Do Kids Really Misbehave For Attention?

Written By:

Written By:

child behavior kids misbehave for attention 1

Itโ€™s normal for a kid to seek attention and approval from their parent and equally important for parents to reciprocate. However, the attention seeking habit becomes a problem when kids begin to show signs of bad behavior at school or with peers. So read on to better understand child behavior.




The case for a broader understanding of a child behavior, why kids misbehave and need for attention.

  • Traditionalย parentingย advice holds that kids misbehave for seekingย attention, even if itโ€™s negative, and so time-outs and other responses that avoid rewarding the child behavior are best.
  • Mote recent research, based on a growing understanding of developing brains, suggests almost the opposite: Responding with a โ€œtime in.โ€
  • It can be tempting as a parent to decide on one approach to discipline and follow it in every situation. In practice, flexibility will serve most families better.

Understanding Child Behavior

One of the ageless truisms in parenting is that attention-seeking is a primary motivation for a childโ€™s bad behavior. If little Johnny smacks his sister, throws a tantrum, or takes that extra cookie, we are often instructed to see this action as a strategic play to get mom or dad to stop doing what they are doing and pay attention to Johnny. 



Even negative attention is preferable to no attention at all, the adage continues. It follows then that a parentโ€™s next best move is to demonstrate to the child that such behavior doesnโ€™t โ€œworkโ€ through doing things like active ignoring or even a time-out that involves the deliberate withdrawal of parental focus. 

This theory has been a cornerstone of a number of evidence-based parent guidance programs. Combined with techniques designed to help parents give additional attention and praise to positive behaviors, these methods have been shown to be helpful for many, though certainly not all, children. 

Related: 8 Ways To Slow Down and Connect With Your Children At Home




But lately, both the techniques and the attention seeking hypothesis have been challenged. The momentum for this has come from a number of developments, including โ€“

1) increased appreciation for the effects of early trauma and adversity on developing brains,

2) awareness that these methods donโ€™t seem to help certain children and in some cases can make child behavior worse, and

3) additional understanding that self-regulation and relationships need to be taught rather than just reinforced.

As a result, many advocates and child development experts now encourage parents to respond in ways that are almost directly opposite to the traditional advice. Instead of giving your child a time-out when he gets out of control, for example, you give him a โ€œtime-inโ€ by engaging with him in a warm and sympathetic way to help him learn how to cope when he gets upset. Instead of demonstrating your authority by enforcing limits and rules, you negotiate and reason toward a solution that works for everyone.

If the experts canโ€™t seem to agree, the poor mother who has just witnessed her 4-year-old son throw a toy at his sibling is really confused as to her next step as she watches him run from the room, crying and yelling in full meltdown mode. Which โ€œcampโ€ does she belong to? Does she put the already upset child in time-out? Does she go try and calm him down and refrain from any punishments? Or does she just grab a glass of wine and let her son cool off on his own?




The major problem with these different perspectives and responses isnโ€™t that they are totally wrong but rather that they are incomplete. Most packaged approaches to disruptive or oppositional child behavior are generally portrayed as exclusive choices that one has to make when responding to all kids, all the time.

Related: Psychopathy in Children: How To Spot and Deal With Psychopathic Children

Sure, most of these advocates, when pinned down, will acknowledge that kids are different and that one approach doesnโ€™t work for everyone, but that admission is usually found in the fine print and does not feature very prominently at all in the blog posts, books, or training programs being offered. 

But hereโ€™s the messy, complicated, and wholly unsatisfying truthโ€ฆ sometimes kids misbehave for attention, sometimes they donโ€™t. Even worse, the reasons for negative child behavior in the same kid might be different at different times.

Ugh!

How Is That Supposed To Fit Into A Tweet? 

Itโ€™s not. Developing brains, it turns out, are pretty complex. Different techniques work for different kinds of kids, at different moments, and with different parents.

But this lack of easy answers is hardly a reason to throw your hands up in despair. A deep breath or two, some attempts to understand your and your childโ€™s temperament, a little observational skill, and then a good dash of patience and flexibility will get you well on your way.




Remember that ability you used to have to distinguish (most of the time) a wet diaper cry from a hungry cry from an โ€œIโ€™m in painโ€ cry? Itโ€™s not that different.

You will make the wrong call sometimes, but thatโ€™s okay. You allow yourself to learn and adjust, rather than trying to dogmatically apply to the bitter end some method a person you donโ€™t know found to work best for their own kids.  

As awesome as it would be if every kid followed the same playbook and could be skillfully raised by parents all doing the same thing, it just doesnโ€™t work that way.

When it comes to many of those timeless dilemmas parents have to face about screen time, praise, daycare, sleep training, and, yes, discipline, the best advice science often has to offer is, โ€œIt depends.โ€ Of course, there is some important general evidence on many of these topics worth knowing, but the broader principles often need to be adjusted and customized, and this requires parents seeing themselves a bit more like scientists and a bit less like converts to a particular religion.

Related: 4 Signs of Mental Health Problems in Children




When it comes to discipline, I personally like to assume kids can do things until proven otherwise. Motivation can go a long way, and techniques like occasional time-outs that help control how and when you pay attention to your child are not ones, in my view, to categorically exclude from your toolbox out of hand.

Yet for many kids, and especially those who really struggle with self-regulation, attention-seeking really is not the primary driver of challenging child behavior, and all the motivation in the world will not be enough to get them to change course. For these folks, engagement, empathy, and coaching are needed instead. 

