How To Trust Your Gut And Stand Up For Yourself When Your Man Says You’re Overreacting

Author : Nancy Nichols

Have you ever encountered a situation where you were 100% sure about what and why you’re doing, but you man says you’re overreacting? Maybe you should learn to trust your gut feelings.




My fiancé knew exactly what to say to wound me and knock me off balance. Like many others, you sometimes don’t know how to stand up for yourself, and this was the case for me.

One evening at dinner, he zinged me with a snide remark about my weight (I was a size 8). He jeered, “Ya know, the problem with fat people is they never leave anything on their plate. When you finish eating, I don’t even have to wash your plate.”



I told him his comment hurt my feelings. He retorted, “Jeez, You said you wanted to lose weight. I was trying to help you. I’ll just leave you alone from now on.”

He made me feel guilty, but in my gut, I knew it was his attempt to throw me off track.

Children sometimes grow up with a weak sense of self. And when you don’t trust your gut, you leave yourself vulnerable.

Growing up I heard statements like, “You shouldn’t feel that way. You’re overreacting,” and, “You’re being too sensitive, Nancy.” While these statements seemed harmless and insignificant, it was put-down phrases like these which told me my feelings were incorrect and taught me to doubt, deny and stuff my hurt feelings.




As an adult, I doubted my self-worth and I questioned my ability to understand people who were manipulative and controlling. I even doubted my gut feelings.

Related: How Cognitive Distortions Harm Us

Even though my gut feeling told me to, I couldn’t confront a girlfriend who treated me unfairly. I didn’t know how to deal with and a conniving coworker. I struggled to maintain healthy boundaries with my overbearing mother and sharp-tongued, calculating daughter.

I was afraid to stand up to the people I loved because I didn’t want to seem irrational, unreasonable or ungrateful. I was naïve, gullible and trusting. I didn’t trust my judgments about men. I evaluated men (and everyone) with my impressionable, impulsive emotions.

When I dated a guy, I struggled to figure him out. I blamed myself for my relationship problems (because he told me I was at fault). I whined to my girlfriend, “Do you think he likes me?” “What should I say or do next?” “Do you think he’ll call me again?” “Why did he stop calling me?” And, of course, “What did I do wrong?” I made bad relationship choices and I got my heart broken frequently.

I was accustomed to the accusing, disparaging, befuddling statements that a man would hurl at me during an argument.




Related: 14 Tips and Tricks To Master Your Intuition

He’d growl, “That’s not what I said,” or “You heard that wrong,” or “I don’t remember saying that,” or “What’s wrong with you? I was only joking!” When those digs failed to squelch my spirit my man would use his well-honed jab, “You’re overreacting” — code for: “What’s wrong with you?”

I wondered: Was I being overly sensitive to his seemingly spiteful, wounding remarks? Could I have misheard or misinterpreted what felt like a hard slap in the face? Am I the one who is destroying our relationship, like he says I am?

And then I began to ask myself: If I misunderstood what he said, or if he didn’t say what I heard him say: Why then did I hurt so bad inside? Am I that much out of touch with reality?

The book Blink presents the power of “thin-slicing.” It states that “thin-slicing” — that is, our first subconscious, split-second, knee-jerk reaction — is our most intellectual and accurate observation and that it is the feeling we should trust.

The book explains that you must practice and perfect the skill of thin-slicing (taking in a very thin slice of information and making an accurate prediction or assessment) in order to instinctively eliminate confusing and unimportant incoming data that can lead to a bad decision (e.g., my fiancé’s charm, braggadocio and exciting personality caused me to discount the obvious fact that he was, in fact, a flagrant, lying dirt bag).

Related: 10 Things He’ll Say If He’s Only Stringing You Along




A scumbag may fool your heart, but he can’t fool your ability to trust your gut.

Whenever your man says you’re overreacting or when a boyfriend tries to put you down, know this: A man’s discounting, dismissive, blaming statements are designed to make YOU doubt your ability to reason and understand a dysfunctional relationship.

Trust your inner knowing.

Don’t let a man or anyone talk you out of your feelings. Subconsciously you know the truth.

trust your gut

You suspect he’s lying. You did NOT misconstrue what he said.

You are NOT overreacting to manipulative, disparaging comments uttered by your man. You DID interpret his demeaning remarks correctly. You sense that he is shifting the blame to conceal his bad behaviour.


Written by Nancy Nichols 
Originally Published on knowitallnancy.com
Nancy Nichols is a self-esteem and dating coach and best-selling author of many books. Browse her books here




When Your Man Says You're Overreacting Think Again.
Trust Gut Stand Up For Yourself When Man Overreacting pin


Published On:

Last updated on:

Nancy Nichols

Nancy Nichols is a best-selling author, empowerment speaker, and the notorious Know-It-All Nancy blogger. Her self-help books promote self-esteem, relationship understanding and personal healing for women. Her book trilogy includes Secrets of the Ultimate Husband Hunter, Never Date A Dead Animal and God, Please Fix Me! You can find Nancy and her books at www.knowitallnancy.com

Disclaimer: The informational content on The Minds Journal have been created and reviewed by qualified mental health professionals. They are intended solely for educational and self-awareness purposes and should not be used as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. If you are experiencing emotional distress or have concerns about your mental health, please seek help from a licensed mental health professional or healthcare provider.

Leave a Comment

Today's Horoscope

Daily Horoscope 17 March 2026: Prediction for Zodiac Signs

Daily Horoscope 17 March, 2026: Prediction for Each Zodiac Sign

Today carries a calm, thoughtful kind of energy that may not be obvious at first.

Latest Quizzes

Interesting Finger Personality Test: 4 Finger Lines

Finger Personality Test: Join Your Fingers And Reveal A Hidden Personality Secret!

