values even when others don’t.

Fear of being misunderstood, judged, or rejected by our peers can make it challenging to take the high road.

We can find a sense of peace if we recognize that our suffering on the high road stems from attachment.

Releasin