Do Kids Really Misbehave For Attention

When to zig and when to zag when kids misbehave will likely continue to be a puzzle for many parentsโ€”and it should. Strictly following a recipe of what to do from some self-proclaimed expert may seem at first like a good way out of the confusion, and maybe a decent place to start if you feel overwhelmed, but over the long haul, a customized approach that incorporates an honest look at the temperament of both you and your child is likely to produce the best and most sustainable results. And if you donโ€™t know how to respond when asked whether you are an โ€œattachmentโ€ or a โ€œfree-rangeโ€ or an โ€œintensiveโ€ parent, just say โ€œyes.โ€

Whatโ€™s your opinion on child behavior and kids wanting attention?

Let us know in comments.


References



Rettew D.  Parenting Made Complicated: What Science Really Knows about the Greatest Debates of Early Childhood. New York: Oxford University Press, 2021.


Written by: David Rettew, M.D
Originally appeared on: Psychology Today
Republished with permission

Understanding Child kid Behavior pin
Understanding Child Behavior pin
child behavior kids misbehave for attention pin


— Share —

Published On:

Last updated on:

, ,

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

Should Parents Set Consequences for Misbehavior or Not?

Should Parents Set Consequences For Misbehavior? Key Points

You want your child to grow up responsible and disciplined, but should you set consequences for misbehavior? Let’s learn the right balance between discipline and understanding.

Should we set consequences for our children when they don’t do what we want?

Key points

Research shows that physical punishment predicts negative outcomes in children.

Authoritative parenting has been found to be the most effective style that yields the happiest children.

Parents need to be able to tolerate their children being upset, disappointed, sad, or even angry with them.

Up Next

Does Gentle Parenting Work?

Does Gentle Parenting Style Work? Important Things To Know

Can setting firm boundaries with kindness raise well-behaved kids, or does it lead to entitlement and defiance? Let’s learn more about gentle parenting style!

A look at the data on gentle parenting.

Key points

The concept of Gentle Parenting is not based on scientific data.

Gentle Parenting does incorporate some very good parenting techniques.

Gentle Parenting may ask too much of parents.

What Is Gentle Parenting Style?

Up Next

Let Kids Be Kids? 6 Identifying Signs of Hurried Child Syndrome

Clear Hurried Child Syndrome Symptoms

Some of us felt the pressure to grow up too fastโ€ฆ meet deadlines, succeed academically, and always be on top of thingsโ€”before we were even ready. It turns out, this pressure is real for some children today, and itโ€™s called Hurried Child Syndrome. Letโ€™s explore more about this condition.

What Is Hurried Child Syndrome?

Wondering what is Hurried Child Syndrome? It re

Up Next

Hovering Too Hard? 7 Mistakes Parents Who Overparent Often Make

Mistakes Parents Who Overparent Make: Hovering Too Hard?

Itโ€™s easy for parents who overparent to fall into the trap of doing too much in the name of love and care. But sometimes, all that hovering and controlling can backfire in surprising ways. Letโ€™s break down the seven common mistakes and how to avoid them!

KEY POINTS

Overprotective parenting can have a negative impact on childrenโ€™s mental health and relationships.

If you recognize any of these signs in yourself, itโ€™s important to take steps to change your behavior.

Encourage your child to try new things, let them make mistakes, take risks, and solve problems on their own.

Up Next

Is Your Daughter in a Controlling Relationship? 9 Ways to Help Her Break Free

Daughter in a Controlling Relationship? Things You Can Do

Have you ever had a very strong gut feeling that your daughter might not be in a healthy relationship? Or that she is in a relationship with a controlling boyfriend? Today we are going to talk about what you can do, when you have a daughter in a controlling relationship.

Yeah, itโ€™s a tough pill to swallow. Bossy boyfriends sneakily isolate, manipulate and dim the light in the people they date. And if your daughter is dating someone like this, then it’s understandable how tough it can be to watch that.

However, there’s always light at the end of the tunnel – as her mother, you can help her break free from her controlling boyfriend. This isnโ€™t about swooping in like a superhero; itโ€™s about being smart, supportive, and steady.

First, let’s start with trying to understand who a controlling boyfriend

Up Next

8 Undeniable Signs She’s Destined to Be an A+ Mom

Qualities of a Good Mother That Guarantee A+ Parenting!

Moms are superheroes, plain and simple. But being a great mom isnโ€™t just about keeping the fridge stocked and making sure homework gets done. Itโ€™s about making your kids feel loved, valued, and truly understood. Moms are often the first and biggest influence in a childโ€™s life, shaping how they see themselves and the world.

Being a good mom is about way more than just keeping a kid alive (though, yes, thatโ€™s non-negotiable). Itโ€™s about showing up with love, wisdom, and that unshakable belief in her kidโ€™s potential. Moms help mold who we are and how we see the world.

Up Next

Divorce And Holidays: 5 Co-Parenting Tips To Help Kids Enjoy Christmas

Helpful Divorce And Holidays Coping Tips For Parents

The festive season is often described as the most wonderful time of the year. However, divorce and holidays can be tricky to navigate for some families, itโ€™s not only challenging for kids but also for their parents.

Children deserve to be in happy and healthy homes, a safe space to enjoy and make memories rather than facing bickering fights and drama.

If youโ€™re co parenting on Christmas, create a holiday season thatโ€™s joyful and comforting for your children. Below are five practical divorce and holidays coping tips to help your kids enjoy the festivities, even after a separation or divorce.