How Smartphones and Social Comparison are Making Us Unhappy?

Social Comparison and the Rise of Mental Health Problems in Young Americans

Your smartphone could be making you miserable. Young Americans today are facing levels of stress, anxiety, depression, and other mental illnesses that are higher than they were a generation ago. And the rest of us arenโ€™t doing much better.

Depressed Teen: Social Comparison and the Rise of Mental Health Problems in Young Americans

According to the CDC, 1 in 10 Americans suffers from some form of depression.

(1) People between the ages of 18-24 report the highest incidences.

(2) 40 million of us over the age of 18 have an anxiety disorder, and as the APA pointed out in its recent report Stress in America millennials are the hardest hit.

(3) Suicide is the third leading cause of death for youth between the ages of 10 and 24 claiming 4600 lives per year.

Related:ย Essential Steps How To Combat of College Depression and Anxiety

This is a society that has more wealth than much of the rest of the world combined. Whatโ€™s happening here?

Some claim better reportingโ€”that we have better mental health resources in place and more people are aware of their psychological problems than they were a generation or two ago. Others point to common sources of stress such as money problems, economic instability, family relationships, personal responsibilities, lack of job security, and unemployment. While these may all be contributing factors, thereโ€™s another unrecognized piece of the puzzle that I believe is driving much of our discontent. And itโ€™s right in your pocket.

Related: Social Comparison โ€“ย Two-sided Sword That We Should Be Careful To

Comparing Monkeys

We, humans, love to compare ourselves to the people around us. Even when we are reasonably happy with what we have, once we compare ourselves to someone who has something better we become dissatisfied. You may have experienced a similar effect watching episodes of Keeping up with the Kardashians. Interestingly, this social comparison tendency seems to be innate in primates and has been shown even in animal models.

Frans de Waal has an enlightening and entertaining Ted Talk where he shows an experiment he conducted on capuchin monkeys illustrating social comparison and resource acquisition in much the same way humans do:

The experiment goes like thisโ€ฆ

There are two monkeys in adjacent cages. They are rewarded for handing a researcher outside the cage a stone. The first monkey successfully gives the scientist a stone and is rewarded with a piece of cucumber.

Monkey #1 is satisfied and enjoys his reward.

Then monkey #2 completes the same task, but is given a grape which he eats with relish. Monkeys like grapes a great deal more than cucumbers so when they are tested again, things get interesting.

During the second round of tests, monkey #1 once again successfully hands the researcher a stone and is given a cucumber. He puts the cucumber to his lips, looks at the researcher, then reaches outside the cage, throws the piece of cucumber at the scientist and shakes the cage.

On the second round, monkey #2 once again enjoys a grape. As you might imagine, by the third round monkey #1 appears positively outraged by the cucumber. Shaking his cage, making noise, throwing cucumbers at the researchers and so forth.

What was once fineโ€”the cucumberโ€”is now no longer even acceptable in light of the possibility of enjoying a grape.

Data on income disparities in people show similar results. The amount of money you make is not a good indicator of life satisfaction alone. Rather itโ€™s the rank of your income within a comparison group that seems to matter most.

(4) We see this quite clearly in communities where income disparity is highest. A measure sometimes called The Robin Hood index plots household incomes in specific neighborhoods on a single graph. In places where the Robin Hood index is highest, we see greater instances of violence and homicide.

(5) Itโ€™s not just the amount of money people make, but income inequality that seems to drive these behaviors. This kind of social comparison probably started as an adaptive behavior in animals as much as 540 million years ago.

How do we know this?

Well, our ability to compare is connected to the ability to choose between richer and leaner reinforcement schedules. If you didnโ€™t do that, it would be really bad from a survival standpoint.

Animals have to be able to look around and see which field is more likely to yield good food. As socialization developed, this ability to compare stretched into the realm of the community as well.

If you look around and see another group or person is doing better than you, you may sidle up to the other group and make friends. If youโ€™ve got a hunk of meat and I donโ€™t, Iโ€™m going to go over and stand next to you. Maybe youโ€™ll share or I might even be able to steal it from you.

Fast forward 540 million years and we have developed technology and cognitive abilities based on relational learning that put this process on steroids. We donโ€™t have to get angry over cucumbers โ€“ we can compare ourselves with little more than cognitive labels. Who is hot, who is cool, or anything in between. We can be upset over what is fair or unfair, based on complex ideas of โ€œfairness.โ€ That process was known even in Biblical times, as the story of the workers in the vineyard shows (Matt 20: 1-16).

But now science and technology โ€“ that mountain of achievement based on human cognition โ€“ has given us the capacity to compare ourselves to anything or anybody, anywhere or anytime. And that brings us back to your smartphone.

Related:ย How Technology Is Ruining Marriage And Relationships

A Tool for Social Comparison

Right now, you have a device in your pocket or purse that allows you to carry out social comparisons like the ones illustrated above constantly and with ease. Itโ€™s called your smartphone. With it, you can see whatโ€™s going on anywhere in the world at any time.

