Forgiveness Through An Evolutionary Lens

Forgiveness is a process. And it is a product of evolutionary forces.

So picture this:ย You receive an email from Dan, a longtimeย co-worker and friend. You quickly realize that the email was not meant for you but was, rather, meant for a different colleague in your department. You happen to be running for an electedย leadershipย position as area director against your long-standing nemesis, Maria.ย 

The content of Danโ€™s email, which is meant for another departmental colleague, Sara, includes this statement: โ€œWhile heโ€™s definitely my best friend at work, I totally think Maria will do a waaaaay better job. We should vote for her. I know Iโ€™m going to.โ€

You sit there at your desk stunned. You can barely even think. After what seems an eternity, you receive another email. It is Dan, apologizing and trying to explain himself.

โ€œToo late, Danโ€”I know your true colors now!โ€ you think to yourself.

So Dan pretty much raked you over the coals and just like that, Dan has gone from the category of friend to foe in your mind. You donโ€™t even think you can stay in the office today.

Read 8 Reasons To Forgive And Why It Matters

Theย Evolutionary Psychologyย ofย Forgiveness

The human social mind did not evolveย to be adapted to modern large-scale conditions, such as mega-cities; it evolved for millennia as our ancestors lived in small, tight-knit groups that were capped at about 150 (see Dunbar, 1992). Under such conditions, people developed long-standing alliances and relationships with one anotherโ€”relationships that often lasted a lifetime. Under such conditions, people came to help each other in mutually beneficial ways and they learned whoย could be trusted and who could not be. Such social-cognitive skills were critical for ultimately surviving and reproducing under these ancestral conditions (see Trivers, 1985).

In such an environment, complex moral emotions evolved. Such moral emotions, including such states as remorse,ย shame,ย gratitude, and forgiveness, largely evolved to motivate behaviors to keep people connected with others after transgressions and disruptions in the fabric of the community (seeย DeJesus et al., 2021).ย 

Forgiveness specifically seems to have evolved to help people reconnect with others who have wronged them in some way. When someone transgresses against you in a social context, there is something of a cost-benefit reasoning process that takes place.

On one hand, if you cut the transgressor out of your life completely, you are less likely to have that person cause you problems in the future. On the other hand,ย cuttingย that person out completely means that you lose at least one ally. And you likely will lose more allies, such as close friends and family members of the transgressor, along the way. So dealing with a transgression by someone from your inner circle is evolutionarily tricky business (see Geher et al., 2019;ย Geher & Wedberg, 2020).ย 

This said, forgiving someone immediately so as to not lose that personโ€™s support could lead to your being exploited into the future, which would have obvious evolutionarily deleterious outcomes. In our recent work on this topic, we refer to such forgiveness asย divine forgivenessย (see DeJesus et al., 2021), and we see it as rare and unlikely.ย 

Read 7 Signs Someone Is Always Playing The Victim Role

In fact, for good evolutionary reasons, forgiveness is a processโ€”one that often includes outrage on the part of the victim,ย guiltย and remorse on the part of the transgressor, and then, possibly, forgiveness on the part of the victim (see DeJesus et al., 2021).

forgiveness doesn't excuse their behavior

Ultimate and Proximate Factors that Underlie Forgiveness

Renowned ethologist Niko Tinbergen (1963) argued that all behaviors of all animals can be thought of in terms of bothย ultimateย andย proximateย causes. From an evolutionary perspective, an ultimate cause pertains to ways that the behavior of interest ultimately helps facilitate oneโ€™s own likelihood of survival and/or reproduction. Proximate causes are immediate processes or factors that specifically motivate the behavior.

From an ultimate perspective, forgiveness, when done under appropriate conditions, can help provide important glue to the social fabric of oneโ€™s broader community, keeping oneself closely connected to others who may be helpful allies during the trials and tribulations of life.ย 

Further, much research has gone into the proximate causes of forgiveness as well (see Gorsuch & Hao, 1993;ย Geher & Wedberg, 2020). Genuine forgiveness has the capacity to flood one with warm feelings and increases inย self-worth. In short, it feels good to forgive, thus making it so that forgiveness provides immediate benefits to both the person being forgiven as well as the forgiver.

Should You Forgive Dan?

So letโ€™s get back to our initial scenario. Danโ€™s misdirected email really stung.ย 

Based on our recently presented model of the evolution of forgiveness (see DeJesus et al., 2021), youโ€™re likely to be outraged by Danโ€™s actions. And upon feeling your outrage, Dan may well feel and express all kinds of guilt. And he may well attempt to engage in various reparative behaviors, such as writing you an apologetic letter, offering to take you out to drinks, etc.ย Will youย forgive Dan after all this?ย Shouldย youย forgive Dan after all this?

Each situation is different and many factors are still at play. But if Danโ€™s apologies seem deep and genuine enough and if you value your connections with Dan enoughโ€”and if forgiving him will make you feel better about thingsโ€”you just might have it in you to forgive him.ย Or maybe not!As we all know, once we make it to a certain point in life, forgiveness is a tricky business. And sometimes a grudge can last for a lifetime (see DeJesus, 2021).ย 

Read Escaping the Cycle of Suffering: Why You Should Forgive Your Parents

Bottom Line

At the end of the day, we are all imperfect. Each and every one of us. Forgiveness evolved to help keep people interconnected after transgressions that take place in social contexts, and it has the proximate function of making one feel relieved and better able to move forward. This all said, forgiveness is never a guarantee and it is, for good evolutionary reasons, always quite a process. If we want to better understand the nature of forgiveness, which profoundly impacts many if not all of us at some point in life, we need to keep our evolutionary history in mind.ย 

I Donโ€™t Forgive People Because Iโ€™m Weak But because I'm strong.

