4 Warning Signs Of A Toxic Leader


, ,
Warning Signs Of A Toxic Leader

Have you ever worked with a toxic boss or toxic leader? If you have, then you know how horrible and malicious they really are, and if you haven’t, then read on to know the signs of a toxic leader so that it’s easier for you to understand what you are dealing with.


  • Poor, toxic leaders demand unquestioning loyalty and service to the leader.
  • Bad leaders rule by a sense of fear, both of outsiders and of the leader’s wrath.
  • Good leadership empowers followers, shows concern for them, and benefits the collective.

All too often, people fall prey to self-serving leaders, who exploit their followers for personal gain. In order to do so, they use a number of psychological tactics to manipulate people and gain power.

All leaders use power and persuasion in order to lead, and there’s nothing wrong with that. Followers are expected to comply with the leader’s requests, to show loyalty, and to work toward a shared goal or outcome.

As a result, leaders build commitment, and together with followers, are able to accomplish things.

Often, however, there is a fine line between a leader’s use of power in positive ways and the abuse of power. Toxic leaders use power to command and control, and they are more concerned about their own selfish needs and goals than about those of the collective.

In addition, truly insidious toxic leaders are well-versed in basic, psychological strategies that make it easy to control followers and get them to do the leader’s bidding.

Here are some warning signs of a toxic leader.

Related: Toxic Bosses Unmasked: 20 Warning Signs to Watch For

4 Warning Signs Of A Toxic Leader

1. They create “enemies.”

Human beings are especially prone to forming strong bonds with others who are similar and who are familiar, and they are wary of people who are different—those who are part of the “outgroup.”

This psychological phenomenon is known as in-group/out-group bias or the we-they effect.

It is this tendency that builds cohesiveness among team members, and, in organizations and teams, can lead to competitiveness with other organizations and teams. A good leader can harness this in order to motivate team members to “beat the competition.”

A toxic leader, on the other hand, exploits this and vilifies outgroup members as a way to build solidarity in their team of followers: “We are the good guys, they are the bad guys. We are right, they are wrong. They are a threat.”

It’s important to note that In-group/out-group bias is at the root of prejudice and discrimination.

We see in-group/out-group bias in politics when leaders use opposing groups as targeted scapegoats and portray them as evil (e.g., referring to opposing nations as “evil empires”). Differences are magnified, while similarities are ignored.

We see this in international struggles, in our increasingly partisan politics, in rival street gangs, and in our communities where leaders allow the “other guys” to be vilified, primarily to solidify their followers’ support.

This demonizing of outgroups, such as referring to them as “criminals” or “animals,” creates fear, but it can also bring out the worst in human nature—leading to attacks on outgroup members.

Signs of a toxic leader
4 Warning Signs Of A Toxic Leader

2. They demand unquestioning loyalty.

Toxic leaders require blind obedience from followers. Followers are not allowed to question the leader’s decisions, or motives, and anyone who objects or disagrees with the leader is threatened, punished, or ostracized.

3. They rule by fear.

The easiest way for a leader to gain the unquestioning, blind allegiance of followers is to create fear. This relates to the vilifying of outsiders (“They are dangerous.” “They are a threat to our way of life.”).

4. They promise protection.

Once fear is stoked, the toxic leader promises protection and emphasizes that the leader is the only one who can do this. This helps build followers’ total dependence on the leader.

Using these basic psychological principles, bad leaders can fairly easily get the unempowered and unsuspecting followers to unquestioningly do their bidding.

Related: Top 10 Bad Leadership Behaviors That Destroy Organisations

What Does Good Leadership Look Like?

Good leaders:

1. Unify and don’t divide.

Good leaders never create divisions in their constituents nor create an us-vs.-them effect.

2. Achieve results but limit collateral damage.

A good leader is effective, but never at the cost of hurting the well-being of followers or destroying the environment or the social structure. They don’t turn potential friends into foes.

Signs of a toxic leader
4 Warning Signs Of A Toxic Leader

3. Share the leadership with followers.

They work with followers, consulting with them, caring for them, and developing their shared leadership capacity.


Lipman-Blumen, J. (2006). The allure of toxic leaders: Why we follow destructive bosses and corrupt politicians--and how we can survive them. Oxford University Press, USA.

Shamir, B. (1991). The charismatic relationship: Alternative explanations and predictions. The leadership quarterly, 2(2), 81-104.

Riggio, R.E. (1987). The charisma quotient. NY: Dodd Mead.

