How Memory Problems Causes Arguments In Relationships

How Memory Problems Causes Arguments

Your story feels accurate, but when rehashing issues, things become distorted. Read on to know how memory problem causes arguments in relationships.

Your Memory Is Deceptive

Shelby and Stan (names have been changed) were arguing in front of me over an incident at her parents’ house. “We went there for a family barbecue after we first started dating,” Shelby reported. “Stan was just getting to know my family, and he ended up losing his temper and embarrassing me in front of everyone. It was a catastrophe!”

“Her little brother is a twerp, and he came up and pulled my shorts down around my ankles,” said Stan. “He thought this was hysterical, but I was mad.”

“So you hurt him,” Shelby said. “You Hulked out and tackled him and he ended up with bruises and is now freaked out by you. My parents were wondering what kind of guy I brought over.”

“Your parents should have been wondering about what kind of teenager they were raising.” Stan snapped. “Your brother was a spoiled punk, and I didn’t tackle him. I just chased him and put him in a little headlock. He needed to learn his lesson, and he wasn’t hurt, he just had a couple of scuffs.”

“He was bleeding and crying! You almost killed him!”

“I barely touched him, and he was laughing!”

“Everyone was shocked at what you did!”

“No one cared! They thought he deserved it!”

Have you done this in your relationship?
Recounted the same event but had different versions of it?
Have you become frustrated at your partner’s inaccuracies in memory?
How could they be so wrong about basic facts?
Are they lying or just confused?

They are probably just doing the same thing you’re doing, which is remembering something incompletely.

Also read 16 Weird Mind Tricks Your Brain Plays On You

Memory is not a video that replays the same way each time. It is like an improvisational play, where themes and events are reworked slightly with each performance.

Professor Ulrick Neisser did an impromptu experiment after the space shuttle Challenger exploded in 1986. The day after the disaster, he asked his class of 106 students to write down where they were when they heard about it.

Listening to 5 to 10 songs a day can improve memory

Three years later he asked these students the same thing. Over 90% of the accounts changed, and about half of them were inaccurate in at least two-thirds of the details. The revised memories had supplanted the earlier, more accurate ones, but the new ones still felt true. One student was shown her first description, written three years earlier, and said, “I know that’s my handwriting, but I couldn’t possibly have written that.”

Memories are shaped by feelings that existed at the time, but also by the way the memory is retrieved.

For example, how someone asks a question will influence the details of an event. Elizabeth Loftus showed participants a short movie of an auto accident, and afterward, asked them questions, but discovered that the words she used influenced what observers remembered.

For instance, she asked people how fast the car was going when it hit the other car. But when she changed the word “hit,” to “smashed,” the estimates of speed were higher. More people remembered seeing broken glass when she asked the “smashed” version as well.

sometimes a perfect memory can be ruined if put to words

Also read What Is Cognitive Dissonance? Common Causes and How To Resolve It

If Memory Serves …

If a partner recalls a story while angry, the details will be more negative. Brains fill in gaps to support the angry version, and memory serves its owner. Details that don’t fit are dropped, and others are added to make the memory coherent and pleasing.

It only takes a few days after an event for the details to change. Stan and Shelby may have had similar initial memories of when Stan mooned the barbecue, but their current marriage problems were darkening these recollections. Now Stan remembers Shelby being biased and critical, and she remembers him as extreme and violent.

This negative filter was a bad sign. Couples who are not doing well say things like, “We got married too young, I didn’t see what a slob he was then.” Or, “She tricked me into thinking she would actually be excited about sex.”

In one study, researchers interviewed 56 couples, none of whom were planning to divorce. However, the team accurately predicted the seven couples that would divorce based on the negative way they talked about their history. After relationships fail, exes are inclined toward “retroactive pessimism,” where they recall the problems in a way that sounds like they were inevitable: “It was doomed from the start.”

The reverse is true as well.

