In a groundbreaking study by the Oxford Internet Institute, researchers have found no significant evidence linking internet use to widespread harm to mental health. The study, considered the largest of its kind, challenges concerns about the negative impact of online activities such as social media browsing and gaming on mental well-being.
Contrary to popular beliefs that certain groups might be more susceptible to mental health issues caused by technology, the research, encompassing data from over 2 million people, discovered no definitive “smoking gun” indicating harm from online activities.
The Oxford Internet Institute’s study stands in contrast to the growing body of research associating the onset of the smartphone era with increased rates of anxiety and depression, especially among teenage girls.
However, Professor Andrew Przybylski, part of the University of Oxford and lead researcher on the study, highlighted the absence of data necessary to establish a causal connection, urging for greater cooperation from tech companies.
He emphasized that if certain apps do indeed have detrimental effects on mental health, only the companies developing them possess the user data that could prove such claims.
“The best data we have available suggests that there is not a global link between these factors,” Przybylski stated. He stressed that due to the high stakes involved in addressing potential mental health problems caused by online activity, any regulatory measures should be based on more conclusive evidence.
Study To Understand How Internet Use Is Not Responsible For Bad Mental Health
Published in the journal Clinical Psychological Science under the title “Global Well-Being and Mental Health in the Internet Age,” the study analyzed psychological well-being data from 2.4 million people across 168 countries between 2005 and 2022.
The researchers compared this data with industry information on the growth of internet subscriptions over the same period and tracked associations between mental health and internet adoption in 202 countries from 2000-2019.
The results of the study indicate that there is no substantial evidence supporting the notion that the internet, including technologies like smartphones with internet access, actively promotes or harms global well-being or mental health.
While the study acknowledged “some evidence” of stronger associations between mental health problems and technology in younger individuals, the magnitude of these associations was described as small.
Przybylski, a known advocate for robust data in discussions about technology’s impact on society, criticized the existing standards of evidence in much of the research in this area. He pointed out that the majority of studies have been focused on English-speaking countries, neglecting the fact that more than 90 percent of young people reside outside North America and Europe.
Despite the study’s findings, debates surrounding the effects of technology on mental health persist. Przybylski cautioned against hasty regulatory proposals, likening them to “wellbeing theatre.” He emphasized the need for comprehensive data before proposing solutions or treatments, challenging the prevailing notions around technology’s negative impact.
As Big Tech companies face increasing pressure to address the potential effects of their products, studies like these play a crucial role in shaping the conversation. The Oxford Internet Institute’s research adds nuance to the ongoing discourse, highlighting the complexities involved in understanding the relationship between technology and mental health.
Leave a Reply