What Happens When Men And Women Reverse Dating Roles?

Men Women Reverse Dating Roles 1

When it comes to dating, there is still a lot of traditionalism regarding who should approach whom. But imagine if men and women reverse dating roles? What if the dating roles are reversed, and instead of the man approaching the woman, itโ€™s the other way round?

Two people are out at a party. One is standing with friends, while another person approaches from across the room to strike up a conversation. Chances are, in this scenario, you imagined that it was a guy approaching a girl. Whether itโ€™s in a social setting or online, we seem to expect men to make the first move.

Why? Well, we all have what psychologists call โ€œbehavioral scripts,โ€ย which are a sequence of events that we expect to typically occur in social situations. You have a script for how to act in a job interview, how to place an order at a restaurant, and how to cheer for a sports team.ย 

Related: 3 Frustrating and Ridiculous Ways Men Test Women While Datingย 

Datingย is no different. In most cultures, expectations about male and female dating behavior (such as โ€œguys approach girlsโ€) are fairly entrenched. A study of nearly 300 undergraduates found that if a man initiated a date, students felt both partners were interested (Reid et al., 2011). However, if the woman initiated the date, many (around 40%) saw the man as only doing it out of pity. When a woman initiates, it appears to violate some type of unwritten rule.

But we donโ€™t always follow those rules. There are exceptions. For example, there are special days or events where we intentionally flip the script. Onย Sadie Hawkins Dayย (traditionally observed in early Novemberโ€”it falls on November 13thย in 2020 and 2021) or at a Sadie Hawkins Dance, women have the opportunity to invert social convention by asking men out on a date or to a dance.ย 

Researchers have examined speed dating to help them better understand datingโ€™s underlying scripts and expectations (Finkel & Eastwick, 2008). Speed dating is a structured way for daters to meet a lot of people quickly. The typical speed-dating event features women sitting at various locations around a room, often a coffee shop or bar, while men circulate and chat with each woman for a few minutes. A signal will then indicate that time is up and the men should move along to the next woman.

The process repeats until everyone at the event has โ€œdatedโ€ each other. Later, the male and female participants let the event organizer know which partners they would like to see again. If the male and female indicate mutual interest, the organizer gives them each otherโ€™s contact information. If done efficiently, a speed dater could meet over a dozen potential dating partners in less than an hour.

The typical speed-dating event relies heavily on the โ€œmale approaches femaleโ€ norm. Consistent with the norm, speed-dating research reveals thatย women are pickier than menย when indicating interest in potential partners (Todd et al., 2007). That is, women say โ€œyesโ€ much less frequently than men, with menย indicating interest in roughly halfย the potential partners and women indicating interest in only a third (Kurzban & Weeden, 2005).ย 

However, other researchers wondered if what seems like a clear-cutย genderย difference, truly was a gender difference, or if the social situation was the actual cause (Finkel & Eastwick, 2009). Specifically, they investigated whether women were pickier because they got to sit in one place, while men had to work their way around the room.

To test this, they had more than 300 undergraduates participate in speed-dating events. In half of those events, participants engaged in the standard speed-dating procedure where men circulated while women stayed in one place. For the other events, men and women performed a Sadie Hawkins-like role reversal: men stayed in one place while women circulated around the room.ย 

In the standard โ€œmen rotatingโ€ events, the researchers replicated previous findings (and the prevailing stereotypes) that women were pickier about who they liked relative to men. But in the non-standard โ€œwomen rotatingโ€ events where men and women reversed roles, the researcher found the exact opposite pattern: men were picky, whereas women were less selective. Put another way, there was aย โ€œSadie Hawkins Effect.โ€ย 

When women were forced to go from man to man during the speed-dating event, they debunked the gender stereotype by showing an interest in more of the potential partners.

