Healthy Disagreements: 11 Tips for Talking to Someone You Disagree With

 / 

,

Talking with someone we disagree with is an unpredictable nightmare for a lot of us. Tensions escalate quickly, especially in times of uncertainty.

In our present political climate, many of us are experiencing a breakdown in our ability to engage the โ€œother side.โ€ When these channels of communication fail, it can represent a significant loss to our relationships, our families, our communities, and even our democracy.

How can we overcome such deep polarization?

This article discusses ways to improve conversations with people with whom we disagree on any given subject.

Note: This article presumes you are speaking to someone who is not posing an immediate threat of violence or abuse to you or to others. If that is the case, seek the professional guidance of a therapist or mediator.

Before we dive in, let me offer that we should advocate passionately and articulately for causes we believe in. The goal here is not to tone ourselves down or apologize for our beliefs, but to become more effective, credible, and collaborative when weโ€™re engaging with people who see the world differently.

Why does this matter? It matters because while many of us are afraid of disagreement, the fact is that disagreement is a natural part of life. It can either be healthy or unhealthy. If we seek to protect our relationships and strengthen our communities instead of allowing them to be torn apart, we should prioritize healthier disagreement.

Related: How Productive Fighting Can Strengthen Your Relationship: 10 Ways

11 Tips For Talking To Someone You Disagree With

1. DO: Tell People They Matter.

Before anything else, make sure you reinforce your relationship with the person. Saying things like, โ€œBefore I say anything else, I want to make sure you know that I care about youโ€ or โ€œI want to respect you and appreciate your perspectiveโ€ goes a long way. Instead of walking into a conversation ready for a fight, which immediately puts everyone in earshot on the defensive, try warming up with โ€œHi, itโ€™s me. Someone who cares.โ€

Remember not to say, โ€œI care about youโ€ฆ but.โ€ Itโ€™s important not to qualify. Expressing that they matter, full stop reminds both of you of the value of the relationship over and above personal beliefs and ideals. Itโ€™s a big glowing reminder that our humanity is determined by how we treat each other, not by how much we agree.

healthy disagreements

2. DONโ€™T: Let Frustration Overcome You. Channel It.

Itโ€™s hard to stay calm when people are saying things you strongly oppose. It can be tempting, and even cathartic in the moment, to blow up at them.

Take a moment and remember a time when you changed your mind about something. Did that experience involve someone screaming at you or shaming you? Probably not.

Our goals in difficult conversations should generally be to 1) Protect the relationship with that person, and 2) increase your understanding and increase the chances that you will be understood. These goals are much harder than exploding.

In those times when you feel like a boiler ready to burst, take a deep breath and focus all of that energy into justโ€ฆ making more sense. Donโ€™t explode, donโ€™t lash out. Channel that frustration into pure, unmitigated reason. Make that energy work on your behalf.

If you canโ€™t channel it at that moment, thereโ€™s absolutely no problem with saying, โ€œIโ€™m too angry, I need to take a break.โ€ Go blow off some steam, and come back to this later. Thereโ€™s always time for a pause if youโ€™re in over your head. Because if you donโ€™t slow down and pause, you risk putting the entire relationship in jeopardy. You might lose any credibility or trust that you have been working to build.

So protect your investment in that person, and do everything you can to stay in productive communication with them (except in cases when stronger boundaries are needed or itโ€™s necessary to end the relationship for your own safety).

3. DO: Acknowledge Fears Under The Surface.

In my book, I argue that all conflict has some kind of fear at its core. Humans generally want to live and not die. We want to be free and not controlled. We fear chaos and seek meaning and order. Itโ€™s important to recognize which fears are driving someoneโ€™s belief structure.

  • โ€œI can understand how you would feel if you believed that if _ doesnโ€™t happen the world will fall apart.โ€
  • โ€œIโ€™m afraid of seeing my country crumble.โ€
  • โ€œDo you know what Iโ€™m scared of?โ€

Itโ€™s important for strong emotional connections to understand the things we have in common. Acknowledging fears shows empathy, and itโ€™s a reminder of our shared human experience. Sometimes, fear may be the biggest thing we have in common.

