An Open Letter To The Guy Who Made A Fool Of Me

Author : Kirsten Corley

It is hard to quit sometimes despite seeing the red flags in someone, so hereโ€™s an open letter to the man who broke my heart. I made a fool of myself, but now Iโ€™ve learned and I will gain wisdom from it.

โ€œI wish no one would ever mess with your head or send you mixed signals. Like they were so into one day and then blew you off the next. I wish no one would wait two days to text you back, because you know they had their phone off them the entire time.
Because I only want things to be simple for you. And I only want you to be happy. Because you deserve that. Because you deserve people being honest with you.โ€ -Taylor Swift 

An Open Letter To The Man Who Broke My Heart

Even saying your name to my friends, left them questioning why I was giving you another chance. Cause it wasnโ€™t just a second chance but rather chance 5,650. But there was something about you, I thought I saw something in you. I thought if I just kept trying, maybe we could get it right.

An Open Letter To The Man Who Broke My Heart

What I didnโ€™t realize was, I was playing a game, I was bound to lose the whole time.

I didnโ€™t see it then though. Because Iโ€™m not the type to give up on people. Iโ€™m not the type to ever walk away, I give people my best every time and hope itโ€™s reciprocated.

I wanted to believe in you. 

I thought I saw something in you. In fact, I know I did. I saw bits and pieces of the man you could be, but it takes the right woman to bring out the man in a boy. Maybe I wasnโ€™t right. Maybe we werenโ€™t right.

And everyone told me I was playing with fire with you. They told me I was gonna get burnt. They told me donโ€™t walk towards danger. They saw what I didnโ€™t want to. We see things when we want to, not always when we need to.

Related: 7 Ways Your Heartbreak Makes You Wiser

I was willing to fight for you. 

I didnโ€™t care what people said about you. I didnโ€™t care about your reputation. I didnโ€™t care about how many times you hurt me and left me alone and crying. For some reason my heart chose you and I followed it, fearlessly.

to the man who broke my heart

Everyone said such horrible things about you. Even people saying your name left everyoneโ€™s tongues bitter and wanting to change the subject. Every conversation with everyone ended with, โ€œI hate him.โ€

But I didnโ€™t. I loved you more than anyone. And I would have done anything for you.

I wanted to prove, everyone wrong about you. 

I wanted so badly to prove to everyone they were wrong. I wanted everyone to see you in the light I did. But more than that I think in my stubborn nature, I didnโ€™t want to be wrong. I didnโ€™t want to look back at this all and realize I wasted my time. I wanted everyone to like you the way I did. But it wasnโ€™t just like, it was a cruel game of love that swallowed me whole.

But you broke meโ€ฆ 

I remember standing there, as the calls went right to voicemail. I remember looking at my phone as texts were delivered, but no response. I remember going to bed every night crying for so long. I donโ€™t know what I did to deserve any of that.

to the man who broke my heart

All I ever did was love you the best I could.

But you left me high and dry when you were done with me.

You were quick to make phone calls in the late hours of the night and I answered every time. I gave you what you wanted. If you asked me to come, I would have.

But you used me.

I believed you when you told me weโ€™d get it right eventually. I held onto that. I held onto every conversation. I reread messages as you told me you loved me because I truly did love you. I loved you more than anyone. I would have chosen you first. I would have loved you with everything I was capable of. I would have given you the best of me.

Read To the Guy Who I Thought I Would Grow Old with

Then left me to pick up the pieces. 

And all you could reciprocate was thanking me for being a temporary fix until you got the real thing. But to me, you were the real thing. You were every thought at night. You were every wish. But I didnโ€™t mean as much to you.

to the man who broke my heart

And you let me go and you walked away, not looking back.

And I was the fool, for being surprised.

And no one said I told you so. Because, when you place your bets on the one person no one else wants to, that moment you lose, youโ€™re left to deal with it on your own. Because you know everyone was right.

So I took my tears and silently wept, in the privacy of my room, as the darkness screamed your name so loudly.

I was the only one to believe in you. I was the only one to love you as I did. I was the only one who saw good and didnโ€™t define you by how badly you treated me.

You made a fool of me. And I promised myself after you, no one would ever do such a thing to me again.