When couples feel loving, they recall things more generously.

Satisfied partners describe their history in positive terms and will laugh about previous bumps and misunderstandings. When President Kennedy was assassinated, there was an outpouring of grief in the United States. In a poll following, two-thirds of respondents recalled voting for him in the previous election, when only half really had. People’s memories changed to be consistent with the positive emotions they felt about their martyred president.

Not only do memories feel true, but they aren’t easily corrected. When someone is attached to a story, challenging it with contrary information can entrench it further. This tendency is called “belief perseverance,” which is when a person refuses to change even in the face of contradictory data. Stubborn partners are often wrong, but they are rarely in doubt.

Also read The 3 Methods Of Mastering The Mind

Belief perseverance is self-protective. When couples attack each other’s recall, even with evidence, it feels like an attack of the person. Stan and Shelby were implying the other was incompetent, not just inaccurate. Even if each brought witnesses from the barbecue to testify for their version, it would not convince the other.

When a spouse tries to browbeat the other into agreement, it doesn’t work and causes resentment. Imagine an argument where one comes away grateful for having been forcibly corrected: “Gee, thanks Shelby for helping me see how wrong I was! Now I can go forward in truth and light!”

Stan and Shelby finally realized no amount of arguing would convince each other whose story was most correct at that fateful poolside day. As they improved at having positive conversations, they were better able to laugh and see that their stories had become warped. They heard each other out and agreed to drop the issue. They also agreed to avoid pool parties at her parent’s house until her brother left home.

Adapted from Love Me True: Overcoming the Surprising Ways We Deceive in Relationships. Cedar Fort Publishing.


Ulric Neisser, and Nicole Harsch, "Phantom Flashbulbs: False Recollections of Hearing the News About Challenger." (1992). In Affect and accuracy in Recall: Studies of 'Flashbulb' Memories, eds. E. Winograd, Ulric Neisser (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1992, p. 9-31). ISBN 978-0521401883

Elizabeth F. Loftus and John C. Palmer, “Reconstruction of Automobile Destruction:An Example of the Interaction Between Language and Memory,” Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 13, 585-589 (1974).

H. L. Roediger, E. T. Bergman, and M. L. Meade, “Repeated Reproduction from Memory,” in Bartlett, Culture and Cognition, ed. A. Saito (London, UK: Psychology Press, 2000), 115-34.

Burger, Jerry M., and Rose M. Huntzinger. "Temporal Effects On Attributions for One's Own Behavior: The Role of Task Outcome." Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 21, no. 3 (1985): 247-261.

Lawrence J. Sanna, and Edward C. Chang, "The Past Is Not What It Used to Be: Optimists’ Use of Retroactive Pessimism To Diminish The Sting of Failure," Journal of Research in Personality 37, no. 5 (2003): 388-404.

Lawrence J. Sanna, and Edward C. Chang, "The Past Is Not What It Used to Be: Optimists’ Use of Retroactive Pessimism To Diminish The Sting of Failure," Journal of Research in Personality 37, no. 5 (2003): 388-404

Written by: Jason Whiting, Ph.D
Originally appeared on: Psychology Today
Republished with permission
How Memory Problems Causes Arguments PIN

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

Why Is It So Hard To Find A Good Man? 7 Harsh Truths

Why Is It So Hard To Find A Good Man? Harsh Reasons

Why is it so hard to find a good man? This question has echoed through the minds of countless individuals searching for love, companionship, and a fulfilling relationship. 

In today’s fast-paced world, where dating apps and social media dominate the landscape, the pursuit of a genuine connection can feel like an elusive endeavor. However, by understanding the best personality traits in a man, recognizing what is required to find a good partner, and learning how to meet a nice man, we can navigate the complexities of modern dating with hope and confidence.

Who is a “Good Man”?