Donโ€™t rush past this important and very real element. If a conversation is stuck in the mud and not going anywhere, examining and sharing fears can get things moving in a more fruitful direction.

Related: 5 Ways To Stay Calm During An Argument With Your Spouse

4. DONโ€™T: Assume The Worst.

The vast majority of us want to be good. We want to fight for the best possible world and do the right thing. We may have different visions of how to get there, but itโ€™s important to assume someone means well until we have definitive proof that they donโ€™t.

Try to make a point to say things like:

  • โ€œI can understand where you are coming from.โ€
  • โ€œI can see your intentions come from a good place.โ€
  • โ€œYou make a good point there.โ€

Show that you see the person beneath the opinions. Show that you assume they have good intentions unless you have direct evidence to the contrary. Try to interpret what they say in a generous light, even if you plan to push back against their ideas.

What does this accomplish? It shows our conversation partner that we arenโ€™t hellbent on attacking them just because they are on the โ€œotherโ€ side. Extending goodwill is both reasonable and neighborly. It creates a spirit of collaboration. Even if we think someone is in espousing weird or problematic ideas, telling them that we hope for and expect the best from them builds a bridge.

Except in extreme cases where someone is saying something blatantly malicious, try to see what value or merit their ideas hold. Give credit where itโ€™s due, and someone is more likely to open up and have a real conversation.

5. DO: Share Your Sources.

The information we use to construct and uphold our beliefs is incredibly important. Where we get this information is also important. The problem is, in the digital age, thereโ€™s a lot of convincing false, or misleading information floating around in the world.

Share your sources of information, like articles, books, or documentariesโ€”and be ready for the possibility that people will critique those sources or reject their legitimacy. Thatโ€™s all part of the process of social negotiation and healthy disagreement. If your sources are legitimate, they should have no problem holding up under scrutiny.

If someone rejects your sources, try to find sources you can both agree to accept as valid, even if you understand those sources might have bias. Hereโ€™s a handy guide for validating sources of information.

Related: Feeling Stuck In Useless Relationship Fights? 3 Steps To Get Out

6. DONโ€™T: Launch Verbal Grenades.

Some words can be perceived as emotionally aggressive and create the opposite effect of collaborative, productive discourse.

This includes any of the following:

  • Name-callingโ€”words like โ€œstupid,โ€ โ€œignorant,โ€ โ€œcrazyโ€
  • Blanket statements that include the words โ€œalwaysโ€ or โ€œneverโ€
  • โ€œZingers,โ€ โ€œgotchaโ€ moments, or clap backsโ€”these are momentarily gratifying but may erode your relationship with the person
  • Personal (ad hominem) attacks
  • Labels that people have not adopted themselves
  • Swear words (Iโ€™m not opposed to swearing in general, but in difficult conversations, swearing can be distracting and heighten emotions and defensiveness)

Of course, we are able to use these words if we so choose; itโ€™s a free country. But if we really want to be credible and trusted during a disagreement, if we want to maximize our impact and understanding, we will take caution. These words breed hostility and anxiety.

When we use them, those who might have been sympathetic to our cause may now think we are a jerk.

disagreement

7. DO: Show You Understand, Even If You Donโ€™t Agree.

We canโ€™t play basketball if we donโ€™t know what actions constitute a violation or a foul, right?

The same is true when we disagree. If we walk into a conversation and donโ€™t take the time to actually listen and understand the nuance of what someone is saying or believing, we are playing the game without understanding the rules. We might say things that donโ€™t make sense or fit the situation, which could mean our participation becomes frustrating or irrelevant.

We might also miss opportunities to make good points that we could have made if we had only paid attention. Everyone wants to be heard, especially in disagreements. Not being heard, or having our words twisted, creates a lot of resentment. So take the time to listen.

And after weโ€™ve listened, then make a point to reflectโ€”literally, and out loud. Let them know that we listened:

  • โ€œSo if I understand you correctlyโ€ฆโ€
  • โ€œIt seems like you are saying __, is that accurate?โ€
  • โ€œCan I summarize what Iโ€™m understanding so far?โ€

8. DONโ€™T: Use Sarcasm And Refrain From Speaking In Sound Bites.

Sarcasm, especially sarcasm in online conversations, can be particularly risky for discourse because we canโ€™t always hear or accurately interpret auditory tone. It can be hard to know when someone is being facetious.