References

  • Deโ€™Jesรบs, A. R., Cristo, M., Ruel, M., Kruchowy, D.,ย Geher, G.,ย Nolan, K., Santos, A., Wojszynski, C., Alijaj, N., DeBonis, A., Elyukin, N., Huppert, S., Maurer, E., Spackman, B. C., Villegas, A., Widrick, K., & Zezula, V.ย (2021). Betrayal, Outrage, Guilt, and Forgiveness: The Four Horsemen of the Human Social-Emotional Experience.ย The Journal of the Evolutionary Studies Consortium,ย 9(1), 1-13.
  • Dunbar, R. I. M. (1992). Neocortex size as a constraint on group size in primates.ย Journal of Human Evolution, 22(6), 469โ€“493.
  • Geher, G.,ย Rolon, V., Holler, R., Baroni, A., Gleason, M., Nitza, E., Sullivan, G., Thomson, G., & Di Santo, J. M. (2019). Youโ€™re dead to me! The evolutionary psychology of social estrangements and social transgressions.ย Current Psychology. doi: 10.1007/s12144-019-00381-z
  • Geher, G. &ย Wedberg, N.ย (2020). Positive Evolutionary Psychology: Darwinโ€™s Guide to Living a Richer Life. New York: Oxford University Press.
  • Gorsuch, R. L., & Hao, J. Y. (1993). Forgiveness: An exploratory factor analysis and its relationship to religious variables, Review of Religious Research, 34, 351- 363.
  • Tinbergen, N. (1963) On aims and methods of ethology. Zeitschrift fรผr Tierpsychologie, 20, 410-433.
  • Trivers, R. (1985). Social evolution. Meno Park, CA: Benjamin/Cummings.

Written by: Glenn Geher, Ph.D.
Originally appeared on Psychology Today
Republished with permission
Forgiveness Evolutionary Lens pin

— Share —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

Am I Motivating Myself or Just Pushing Myself?

Motivation Myself or Pushing Myself Redefining

Am I truly motivating myself or just pushing too hard? Andrea asks a reflecting question if itโ€™s inspiration or unrelenting pressure. Let’s find out more about it!

Personal Perspective: The bracelet is inscribed โ€œKeep Going.โ€ Can I?

Motivating Myself Or Pushing Myself?

This bracelet inscribed โ€œKeep Goingโ€ was originally meant to inspire me because last year was a t

Up Next

Things People Learn Too Late In Life: 7 Eye-Opening Life Lessons

Things People Learn Too Late in Life Eye Opening Life Lessons

Life is full of unexpected events and sometimes there are things people learn too late. Though some lessons come with age and experience, as time goes by, we often wish we had known some important truths sooner.

These moments of truth can be very shocking as well as transformative, they help us live authentically, appreciate what truly matters, and make the most of our time. Below are seven crucial life lessons people learn too late and can still change the way they approach life.

7 Things People Learn Too Late In

Up Next

Anger and Emotions: What’s Really Setting Us Off?

Anger and Emotion Whats Really Setting Us Off

Ever wonder whatโ€™s really fueling your anger and emotions? Discover how a mindful approach can help you regain inner peace in your life!

Taking a mindful approach to exploring why we are angry.

Key points

Anger is a secondary emotion.

Anger is a warning sign that lets us know there is an issue to address.

Knowing what we are feeling will help us to address the source of our anger.

Anger can hit us when we least expect it. There are some people who get angry and not know what they are angry about. The

Up Next

How I Hacked My Personality: Steps To Be The Better Version Of Myself

How I Hacked My Personality

Can we truly reshape our personalities for lasting change? Discover Dr. Shannon Sauer-Zavala’s article “How I hacked my personality” and learn how small shifts in mindset and behavior can lead to meaningful transformation in your life.

A Personal Perspective: Science-backed strategies for intentional trait change.

Key points

Research suggests that personality changes over time.

We can speed up personality change by taking intentional action.

Changes that are reinforced by the environment are easier to maintain.

Up Next

Women Empowerment: The Rebecca Effect in “Ted Lasso”

Rebecca Effect In Ted Lasso Women Empowerment

Can women turn negative experiences into empowerment? Discover the โ€œRebecca Effectโ€ from Ted Lasso and transform your personal trials into powerful self-acceptance!

Personal Perspective: Empowering women to transform shame and betrayal.

Key points

“Ted Lasso” inspired with imperfect, endearing characters whose trials and transformations mirrored our own.

The โ€œRebecca Effectโ€ is the empowerment and transformation possible when we have been oppressed or shamed.

The “Rebecca Effect” is the process through which women embrace themselves in totality.

Up Next

The Healing Power of Emotional Tears

The Healing Power of Emotional Tears

Ever wondered why we shed emotional tears? Tears serve a healing purpose. Explore how it plays an important role for our well-being.

Emotional tears are an expression of our shared humanity.

Emotional tears, expressed by children, teens, and adults, are a universal experience observed across the globe. Emotional tears play a healing role, leading to our emotional and physical well-being. This post explores the value of emotional tears and the importance of presence and support from family and friends during unexpected

Read More Here: โ€œWhy Am I Always On The Verg

Up Next

10 Important Weekly Reflection Questions You Need To Ask Yourself

If you feel stuck and want to keep track of your goals every week, then weekly reflection questions can really help you. Weekly reflection questions can help you check in with yourself and make sure youโ€™re headed in the right direction. These are the questions you need to ask yourself every week to keep growing and moving forward.

Have you ever had a week with so much going on that you end the week feeling overwhelmed and exhausted? I know I have been there. Sometimes, the week goes by so fast that itโ€™s over before I know it, and there is no time left to process it.

A weekly reflection can help evaluate if what you are doing is working. It fosters self-growth. So, pull out that weekly reflection journal and answer the weekly reflection prompts below.