Written By Ronald Riggio
Originally Appeared On Psychology Today
toxic leader
4 Warning Signs Of A Toxic Leader

— Share —

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Up Next

4 Hidden Perks Of Having A Best Friend At Work

Benefits Of Having A Best Friend at Work: Do You Have One

Having a best friend at work is not just about having fun during lunch breaks or discussing the latest office gossip. It is a valuable relationship that can support you during stressful times. Learn how to make work friends if you’re struggling to!

According to Research, ​work friends are crucial for your health​. This is because positive relationships foster shared purpose and accountability that pushes us to strive for excellence.

So without further adieu let’s learn the main benefits of having a best friend at work. Let’s go!

Up Next

Office Personality Test: Leader or a Social Butterfly? Which Role Fits You Best?

Fun Office Personality Test: Types - Which One Are You?

We devote nearly half of our day in the office – our second home! So, it’s important to understand what personality we possess at this place. Therefore, take this office personality test and discover who you are professionally!

In this workplace personality test your desk is your fortress, and coffee breaks are sacred rituals. But amidst all the busy days, have you ever wondered what kind of office personality you have? Let’s find out which one of these office personality types fits you best!

Up Next

Navigating the Dynamics of Workplace Friendship: 8 Dos and Don’ts

Workplace Friendship Dynamics: Effective Dos and Don'ts

They say your co-worker can be your biggest enemy, but this doesn’t have to be true. By following a few simple rules for workplace friendships, you can build lasting and supportive relationships with your colleagues.

However, these relationships come with their own set of challenges that require careful navigation. Here are some do’s and don’ts to help you find a buddy for life and cherish your work relationships more.

Understanding Workplace Friendship Dynamics

Up Next

5 Examples of Relationship Boundaries: Set Up Healthy Relationship Standards

Examples of Relationship Boundaries for a Healthy Life

What keeps relationships healthy and thriving? Is it love? respect? Well, you’d be surprised to know that the answer is “Boundaries”. Curious about how they work? Here are five essential examples of relationship boundaries that ensure mutual respect, trust, and happiness.

The big question is, “What are relationship boundaries? And do most loving relationships need it?” It’s subjective. We feel differently in different situations because our personalities are different too. So we have to know our relationship traits and set boundaries accordingly.

If you’re thinking of setting boundaries in relationships, then read more below!

What Are Relationship Boundaries?


Up Next

Empathic Leadership: 5 Top Traits Of Leaders Who Lead With Heart

Empathic Leadership: Clear Traits Of An Empathetic Leader

Empathic leadership is all about leading with heart. Let’s explore the top 5 traits of an empathetic leader and how to truly be compassionate and effective in connecting with your team.

Empathy is a vital leadership skill in our world.

There’s a hunger for empathic leadership in many organizations including corporations, governments, medical centers, and small businesses across the globe.

What Is Empathic Leadership?

Recently the Global Empathy Index, which is published in the Harvard Business Review, examined data from employees’ responses to questions ranging from a CEO’s approval ranking to their own happiness level in their job.

Up Next

“I Don’t Want To Work Anymore!”: 8 Reasons Why You Are Tired Of The Daily Grind

"I Don't Want To Work Anymore!": Reasons Why You Hate Work

Do you constantly say to yourself “I don’t want to work anymore!!”? Hey, we’ve all been there. Staring at our alarm clocks, dreading the sound that signals another long day of work. The thought of dragging yourself out of bed and getting ready to do the same everyday routine can be downright depressing.

In this fast-paced world, it’s no wonder that many of us have reached a breaking point when it comes to the daily grind. But the question is, why do we feel this way? Is it normal to not want to work anymore? What are the reasons for not wanting to go to work?

Well, grab a cup of coffee (or a glass of wine, absolutely no judgment here!), because we’re about to delve into eight relatable reasons why you might be telling yourself “I don’t want to work anymore”.

Up Next

Toxic Bosses Unmasked: 20 Warning Signs to Watch For

Toxic Bosses Unmasked: Warning Signs to Watch For

Having a toxic boss can really take a toll on you mentally, and toxic bosses are seriously so horrible. This article is going to help you understand the traits of a toxic boss so that you know which behaviors are not normal and ethical. Read on to know more about the signs of a toxic boss or toxic bosses.

We hear about toxic bosses all the time, but how do you know when a boss is “toxic”? “Toxic” is, of course, a vague descriptor. Are bosses toxic when they throw fits and scream, or only when they break the law?

Or are they toxic when they are immoral or unethical? Are they toxic if they’re nice one day and nasty the next, or just when they make you uncomfortable, nervous, or sick? These are valid questions because these individuals are easy to identify when their behaviors are outrageous; but perhaps less so when their behavior