Think about what this creates. No matter how successful you are, you are not a gazillionaire. And you can see how gazillionaires live with the push of a button. You can see how the rich and famous life, what movie stars do in their daily lives, what they have that you donโ€™t, how they live that you canโ€™t.

The disparity is transparent, and it pushes ancient psychological triggers we developed for important evolutionary reasons.

So how do we manage this?

Social comparison and Unhappiness

We arenโ€™t going to create a world thatโ€™s good enough for everybody. Itโ€™s not possible. Not everyone is going to become Bill Gates. Even if we could, it would never be enough. After all, most Americans are wealthy beyond imagination in comparison to the rest of the world community and we still have epidemic rates of anxiety, depression, and a host of other mental illnesses.

And weโ€™re not going backward. No one is going to take out their iPhones and blow them up. What we have to do is create modern minds for the modern world.

The question is what does that mean and how do we do that?

The modern world is one in which we have to be Olympic class psychological flexibility experts, just to get along. We have to teach and find a way to be more emotionally, cognitively, and behaviorally open and aware, we have to learn how to take the perspective of others, to feel a little of what they feel, and to stick with those feelings even when it gets rough.

Related: Harvard Study Finds #1 Way To Happy Life

We need to create a more accepting, mindful, values-based, caring, compassionate world, and we have to start right here, right now in our hearts, in our families, in our schools, in our community, in our culture, our nation, and our world. The tools are out there, right now. Heck, you can find them on your smartphone.

References:

(1)

(2)

(3) https://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/stress/2012/generations.aspx

(4) Boyce C, Brown G, Moore, S. Money, and happiness: Rank of income, not income, affects life satisfaction. Psychological Science. April 2010. 21(4): 471-475.

(5) Daly, M, and Wilson M. Homicide. 1988. Aldine Transaction Inc.


Written by Steven C. Hayes
Originally appeared in Steven C. Hayes, Ph.d

Google Scholar high impact researcher: http://www.webometrics.info/en/node/58

Check out my TEDx talks:ย http://bit.ly/StevesFirstTEDย orย ย http://bit.ly/StevesSecondTED

For information on my trainings, go to www.praxiscet.com

If you are a professional or student, join the ACT or RFT list serves (set inside your ACBS membership page: seeย http://contextualscience.org/ACBS_listserv_faq

How Smart Phones and Social Comparison are Making Us Unhappy pin

— Share —

, ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

Is He Silently Struggling? 8 Symptoms Of Depression In Men

Symptoms Of Depression In Men

Symptoms of depression in men can often be overlooked. While women may be more open about their emotions, many men tend to keep their struggles hidden. They might not cry, but that doesn’t mean they’re not hurting.

Depression can show up in surprising ways, and sometimes, it’s easy to miss. Today, we are going to talk about not just the symptoms of depression in men, but we are also going to explore the impact it has on them.

This can help you spot the signs that a man might be silently struggling with mental health, and this could be the first step toward helping him get the support he needs.

Related:

Up Next

5-4-3-2-1 Coping Technique for Anxiety: A Great Method to Calm Your Anxiety

If you are looking for a simple but effective coping technique for anxiety, look no further: the 54321 anxiety technique is your answer!

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

This technique is one of the easiest relaxation methods you can learn. So, whether youโ€™re feeling overwhelmed or facing a stressful situation it will help you stay grounded in the present moment by usin

Up Next

Music Therapy: How To Use Music For Emotional Healing?

Do you ever notice how your favorite song instantly lifts your spirits when it comes on? Or how it can calm your mind at the end of a stressful day? Well, thatโ€™s the power of music. It is not just some words and sounds, itโ€™s a powerful tool that can also heal us. So, let us explore ways in which we can use music for emotional healing.

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Up Next

Is Your Depression Causing Anger? 4 Crucial Reasons to Address It

Do you find yourself caught in an emotional tug-of-war? Is your depression causing anger? If every little frustration feels like it could explode into rage and snapping at loved ones for no reason has become a common habit, learn the ways to help yourself with depression and anger.

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

As an effect of depression, anger is quite common because

Up Next

Depression Without Suicidal Thoughts: 8 Signs That You Have Been Ignoring

Have you ever felt like you are going through the motions of daily life but not really feeling present or engaged? Many people experience depression without the extreme of suicidal thoughts, and itโ€™s often overlooked or misunderstood.

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Most of the time depression is associated with visible signs of sadness. However, sometimes it does app

Up Next

10 Songs About Depression: Soulful Songs That You Will Relate To

Depression is the dark shadow that engrosses the normal life function of individuals making them numb or extremely agitated. In this situation, personally, I prefer to listen to music that can beat any stress with a calm vibe. And not only me, music therapy is one of the best ways to deal with depression and sadness.ย 

Up Next

7 Shocking Facts About Mental Health That Will Surprise You

Do you ever feel like you have a pretty good handle on mental health, only to come across a fact that completely challenges your understanding? Have you ever wondered about the lesser known facts about mental health?

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Mental health is a topic that is becoming more openly discussed, which is fantastic for mental health aware