Your Child Needs You to Be Responsive, Not Reactive: Here’s How

Written By:

Written By:

Your Child Needs You to Be Responsive Not Reactive Heres How 1

What do you do when your child is not doing what’s expected? Do you react to your behavior? or respond?
Here’s why your child needs you to be responsive, not reactive and how can you do that.

Dev is trying to read books to his three-year-old, Zoara. Zoara is running around the room and not settling down to participate. She keeps demanding that mommy (Nurit) come back to read to her. Dev spends 20 minutes trying to get Zoara to change her behavior, then reaches his threshold and storms out of the room in frustration. Zoara starts to scream that she didn’t get her books and begs for Nurit who goes to Zoara, settles her down, reads to her, and puts her to bed. This has become a pattern: Zoara demanding mommy do bedtime every night and rejecting Dev.

Dev and Nurit know that this dynamic is unhealthy for everyone, but they feel stuck. Dev is so upset in the moment that it’s hard for him not to be reactive. For Nurit’s part, she has a hard time not going to Zoara when she’s screaming for her.


In my work collaborating with families to solve their most vexing child rearing challenges, I have identified a number of consistent parental mindsets that result in moms and dads getting triggered and reacting in ways that are ineffective and often increase the intensity and frequency of meltdowns, power struggles, and other challenging behaviors.

One of the most prevalent of these faulty mindsets is: “I can and need to control my child. I have the power to change his behavior.” 

But the fact is that you cannot actually make your children do anything: eat, sleep, use the potty, be kind, not yell or have a tantrum. Children, like all humans, are the only ones who control their words and actions. This is one of the most humbling aspects of parenting that no one warns you about. It is so fiercely counter to how we see ourselves and our role. We are supposed to be able to make our children behave.

The problem is that when you focus your efforts on trying to make your child change his behavior, you actually put him in the driver’s seat. When you are in the position of trying to convince your child to cooperate with a direction or agree to a limit, you are actually ceding control of the situation to him.

Think about it,  all of the typical tactics we use to try to get children to get with the program—logic (you’ll be tired in the morning if you don’t go to sleep right now), rewards/bribes (you’ll get an extra hour of screen time), or threats (you will lose screen time)—put the outcome in their hands.

What happens if your child isn’t swayed by your logic; if he doesn’t accept the bribe or reward or he doesn’t fear the threat? Your child remains in control of how the scenario unfolds and gets resolved, a dynamic that is infuriating to most parents and results in reactivity.

So you want to keep reminding yourself in these maddening moments to focus on what you do control—the situation—and not what you don’t control: your child.

Read How to Help Highly Sensitive Kids Manage Intense Emotions: 3 Tips

But it turns out that because you’re human, this is easier said than done. Even with this insight, if you are like most of the parents I work with, you get so triggered in the moment by your child’s defiance, sassiness or obfuscation that it is hard to think clearly and go through this reflective process. (I know this feeling all too well as I am a big reactor by nature and had a very hard time practicing what I preach.)

Your children don’t belong to you.

To help parents be more responsive vs. reactive at times when your child is not doing what’s expected, I have come up with a simple strategy to throw a monkey wrench into a downward spiral with your child: taking a mommy/daddy moment.

Here are the three key steps:

1. Matter-of-factly name the problem at hand:

“It’s time to get into the car seat but you are having a hard time following that direction.”

Read 9 Guiding Principles For More Positive Parenting

2. Tell your child you are going to take a mommy/daddy moment

To buy you time to think about how to solve the problem.

3. Give your child the choices

That you have come up with as a result of thinking through the situation that still enable you to remain in control of the situation.

The mommy/daddy moment essentially enables you to think about how you want to respond before you act. It is a tool for parental self-regulation—our capacity for which is often the key factor in whether a challenging situation with our children escalates or get resolved.

Dev and Nurit decide to start using this strategy to help them implement a plan that they think is best for Zoara—that would help her accept both mommy and daddy as trusted, loving caregivers.