These findings show how a widely assumed gender difference โ€”ย women are picky about who they date, while men arenโ€™t โ€”ย maybe an artifact of social situations. Men may be less picky not because they are men, but because societal norms require them to do most of the approaching in dating scenarios. Womenโ€™s selectivity, meanwhile, might arise from their essentially arbitrary role as โ€œselectors.โ€ย In other words, when lots of potential suitors regularly approach you, itโ€™s a lot easier to be picky.

Related: The Top 9 Biggest Turn-Offs For Men When Dating

This brings up a much broader point: itโ€™s simple to assume that men and women behave very differently because of evolved, inborn differences. Research on the Sadie Hawkins effect shows how careful we should be to avoid assumptions about gender differences, and how we may not need to look far for other potential explanations. Situations are powerful influencers that we too easily overlook.

Check out the new book of Gary W. Lewandowski Jr.,ย Stronger Than You Think: The 10 Blindย Spots That Undermine Yourย Relationshipโ€ฆand How to See Pastย Them, to know more about relationships, and how to handle them.

References:

Reid, J., Elliott, S., & Webber, G. (2011). Casual hookups to formal dates: Refining the boundaries of the sexual double standard.ย Gender and Society, 25(5), 545-568.ย 
Finkel, E. J., & Eastwick, P. W. (2008). Speed-dating.ย Current Directions in Psychological Science, 17(3), 193โ€“197.ย 
Todd, P. M., Penke, L., Fasolo, B., & Lenton, A. P. (2007). Different cognitive processes underlie human mate choices and mate preferences.ย PNAS Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of The United States of America,ย 104(38), 15011-15016.ย 
Kurzban, R., & Weeden, J. (2005). HurryDate: Mate preferences in action.ย Evolution and Human Behavior,ย 26(3), 227-244.
Finkel, E. J., & Eastwick, P. W. (2009). Arbitrary social norms influence sex differences in romantic selectivity.ย Psychological Science,ย 20(10), 1290-1295.ย 

Written By Gary W. Lewandowski Jr. 
Originally Appeared In Psychology Today
Men Women Reverse Dating Roles pin

— Share —

Published On:

Last updated on:

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

How to Handle Valentineโ€™s Day When Youโ€™re In a Situationship

Rules for Surviving Valentineโ€™s Day with a Situationship

Valentine’s Day with a situationship can be a tricky balance to strike. Youโ€™re not quite in a full-fledged relationship, but thereโ€™s an undeniable connection between you and the other person. This makes the holiday feel like a bit of a gray area โ€” neither here nor there. On one hand, you might feel the urge to celebrate it with gestures of affection, but on the other hand, you donโ€™t want to overstep boundaries or create expectations that aren’t yet there. So, how do you approach Valentineโ€™s Day when things arenโ€™t clearly defined? I’m glad you asked because we are happy to help:

8 Rules for Surviving Valentineโ€™s Day with a Situationship

1. Donโ€™t Assumeโ€”Just Ask

Up Next

Unconventional Valentineโ€™s Day Date Ideas: Skip the Dinner, Try These Instead!

Unconventional Date Ideas For Valentine's Day!

If you’re looking for date ideas for Valentine’s Day that go beyond the typical dinner out, you’re in the right place. While a restaurant meal is a classic choice, it often comes with its own set of challengesโ€”long waits, high prices, and rushed service. Itโ€™s easy to feel like you’re missing out on the true meaning of the day when you’re focused on logistics instead of enjoying each other’s company.

Luckily, there are plenty of creative alternatives to celebrate in a way that feels special, relaxing, and memorable. Whether youโ€™re staying in or trying something new, these ideas will help you make the most of the day without all the usual stress.

Read More: 11 Valentineโ€™s D

Up Next

Singlesโ€™ Survival Guide: How to Have the Best Valentineโ€™s Day Without a Date

Single on Valentineโ€™s Day? Here Are Simple Ways You Can Make the Most of It!