Before we delve into exploring what is required to find a

Up Next

Breadcrumbing in a Relationship: 6 Alarming Signs And How To Manage It

Breadcrumbing In A Relationship | Signs and How to Manage

Breadcrumbing in a relationship is like leaving tiny hints of interest without real commitment. It is confusing and can leave you wondering where you stand. 

 So, how do you know if it’s happening to you?

In this guide, we’ll discuss five signs of breadcrumbing in a relationship. We will also be providing strategies on how to deal with breadcrumbing in a relationship. 

But first, let us learn about the breadcrumbing meaning. 

Up Next

Is It Fate? 8 Unmistakable Signs of Karmic Relationships

Is It Fate? Unmistakable Signs of Karmic Relationships

In the vast theatre of human connections, certain relationships stand out, casting a spell that’s hard to break. They tug at our heartstrings in ways we can’t explain, evoking emotions so raw, so deep, that they shake the very foundation of our being. Imagine crossing paths with someone and feeling an electric charge, a cosmic familiarity. Or, on the flip side, an instant and unexplainable aversion. Maybe these are signs of karmic relationships?

It’s like a song whose lyrics you can’t quite recall, but the melody stirs something profound within. These are not just random encounters; they might be the echoes of past lifetimes reverberating in the present. Welcome to the intriguing and often tumultuous world of karmic connections.

Up Next

Cold Feet Or Clear Signs? 8 Major Warning Signs You Are Marrying The Wrong Person

8 Warning Signs You Are Marrying The Wrong Person

Marriage is one of the most profound commitments one can make in a lifetime. The idea of spending the rest of your life with someone can be both exhilarating and terrifying. Most of us have a mental checklist of the qualities we want in our significant other, and often, we are vigilant for the obvious red flags: dishonesty, incompatibility, or a mismatch in values. But what about the more subtle signs you are marrying the wrong person? The uncommon warnings that lurk in the shadows, often overlooked?

It’s essential to pay attention to these because they can provide insight into potential pitfalls in the future. In your quest for lifelong happiness, it’s vital to ensure that you’re not just seeing what you want to see, but rather, you’re unders

Up Next

What Is New Relationship Energy? 11 Clear Indicators You’re Basking In The Honeymoon Glow

What Is New Relationship Energy? 11 Signs of Honeymoon Phase

Love is an extraordinary emotion that can create a whirlwind of feelings and experiences. When a new relationship blossoms, it often comes with an intense and exhilarating energy known as “new relationship energy”. But what is New Relationship Energy, exactly?

This captivating phase can be both enchanting and transformative, but it’s important to understand its nature, signs, and what happens when new relationship energy wears off. In this article, we delve into the world of new relationship energy, exploring its definition, identifying its signs, and examining the changes that occur when its initial fervour subsides.

Up Next

Can You Be Friends With Your Ex? Exploring The Complexities of Post-Breakup Relationships

Can You Be Friends With Your Ex? Expert Tips To Consider

Breaking up with someone you once loved and cared deeply for is never easy. It often leaves us feeling confused, hurt, and uncertain about the future. In the aftermath of a breakup, one question that frequently arises is, “Can you be friends with your ex?” 

It’s a topic that sparks curiosity, debate, and even skepticism. Let’s explore the complexities of maintaining a friendship with an ex-partner, examining both the potential benefits and challenges that come with this unique dynamic.

Can You Be Friends with Your Ex?

The short answer is yes! It’s possible to be friends with your

Up Next

How Your Body Changes When You Are In Love

How Your Body Changes When You Are In Love

Have you ever wondered how your body changes when you are in love? It’s a question that has intrigued poets, scientists, and romantics alike for centuries.

Love is a profound and complex emotion that can transform our lives in extraordinary ways. Beyond the butterflies in your stomach and the racing heart, falling in love triggers a cascade of physiological and psychological responses that are nothing short of magical.

In this article, we are going to take a deep dive into what happens to our body when we are in love.

What Happens To Your Body When You Fall In Love