I know you arenโ€™t defined by who you are at your worst. I know the man youโ€™ll amount to one day. But getting there took breaking the one person, who loved you most of all. I just hope it was worth it.

I hope when you speak my name, it sends shivers of regret, throughout your body. I hope my name tastes as bitter, coming off your tongue, as yours does me.

But most of all I do wish you the best. The best though was always me, and thatโ€™s what youโ€™ll live with or rather without because if ever you do come back, thatโ€™s a call Iโ€™ll let go right to voicemail.

โ€œOh, and the award for The best lie goes to you For making me believeโ€ฆLetโ€™s hear your speech, oh How about a round of applause A standing ovation But you put on quite a show Really had me going.โ€ -Rihanna 

Read 5 Ways Setting Expectations After Breaking Up Can Help You Move On

Written by Kirsten Corley. For more of Kirsten's work, follow her Facebook fan page.

To The Guy Who Made a Fool Of Me
To The Guy Who Made a Fool Of Me

Published On:

Last updated on:

Kirsten Corley

My name is Kirsten Corley. Both writer by day, hopeless romantic by night live my life with a simple motto. โ€˜What can I do for youโ€™ I believe our lives are only as good as the people whoโ€™s lives you make better. I strive to help readers gain an understanding of intense emotions, like heartbreak and getting through it. I think together we have the ability to overcome the challenges life throws our way and even in those times you hit rock bottom, I see it as a wonderful platform to begin again.

Disclaimer: The informational content on The Minds Journal have been created and reviewed by qualified mental health professionals. They are intended solely for educational and self-awareness purposes and should not be used as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. If you are experiencing emotional distress or have concerns about your mental health, please seek help from a licensed mental health professional or healthcare provider.

Leave a Comment

Today's Horoscope

Weekly Horoscope PART one

Weekly Horoscope 15 March to 21 March 2026

Read your zodiac signโ€™s prediction to understand the energy surrounding you and how to make the most of the days ahead!

Latest Quizzes

Interesting Finger Personality Test: 4 Finger Lines

Finger Personality Test: Join Your Fingers And Reveal A Hidden Personality Secret!

Look closely at your finger lines. Which pattern do you see? This personality test might surprise you!

Latest Quotes

How Men Show Love Through Actions (Male Psychology in Relationships)

How Men Show Love Through Actions (Male Psychology in Relationships)

Male psychology in relationships shows that men express love through presence, protection, and peace more than poetry. Decode his actions so you can see how deeply he actually cares.

Readers Blog

Caption This Image and Selected Wisepicks โ€“ 15 March 2026

Caption This Image and Selected Wisepicks โ€“ 15 March 2026

Ready to unleash your inner wordsmith? โœจ??โ˜บ๏ธ Nowโ€™s your chance to show off your wit, charm, or sheer genius in just one line! Whether itโ€™s laugh-out-loud funny or surprisingly deep, we want to hear it.Submit your funniest, wittiest, or most thought-provoking caption in the comments. Weโ€™ll pick 15+ winners to be featured on our website…

Latest Articles

It is hard to quit sometimes despite seeing the red flags in someone, so hereโ€™s an open letter to the man who broke my heart. I made a fool of myself, but now Iโ€™ve learned and I will gain wisdom from it.

โ€œI wish no one would ever mess with your head or send you mixed signals. Like they were so into one day and then blew you off the next. I wish no one would wait two days to text you back, because you know they had their phone off them the entire time.
Because I only want things to be simple for you. And I only want you to be happy. Because you deserve that. Because you deserve people being honest with you.โ€ -Taylor Swift 

An Open Letter To The Man Who Broke My Heart

Even saying your name to my friends, left them questioning why I was giving you another chance. Cause it wasnโ€™t just a second chance but rather chance 5,650. But there was something about you, I thought I saw something in you. I thought if I just kept trying, maybe we could get it right.

An Open Letter To The Man Who Broke My Heart

What I didnโ€™t realize was, I was playing a game, I was bound to lose the whole time.

I didnโ€™t see it then though. Because Iโ€™m not the type to give up on people. Iโ€™m not the type to ever walk away, I give people my best every time and hope itโ€™s reciprocated.

I wanted to believe in you. 

I thought I saw something in you. In fact, I know I did. I saw bits and pieces of the man you could be, but it takes the right woman to bring out the man in a boy. Maybe I wasnโ€™t right. Maybe we werenโ€™t right.

