What Emotions Help Creativity? Why Creativity Is Not Solely Dependent on Happiness

emotions help creativity 1

Good news: Many emotions can help creativity if we use and manage them well.
Creativity is full of emotion, from the anxiety of the blank computer screen and the frustration of facing inevitable obstacles to the elation of insight and pride of achievement.




Creativity scholars have learned a great deal by examining the role of emotions in creativity for at least 35 years. The biggest and most reliable lesson from this research is that creative idea generation is most successful when people are in happy, energized states.

So, it would seem that in order to be creative, one should be happy. Indeed, readers may have seen this research translated into advice to those aiming to be more creative.



A Tired Brain Could Actually Be More Creative.

Why is it, then, that when we think of creative people, happy and energized arenโ€™t necessarily the first words that come to mind? Indeed, even the authors of the major meta-analysis that reviewed dozens of studies and clearly established the relationship between happy moods and generating creative ideas concluded, โ€œto make a difference in creative performance, manipulating mood states is not very effective and is unlikely to produce clear and visible changes in creativity.โ€

Creativity Is Not Solely Dependent On The Happiness

Why this discrepancy between solid scientific research results and everyday observations?
A look into the nature of this research might help.

Common research studies asked which emotion(s) are beneficial for creativity, and which are detrimental to creativity. Scientists have long prized the ability to control what they study because it enables them to make conclusions about causal relationships.




The research studies looked something like this. Scientists invite people to their labs, likely undergraduate students enrolled in psychology classes. When they first come to the lab, they are put in a specific mood by listening to music or recalling personal memories. Then, they are given a creative task. Typically, they are asked to come up with ideas for different prompts, such as possible uses of a brick, things that are round, or consequences of people becoming invisible at will. They are usually given three to four minutes to complete this task.

This procedure shows time and again that happy, energized moods are beneficial for creativity. Yet, these studies are limiting and rather removed from the real world of creative individuals.

Undergraduate students are not representative of creative individuals. They are not selected to have the personal or social attributes of creative individuals.

Furthermore, how similar are everyday emotions to those evoked by music chosen by experimenters? Music is able to move deeply, but that is music that is personally meaningful to people. When an emotional state is induced by asking someone to recall different life events, the quality and intensity of their emotions will not be the same as during the actual experience.

Read Music Therapy: How Binaural Beats Music Can Help Reduce Depression

Sarcasm promotes creativity.

The validity of the creativity tasks is also worth examining. Are creativity tasks in the lab representative of creative work in everyday life? Real-life creativity rarely (if ever) takes only three to four minutes. Also, laboratory tasks were designed so as not to give an advantage to people with special interests or skills. However, creative individuals care deeply about their work; their passion is part of them as creators.




Finally, and most problematically, these studies make conclusions about creativity, yet only examine one component: idea generation. Simply put, creativity is more than coming up with ideas. Van Gogh did not just have an idea to paint sunflowers; he actually painted them. Hemingway did not just have an idea for a story about an old fisherman who struggles with a giant marlin; he wrote it.

Also, watch โ€“ This is Exactly How Society Kills Our Creativity- In A Breathtaking short film.

Creativity Is More Than Coming Up With Ideas

If one were to start with multiple ideas after the idea generation process like that in laboratory studies, it would be necessary for them to consider which ones are the best to pursue. This requires critical thinkingโ€”a skill that is more successfully applied in more subdued and less positive moods.

Instead of asking what emotional states enhance or hinder creativity, we should ask different questions.
Are there patterns of emotions experienced by more or less creative individuals?
How do people use and transform different emotional experiences in the service of creativity?

Read: Are Mood Disorders the Price We Pay for High Intelligence and Creativity?

The process of developing, evaluating, and executing an idea in a final product has ups and downs and many associated emotions. We must acknowledge that we have complex emotional lives and that we have agency over our emotions.

In order to be open to creativity, one must spend time in solitude.

Most importantly, the fact that people donโ€™t need to be happy to think creatively can be empowering. We can draw creative ideas from nostalgia, sympathy, and frustration. We are not powerless at the mercy of our emotions, but we can influence their course, regulate them through thinking and behavioral strategies, and use them to inspire or fuel thinking.




Are you ready to be creative?

References
1. Baas, M., De Dreu, C. K. W., & Nijstad, B. A. (2008). A meta-analysis of 25 years of mood-creativity research: hedonic tone, activation, or regulatory focus? Psychological Bulletin, 134, 779โ€“806. doi:10.1037/a0012815
2. Ivcevic, Z., & Hoffmann, J. D. (2017). Emotions and creativity: From states to traits and emotion abilities. In G. Feist, R. Reiter-Palmon, & J. C. Kaufman (Eds.). Cambridge Handbook of Creativity and Personality Research (pp. 187-213). New York: Cambridge University Press.
3. van Tilburg, W. A., Sedikides, C., & Wildschut, T. (2015). The mnemonic muse: Nostalgia fosters creativity through openness to experience. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 59, 1-7. doi:10.1016/j.jesp.2015.02.00
4. Yang, H., & Yang, S. (2016). Sympathy fuels creativity: The beneficial effects of sympathy on originality. Thinking Skills and Creativity, 21, 132-143. doi:10.1016/j.tsc.2016.06.002

Written by: Zorana Ivcevic Pringle
Originally appeared on: Zoranaivcevicpringle.com
Republished with permission.
emotions help creativity pin


— Share —

Published On:

Last updated on:

,

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

14 Billie Eilish Song Lyrics That Deserve A Grammy!

Best Billie Eilish Song Lyrics That Deserve A Grammy!