Look closely at your finger lines. Which pattern do you see? This personality test might surprise you!

Latest Quotes

8 Clear Signs a Man Is Not Serious About You

8 Clear Signs a Man Is Not Serious About You

If you are confused about his intentions, paying attention to the signs he is not serious about you can save you time, energy, and heartbreak. Here are eight clear red flags that show he’s not truly invested.

Readers Blog

Caption This Image and Selected Wisepicks – 15 March 2026

Caption This Image and Selected Wisepicks – 15 March 2026

Ready to unleash your inner wordsmith? ✨??☺️ Now’s your chance to show off your wit, charm, or sheer genius in just one line! Whether it’s laugh-out-loud funny or surprisingly deep, we want to hear it.Submit your funniest, wittiest, or most thought-provoking caption in the comments. We’ll pick 15+ winners to be featured on our website…

Latest Articles

Have you ever encountered a situation where you were 100% sure about what and why you’re doing, but you man says you’re overreacting? Maybe you should learn to trust your gut feelings.




My fiancé knew exactly what to say to wound me and knock me off balance. Like many others, you sometimes don’t know how to stand up for yourself, and this was the case for me.

One evening at dinner, he zinged me with a snide remark about my weight (I was a size 8). He jeered, “Ya know, the problem with fat people is they never leave anything on their plate. When you finish eating, I don’t even have to wash your plate.”



I told him his comment hurt my feelings. He retorted, “Jeez, You said you wanted to lose weight. I was trying to help you. I’ll just leave you alone from now on.”

He made me feel guilty, but in my gut, I knew it was his attempt to throw me off track.

Children sometimes grow up with a weak sense of self. And when you don’t trust your gut, you leave yourself vulnerable.

Growing up I heard statements like, “You shouldn’t feel that way. You’re overreacting,” and, “You’re being too sensitive, Nancy.” While these statements seemed harmless and insignificant, it was put-down phrases like these which told me my feelings were incorrect and taught me to doubt, deny and stuff my hurt feelings.




As an adult, I doubted my self-worth and I questioned my ability to understand people who were manipulative and controlling. I even doubted my gut feelings.

Related: How Cognitive Distortions Harm Us

Even though my gut feeling told me to, I couldn’t confront a girlfriend who treated me unfairly. I didn’t know how to deal with and a conniving coworker. I struggled to maintain healthy boundaries with my overbearing mother and sharp-tongued, calculating daughter.

I was afraid to stand up to the people I loved because I didn’t want to seem irrational, unreasonable or ungrateful. I was naïve, gullible and trusting. I didn’t trust my judgments about men. I evaluated men (and everyone) with my impressionable, impulsive emotions.

When I dated a guy, I struggled to figure him out. I blamed myself for my relationship problems (because he told me I was at fault). I whined to my girlfriend, “Do you think he likes me?” “What should I say or do next?” “Do you think he’ll call me again?” “Why did he stop calling me?” And, of course, “What did I do wrong?” I made bad relationship choices and I got my heart broken frequently.

I was accustomed to the accusing, disparaging, befuddling statements that a man would hurl at me during an argument.




Related: 14 Tips and Tricks To Master Your Intuition

He’d growl, “That’s not what I said,” or “You heard that wrong,” or “I don’t remember saying that,” or “What’s wrong with you? I was only joking!” When those digs failed to squelch my spirit my man would use his well-honed jab, “You’re overreacting” — code for: “What’s wrong with you?”

I wondered: Was I being overly sensitive to his seemingly spiteful, wounding remarks? Could I have misheard or misinterpreted what felt like a hard slap in the face? Am I the one who is destroying our relationship, like he says I am?

And then I began to ask myself: If I misunderstood what he said, or if he didn’t say what I heard him say: Why then did I hurt so bad inside? Am I that much out of touch with reality?

The book Blink presents the power of “thin-slicing.” It states that “thin-slicing” — that is, our first subconscious, split-second, knee-jerk reaction — is our most intellectual and accurate observation and that it is the feeling we should trust.

The book explains that you must practice and perfect the skill of thin-slicing (taking in a very thin slice of information and making an accurate prediction or assessment) in order to instinctively eliminate confusing and unimportant incoming data that can lead to a bad decision (e.g., my fiancé’s charm, braggadocio and exciting personality caused me to discount the obvious fact that he was, in fact, a flagrant, lying dirt bag).

Related: 10 Things He’ll Say If He’s Only Stringing You Along




A scumbag may fool your heart, but he can’t fool your ability to trust your gut.

Whenever your man says you’re overreacting or when a boyfriend tries to put you down, know this: A man’s discounting, dismissive, blaming statements are designed to make YOU doubt your ability to reason and understand a dysfunctional relationship.

Trust your inner knowing.

Don’t let a man or anyone talk you out of your feelings. Subconsciously you know the truth.

trust your gut

You suspect he’s lying. You did NOT misconstrue what he said.

You are NOT overreacting to manipulative, disparaging comments uttered by your man. You DID interpret his demeaning remarks correctly. You sense that he is shifting the blame to conceal his bad behaviour.


Written by Nancy Nichols 
Originally Published on knowitallnancy.com
Nancy Nichols is a self-esteem and dating coach and best-selling author of many books. Browse her books here




When Your Man Says You're Overreacting Think Again.
Trust Gut Stand Up For Yourself When Man Overreacting pin


Published On:

Last updated on:

Nancy Nichols

Nancy Nichols is a best-selling author, empowerment speaker, and the notorious Know-It-All Nancy blogger. Her self-help books promote self-esteem, relationship understanding and personal healing for women. Her book trilogy includes Secrets of the Ultimate Husband Hunter, Never Date A Dead Animal and God, Please Fix Me! You can find Nancy and her books at www.knowitallnancy.com

Leave a Comment

    Leave a Comment