Read Raising Well-Behaved Kids: Mistaken vs. Smart Discipline

How to apply the three steps

It goes like this:

1) Dev describes exactly what is happening, without judgment or anger:

“I want to read to you, but you are having a hard time listening.”

2) He employs the mommy/daddy moment:

“I am going to take a daddy moment to think about how I can help us solve this problem.” Then Dev starts tapping his head and brainstorms to himself aloud so Zoara is privy to his process: “Hmm, I see that Zoara really wants mommy to read her books. I get that; she loves book-time with mommy which is great. But mommy and I both want to have a chance to read with Zoara so we have decided to take turns reading each night.

Speak to your children as if they are the wisest

It’s okay if Zoara doesn’t agree with our plan; that’s a mommy/daddy decision. So, let’s see what Zoara’s two choices might be. Hmm… well, I guess they are, one—she can choose to listen to the books; or, two—she can choose not to listen as I read. That’s totally up to her. I can’t force her to listen.”

During this time Zoara is stopped short in her tracks, totally mesmerized by dad’s musings. Witnessing a parent’s calm, rational and respectful thought process often results in kids just decided to cooperate with whatever direction you’ve given them. Even if that is not the result, it is a great exercise for parents. It gives you a concrete way to think through the problem which is calming and clarifying.

Read 6 Effective Ways To Earn Your Child’s Respect

3) Dev presents the “two great choices” to Zoara:

“Ok, sweetie, here are your two choices: you can listen to the books, which I would love, because I really enjoy sharing books with you; or, you can choose not to listen. That’s up to you. But it is a daddy book night so I am going to read and then say goodnight. Mommy has said her goodnight and you will see her in the morning.”

Dev doesn’t give Zoara any fodder to react to (i.e., demand that she listen and put all his energy into trying to get her to change her behavior) and instead moves along with the plan calmly and lovingly. This, together with Nurit not running to the rescue, results in Zoara eventually settling down into dad’s lap.

Of course, it doesn’t always work out so swimmingly with kids immediately complying, but that’s not the point. The purpose of this strategy is to have a plan that enables you to implement the limit whether your child agrees to the plan or not. Often parents dealing with a similar parental preference situation take the same approach, but the child doesn’t accept the limit on the first go-around. The parents don’t get reactive and stay the course.

The “less preferred parent” reads the books even as the child is refusing to participate and then says a loving goodnight, even in the face of the child’s protests. This shows the child that this parent is there for her no matter what—which is exactly what she needs. The purpose of this approach is to show your child that you are her rock and are not going to participate in an unhealthy dynamic, no matter how hard she tries to draw you into it. Usually, within a few nights of sticking to the plan, children adapt—a positive for everyone.

This approach of taking a mommy/daddy moment is even more powerful when you do it together with your partner. Consider Charlie, who is refusing to turn off his video game when his moms tell him the time is up. Sarah says to Beth: “Hmm, mommy, we have asked Charlie to turn off the tablet, but he is having a hard time with that direction.

Let’s take a mama/mommy moment to think about how we can help Charlie with this problem.” The moms then talk it out in front of Charlie in the same respectful, matter-of-fact way described above.

They come up with two great choices:

Charlie can hand the tablet over and get his afternoon tablet time. If he chooses not to give it up voluntarily, they will have to take it out of his hands (which they add may feel uncomfortable for everyone but is what they will need to do) and he won’t get his tablet time later in the day.

Whichever choice Charlie makes leads to the important outcome—that the tablet goes away when screen time is over. This approach provides a very positive, powerful model of parents collaborating to solve a problem. And it gets parents out of the good cop, bad cop roles that often evolve in families.

Please share this article with anyone who you may think will find it valuable and helpful.


Written by: Claire Lerner
Pre-order her book coming out 9/2021: Why is My Child in Charge?
Originally appeared on: Lerner Child Development
Republished with permission 
Your Child Needs You to Be Responsive, Not Reactive Here’s How pin

— Share —

Published On:

Last updated on:

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

Should Parents Set Consequences for Misbehavior or Not?