Being single on Valentineโ€™s Day can be a mix of emotions. While being independent has its perks, itโ€™s hard to ignore the endless displays of love all aroundโ€”flowers, chocolates, and romantic posts flooding social media. It can feel like the whole world is in love except you.

But listen, Valentineโ€™s Day doesnโ€™t have to be a reminder of whatโ€™s missing. Instead, it can be a celebration of self-love, friendship, and the things that bring you joy. Whether you spend the day pampering yourself, hanging out with friends, or simply ignoring the hype, rememberโ€”youโ€™re not alone in this. And love, in all its forms, is always worth celebrating.

Read More: 9 Reminders

Up Next

This Simple 3-6-9 Rule Could Predict Your Relationshipโ€™s Future!

The 3-6-9 Rule: The Relationship Formula You Didnโ€™t Know You Needed!

The 3-6-9 rule is your secret weapon in the dating game. Itโ€™s a simple way to tell if your relationship has the potential to be something real or if youโ€™re about to get played. Curious? Well, buckle up because weโ€™re about to spill the tea!

Ever had one of those moments where you meet someone online, start texting non-stop, and you’re all โ€œThis could be it!โ€? You gush to your friends over brunch, your excitement practically spilling over your mimosa. Heโ€™s sweet, heโ€™s thoughtful, heโ€™s saying all the right things โ€“ it feels like youโ€™ve found your perfect match.

Fast forward a few weeks, and… well, letโ€™s just say things arenโ€™t looking as promising. Cue the brunch round two, but this time, youโ€™re venting about how this guy who seemed โ€œso perfectโ€ turned out to be anything but. Been there?

Up Next

What You Should Do If You Were Ghosted

How To Handle Being Ghosted? Simple Ways

If you’ve ventured into the wild world of modern dating, chances are youโ€™ve probably felt the sting of being ghosted. Donโ€™t feel bad, thoughโ€”you’re definitely not alone. A solid 82% of daters have been left hanging at least once, so itโ€™s practically a rite of passage these days. This spooky trend has become so common that we almost shrug it off, even though deep down, it still stings. So, what should you do when youโ€™re left hanging in the digital abyss? Today we’ll talk about how to handle being ghostedโ€”because you deserve better than to be treated like a forgotten text in someoneโ€™s inbox.

How To Handle Being Ghosted

1. Start by acknowledging how you feel

Gett

Up Next

Soft Ghosting Sucksโ€”Hereโ€™s How to Take Back Control

How to Handle 'Soft Ghosting': When They're Not Gone But Not Present

Youโ€™ve been seeing someone for a while, things are going great, and youโ€™re starting to feel like this could turn into something real. But then, one day, they start pulling away – they start soft ghosting you.

At first, itโ€™s smallโ€”maybe they take longer to reply on a random Monday or they seem a little short. You think itโ€™s no big deal, maybe theyโ€™re just having a tough day. But soon enough, their replies get shorter, and they start disappearing more often.

Theyโ€™re too busy for plans, donโ€™t ask about your weekend anymore, and you canโ€™t remember the last time they initiated anything. You decide to give them space, hoping itโ€™s just a phase, but the truth is: youโ€™ve been soft ghosted.

Soft ghosting is when someone slowly fades away without completely cutting you off. They still watch y

Up Next

7 Dreamy Date Ideas Straight Out of Your Favorite Rom-Com!

Romantic Date Ideas Straight Out of Your Favorite Rom-Coms

Valentineโ€™s Day is right around the corner, and we all know what that meansโ€”love is in the air, hearts are floating, and the pressure to come up with perfect date ideas is real.

If youโ€™re anything like me, youโ€™ve probably spent countless hours binge-watching romantic comedies (no shame). And guess what? Those iconic movie moments are not just for the big screen. Why not take a page out of your favorite rom-com and turn your date night into something straight out of a movie?

Here is a list of romantic date ideas inspired by our favorite rom-coms.

7 Romantic Date Ideas Straight Out of Your Favorite Rom-Coms