And everyone told me I was playing with fire with you. They told me I was gonna get burnt. They told me donโ€™t walk towards danger. They saw what I didnโ€™t want to. We see things when we want to, not always when we need to.

Related: 7 Ways Your Heartbreak Makes You Wiser

I was willing to fight for you. 

I didnโ€™t care what people said about you. I didnโ€™t care about your reputation. I didnโ€™t care about how many times you hurt me and left me alone and crying. For some reason my heart chose you and I followed it, fearlessly.

to the man who broke my heart

Everyone said such horrible things about you. Even people saying your name left everyoneโ€™s tongues bitter and wanting to change the subject. Every conversation with everyone ended with, โ€œI hate him.โ€

But I didnโ€™t. I loved you more than anyone. And I would have done anything for you.

I wanted to prove, everyone wrong about you. 

I wanted so badly to prove to everyone they were wrong. I wanted everyone to see you in the light I did. But more than that I think in my stubborn nature, I didnโ€™t want to be wrong. I didnโ€™t want to look back at this all and realize I wasted my time. I wanted everyone to like you the way I did. But it wasnโ€™t just like, it was a cruel game of love that swallowed me whole.

But you broke meโ€ฆ 

I remember standing there, as the calls went right to voicemail. I remember looking at my phone as texts were delivered, but no response. I remember going to bed every night crying for so long. I donโ€™t know what I did to deserve any of that.

to the man who broke my heart

All I ever did was love you the best I could.

But you left me high and dry when you were done with me.

You were quick to make phone calls in the late hours of the night and I answered every time. I gave you what you wanted. If you asked me to come, I would have.

But you used me.

I believed you when you told me weโ€™d get it right eventually. I held onto that. I held onto every conversation. I reread messages as you told me you loved me because I truly did love you. I loved you more than anyone. I would have chosen you first. I would have loved you with everything I was capable of. I would have given you the best of me.

Read To the Guy Who I Thought I Would Grow Old with

Then left me to pick up the pieces. 

And all you could reciprocate was thanking me for being a temporary fix until you got the real thing. But to me, you were the real thing. You were every thought at night. You were every wish. But I didnโ€™t mean as much to you.

to the man who broke my heart

And you let me go and you walked away, not looking back.

And I was the fool, for being surprised.

And no one said I told you so. Because, when you place your bets on the one person no one else wants to, that moment you lose, youโ€™re left to deal with it on your own. Because you know everyone was right.

So I took my tears and silently wept, in the privacy of my room, as the darkness screamed your name so loudly.

I was the only one to believe in you. I was the only one to love you as I did. I was the only one who saw good and didnโ€™t define you by how badly you treated me.

You made a fool of me. And I promised myself after you, no one would ever do such a thing to me again.

I know you arenโ€™t defined by who you are at your worst. I know the man youโ€™ll amount to one day. But getting there took breaking the one person, who loved you most of all. I just hope it was worth it.

I hope when you speak my name, it sends shivers of regret, throughout your body. I hope my name tastes as bitter, coming off your tongue, as yours does me.

But most of all I do wish you the best. The best though was always me, and thatโ€™s what youโ€™ll live with or rather without because if ever you do come back, thatโ€™s a call Iโ€™ll let go right to voicemail.

โ€œOh, and the award for The best lie goes to you For making me believeโ€ฆLetโ€™s hear your speech, oh How about a round of applause A standing ovation But you put on quite a show Really had me going.โ€ -Rihanna 

Read 5 Ways Setting Expectations After Breaking Up Can Help You Move On

Written by Kirsten Corley. For more of Kirsten's work, follow her Facebook fan page.

To The Guy Who Made a Fool Of Me
To The Guy Who Made a Fool Of Me

Published On:

Last updated on:

Kirsten Corley

My name is Kirsten Corley. Both writer by day, hopeless romantic by night live my life with a simple motto. โ€˜What can I do for youโ€™ I believe our lives are only as good as the people whoโ€™s lives you make better. I strive to help readers gain an understanding of intense emotions, like heartbreak and getting through it. I think together we have the ability to overcome the challenges life throws our way and even in those times you hit rock bottom, I see it as a wonderful platform to begin again.

Leave a Comment

    Leave a Comment