From inspiring to always meaningful, Billie eilish song lyrics quotes spins narratives that fit anyone regardless of who they are, where theyโ€™re from, or what theyโ€™re going through in life.

Despite the massive success and critical acclaim of Billie Eilish’s album, she walked away empty-handed at the Grammys 2025. But if you’re a fan, here are some of the best Billie Eilish lyrics that prove she truly deserved that award.

And while we cherish her 2024 album Hit Me Hard and Soft, and eagerly await the next set of aspiring lyrics from the star, here are some Billie Eilish song lyrics quotes from over the years.

Up Next

Heart Line Personality Test: What It Reveals About Your Inner Personality

Heart Line Personality Test Results To Know Your True Self

Ever wondered how the lines on your palms can reflect your inner personality? This heart line personality test holds the key to revealing your deepest traits and how you navigate relationships and life. 

Palmistry is the practice of predicting the future by analyzing the lines and patterns on a person’s palm.

In this heart line palm test, we’ll explore the fascinating connections between the shape and alignment of your palm lines and your unique personality.

So, whether you’re a peacemaker, an adventurous spirit, or a thinker, your heart line speaks volumes about you. Take a closer look at your hands, and letโ€™s dive into what your heart line reveals about you, are you ready to discover what lies beneath the surface? Letโ€™s go!

Up Next

The Art of Slow Travel: 4 Benefits Of Wandering Mindfully

Amazing Benefits of Slow Travel Trend: Let's Go!

Instead of rushing to check off a list of must-see attractions, try โ€œslow travelโ€ where you can step out with no rigid plans, only the desire to explore at your own pace. 

Sipping coffee at a quiet cafรฉ, chatting with a local vendor at the market, and meandering through winding streets, the slow travel trend is the art of immersing yourself fully in a place, not just passing through it.

Youโ€™re simply absorbing the moment. Where the journey matters just as much as the destination.

So, What Is Slow Travel?

Wondering what is slow travel? It is a sustainable alternative to mass tourism, focusing on deeper

Up Next

2025’s Horror Lineup Will Leave You Sleeping With the Lights On!

Top Most Anticipated Horror Movies of

2024 was a treat for horror fans, with spine-chilling releases like Nosferatu and Longlegs. But 2025 might be the best one yet.

Not only are we getting the final Conjuring film, we also get to see the much awaited Guillermo del Toroโ€™s take on the classic novel Frankenstein. It does not matter if you are into video game adaptations, want to see Cillian Murphy in a terrifying role, or want a vampire story with a twist, the 2025 horror lineup has something for everyone.

And if you are still not convinced, we have Leigh Whannell (creator of Insidious and Saw) returning behind the cameras. To keep you in the loop, weโ€™ve put together a list of the most anticipated horror movies of 2025.

Up Next

Exploring Parasocial Relationships With Gods

Parasocial Relationships With Gods Important Points

How have parasocial relationships evolved from ancient times to the digital age? Explore the connections with gods in this modern age.

How the gods are like social influencers.

Key points

Humans indulge in all sorts of imaginary parasocial relationships.

The exercise of the imagination in parasocial relationships makes those relationships feel real.

Humansโ€™ relationships with the gods are examples of parasocial relationships.

Up Next

Does Performing Rituals Build Character?

Does Performing Rituals Build Character? Important Points

How does performing rituals shape our inner self? This thought-provoking question explores whether ritual participation can lead to personal growth, and moral character. Let’s explore!

Experimental evidence suggests that ritual participation enhances self-control.

Key points

Popular assumptions about connections between religions and morality typically focus on religious beliefs.

Mindless routines seem unlikely candidates for enhancing the virtues.

Cross-cultural experimental evidence suggests that ritual participation enhances childrenโ€™s self-control.

Up Next

Law of Attraction Not Working for You? 6 Reasons Why (And How to Fix It!)

Law of Attraction Not Working? Reasons And How to Fix It

Is the law of attraction not working for you? I know how frustrating this can feel. You are putting in all that effort, visualizing the kind of life you want, saying all the right affirmations, and…still nothing.

No million-dollar check in the mail, no soulmate, and no dream job coming your way. So, why is your manifestation not working? Well, the truth is, there can be quite a few sneaky reasons why things might not be panning out the way you are hoping them to be.

Today, we are going to break all of that down and try to understand why law of attraction is not working for you, despite you pulling all the stops.

First, let’s start with trying to understand what is the law of attraction, shall we?