Try to say exactly what you mean and donโ€™t crack jokes at someoneโ€™s expense. Remember, your long-term relationship with that person is more important than the present conversation. If you want to be influential with them, if you want to stay in community with them, you will seek to use direct language that doesnโ€™t leave room for misinterpretation.

In addition to refraining from sarcasm, take the time to spell out a longer response or explanation instead of trying to use sound bites that can be taken the wrong way or seen as cocky. If the conversation matters to you, take the time to patiently spell it out.

All of this said, using humor to lighten the mood can be helpful when things start getting too intense. But use caution if you are talking about a serious topic where people have experienced pain. In such a case, humor will more than likely come across as insensitive.

Related: How to Read Eyes And Know What Someone Is Thinking

9. DONโ€™T: Be Condescending.

Nobody likes a know-it-all.

Even if youโ€™re dripping in academic knowledge, even if you can talk circles around someone, you will alienate them the minute you act superior. Having more knowledge than someone else does not make you a better person. Note that weโ€™re not talking about confidence, here.

Confidence is important. Ultimately, being condescending is about control: seeking to control or force someone to agree with us and implying that if they donโ€™t, theyโ€™re bad or stupid.

How do we stop being condescending? Here are a few ideas:

  • Put an end to explaining things people may already know, interrupting, acting as if you are the final authority, or being incredulous that someone doesnโ€™t know something
  • If youโ€™re writing to someone, read your draft out loud and take a good, long look at your tone
  • Ask someone else to read it and to give their honest opinion.
  • Admit the possibility that you could be wrong or lack information. Recognize your limits. Qualify your ideas with โ€œI-speakโ€ statements like, โ€œthe way I see it,โ€ โ€œin my experience,โ€ โ€œin my research,โ€ or โ€œin my opinion.โ€

10. DO: Teach And Be Teachable.

Good teachers are patient, gracious, and give people the space to discover things at their own pace. They donโ€™t get mad at someone for not knowing something. Importantly, good teachers donโ€™t mistake โ€œuninformedโ€ for โ€œstupid.โ€ Smart people can believe untrue or misleading ideas, and it doesnโ€™t make them less smart. It means they might have gaps in their understanding or unreliable sources. Intelligence and education are different; remember not to confuse the two.

Be teachable, too. When weโ€™re speaking to a peer, it goes a long way to allow ourselves to be challenged. Saying things like โ€œI never thought about it that way,โ€ or โ€œThatโ€™s new to me, Iโ€™m going to read up on thatโ€ shows that we are a co-learner. If we want to teach, we need to be open to being taught.

A two-way exchange of information equalizes the power dynamic. People are more likely to open up when they are talking to a peer who is still on a learning journey, just like themselves.

disagreement

11. DO: Thank Them For Disagreeing.

This last one is big: Say โ€œthank youโ€ when someone takes the time to disagree. It may not seem like it, but disagreement is truly a gift. When someone disagrees with us, they didnโ€™t have to take precious time out of their life to engage. They donโ€™t owe us their attention or courtesy.

When they do choose to disagree with us in healthy ways, they are offering a courtesy. Try to recognize and honor the awkward beauty of that exchange.

In conclusion: Healthy disagreement is worth the effort.

It is indeed possible to have a conversation with just about anyone, on just about any topic, and not lose our nerve. However, healthy disagreement doesnโ€™t magically happen. Itโ€™s hard work. It requires skills, practice, and courage. The work is worth it, however, because we need to disagree well in order to have strong communities and a strong society.

As we condition our conversational muscles, remember that we canโ€™t control other people. We canโ€™t decide who must agree with us, when, or to what extent. But we can build bridges instead of bonfires.

Related: Perception Vs Reality: 7 Things To Keep In Mind

Contact Melody atย melodystanfordmartin.com.ย for such informative articles.