Should Parents Set Consequences For Misbehavior? Key Points

You want your child to grow up responsible and disciplined, but should you set consequences for misbehavior? Let’s learn the right balance between discipline and understanding.

Should we set consequences for our children when they don’t do what we want?

Key points

Research shows that physical punishment predicts negative outcomes in children.

Authoritative parenting has been found to be the most effective style that yields the happiest children.

Parents need to be able to tolerate their children being upset, disappointed, sad, or even angry with them.

Up Next

Does Gentle Parenting Work?

Does Gentle Parenting Style Work? Important Things To Know

Can setting firm boundaries with kindness raise well-behaved kids, or does it lead to entitlement and defiance? Let’s learn more about gentle parenting style!

A look at the data on gentle parenting.

Key points

The concept of Gentle Parenting is not based on scientific data.

Gentle Parenting does incorporate some very good parenting techniques.

Gentle Parenting may ask too much of parents.

What Is Gentle Parenting Style?

Up Next

Let Kids Be Kids? 6 Identifying Signs of Hurried Child Syndrome

Clear Hurried Child Syndrome Symptoms

Some of us felt the pressure to grow up too fast… meet deadlines, succeed academically, and always be on top of things—before we were even ready. It turns out, this pressure is real for some children today, and it’s called Hurried Child Syndrome. Let’s explore more about this condition.

What Is Hurried Child Syndrome?

Wondering what is Hurried Child Syndrome? It re

Up Next

Hovering Too Hard? 7 Mistakes Parents Who Overparent Often Make

Mistakes Parents Who Overparent Make: Hovering Too Hard?

It’s easy for parents who overparent to fall into the trap of doing too much in the name of love and care. But sometimes, all that hovering and controlling can backfire in surprising ways. Let’s break down the seven common mistakes and how to avoid them!

KEY POINTS

Overprotective parenting can have a negative impact on children’s mental health and relationships.

If you recognize any of these signs in yourself, it’s important to take steps to change your behavior.

Encourage your child to try new things, let them make mistakes, take risks, and solve problems on their own.

Up Next

Is Your Daughter in a Controlling Relationship? 9 Ways to Help Her Break Free

Daughter in a Controlling Relationship? Things You Can Do

Have you ever had a very strong gut feeling that your daughter might not be in a healthy relationship? Or that she is in a relationship with a controlling boyfriend? Today we are going to talk about what you can do, when you have a daughter in a controlling relationship.

Yeah, it’s a tough pill to swallow. Bossy boyfriends sneakily isolate, manipulate and dim the light in the people they date. And if your daughter is dating someone like this, then it’s understandable how tough it can be to watch that.

However, there’s always light at the end of the tunnel – as her mother, you can help her break free from her controlling boyfriend. This isn’t about swooping in like a superhero; it’s about being smart, supportive, and steady.

First, let’s start with trying to understand who a controlling boyfriend

Up Next

8 Undeniable Signs She’s Destined to Be an A+ Mom

Qualities of a Good Mother That Guarantee A+ Parenting!

Moms are superheroes, plain and simple. But being a great mom isn’t just about keeping the fridge stocked and making sure homework gets done. It’s about making your kids feel loved, valued, and truly understood. Moms are often the first and biggest influence in a child’s life, shaping how they see themselves and the world.

Being a good mom is about way more than just keeping a kid alive (though, yes, that’s non-negotiable). It’s about showing up with love, wisdom, and that unshakable belief in her kid’s potential. Moms help mold who we are and how we see the world.

Up Next

Divorce And Holidays: 5 Co-Parenting Tips To Help Kids Enjoy Christmas

Helpful Divorce And Holidays Coping Tips For Parents

The festive season is often described as the most wonderful time of the year. However, divorce and holidays can be tricky to navigate for some families, it’s not only challenging for kids but also for their parents.

Children deserve to be in happy and healthy homes, a safe space to enjoy and make memories rather than facing bickering fights and drama.

If you’re co parenting on Christmas, create a holiday season that’s joyful and comforting for your children. Below are five practical divorce and holidays coping tips to help your kids enjoy the festivities, even after a separation or divorce.