Written By Melody Stanford Martin
Originally Appeared On Psychology Today
talking to someone you disagree pinop
talking to someone you disagree pin

— Share —

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

Things People Learn Too Late In Life: 7 Eye-Opening Life Lessons

Things People Learn Too Late in Life Eye Opening Life Lessons

Life is full of unexpected events and sometimes there are things people learn too late. Though some lessons come with age and experience, as time goes by, we often wish we had known some important truths sooner.

These moments of truth can be very shocking as well as transformative, they help us live authentically, appreciate what truly matters, and make the most of our time. Below are seven crucial life lessons people learn too late and can still change the way they approach life.

7 Things People Learn Too Late In

Up Next

Anger and Emotions: What’s Really Setting Us Off?

Anger and Emotion Whats Really Setting Us Off

Ever wonder whatโ€™s really fueling your anger and emotions? Discover how a mindful approach can help you regain inner peace in your life!

Taking a mindful approach to exploring why we are angry.

Key points

Anger is a secondary emotion.

Anger is a warning sign that lets us know there is an issue to address.

Knowing what we are feeling will help us to address the source of our anger.

Anger can hit us when we least expect it. There are some people who get angry and not know what they are angry about. The

Up Next

Master Your Mind: 8 Subtle Clues Extraverted Intuition Is At Work

Is Extraverted Intuition Guiding You Subtle Clues

If youโ€™ve ever wondered how extraverted intuition works or if you might have it yourself, youโ€™re in the right place. Extraverted intuition (often abbreviated as Ne) is a personality trait that shows up as a knack for spotting connections, exploring ideas, and picking up on possibilities others might overlook.

Itโ€™s like a mental compass, pointing toward new insights, and itโ€™s often subtle but powerful.

Weโ€™re going to look at 8 little-known extraverted intuition signs is at play, helping you spot and harness this amazing skill set in your everyday life.

Let’s first start with what is extraverted intuition.

Related:

Up Next

How I Hacked My Personality: Steps To Be The Better Version Of Myself

How I Hacked My Personality

Can we truly reshape our personalities for lasting change? Discover Dr. Shannon Sauer-Zavala’s article “How I hacked my personality” and learn how small shifts in mindset and behavior can lead to meaningful transformation in your life.

A Personal Perspective: Science-backed strategies for intentional trait change.

Key points

Research suggests that personality changes over time.

We can speed up personality change by taking intentional action.

Changes that are reinforced by the environment are easier to maintain.

Up Next

Women Empowerment: The Rebecca Effect in “Ted Lasso”

Rebecca Effect In Ted Lasso Women Empowerment

Can women turn negative experiences into empowerment? Discover the โ€œRebecca Effectโ€ from Ted Lasso and transform your personal trials into powerful self-acceptance!

Personal Perspective: Empowering women to transform shame and betrayal.

Key points

“Ted Lasso” inspired with imperfect, endearing characters whose trials and transformations mirrored our own.

The โ€œRebecca Effectโ€ is the empowerment and transformation possible when we have been oppressed or shamed.

The “Rebecca Effect” is the process through which women embrace themselves in totality.

Up Next

The Healing Power of Emotional Tears

The Healing Power of Emotional Tears

Ever wondered why we shed emotional tears? Tears serve a healing purpose. Explore how it plays an important role for our well-being.

Emotional tears are an expression of our shared humanity.

Emotional tears, expressed by children, teens, and adults, are a universal experience observed across the globe. Emotional tears play a healing role, leading to our emotional and physical well-being. This post explores the value of emotional tears and the importance of presence and support from family and friends during unexpected

Read More Here: โ€œWhy Am I Always On The Verg

Up Next

10 Important Weekly Reflection Questions You Need To Ask Yourself

If you feel stuck and want to keep track of your goals every week, then weekly reflection questions can really help you. Weekly reflection questions can help you check in with yourself and make sure youโ€™re headed in the right direction. These are the questions you need to ask yourself every week to keep growing and moving forward.

Have you ever had a week with so much going on that you end the week feeling overwhelmed and exhausted? I know I have been there. Sometimes, the week goes by so fast that itโ€™s over before I know it, and there is no time left to process it.

A weekly reflection can help evaluate if what you are doing is working. It fosters self-growth. So, pull out that weekly reflection journal and answer the weekly reflection prompts below.