How Long Does Misery In The Aftermath Of Unemployment Last?

Loss of a job impacts our psychological health. A lot of people find it difficult to recover from the adversity of unemployment. Neglected research argues for nuanced thinking and policy solutions.

This post is co-authored by my long-term collaborator Dr. Patrick E. McKnight, Professor of Psychology at George Mason University.

In the news today (March 26, 2020), the headlines read: โ€œJobless claims this morning will be historicโ€ (Yahoo Finance), โ€œPreparing for millions of layoffsโ€ (New York Times), โ€œU.S. jobless claims jump to 3.28 million, quadruple prior recordโ€ (Bloomberg), and โ€œWall Street shakes off unemployment report as aid nearsโ€ (New York Times).

These numbers are astounding and yet, many believe the effects of joblessness in the United States are trivialโ€”due, in part, to the fact that managing the coronavirus pandemic takes temporal precedence for most individuals. In isolation, shutting down the economy seems an unfathomable concept except when pitched as part of a quarantine solution to halt the spread of the pandemic.

The government recognizes these concerns in its effort to provide a two trillion-dollar financial aid package. The aid offers a short-term salve that masks the immediate and potential long-term consequences of unemployment. Joblessnessโ€”especially when experienced later in oneโ€™s adult working lifeโ€”can have adverse psychological effects (especially for men) that last for years.

The vast majority of unemployed adults do not psychologically recover from the adversity experienced. Not one year later, nor two, nor even three or four years later.

Related: Workplace Bullying Is A Play: Meet The 6 Characters

Psychological Instability And Unemployment

Psychological instability in the aftermath of being unemployed does not discriminate by gender, race, sexual orientation, political ideology, income, or social status. There is near consensus in the field of psychology: following unemployment, people experience lasting declines in well-being and unhealthy personality changes.

For example, with each year spent unemployed, women show larger reductions in compassion and politeness, men become increasingly lower in industriousness, and emotional disturbances such as anxiety disorders and depression become increasingly common.

To put the lingering effect of unemployment in perspective, the loss of a job has a more lasting impact than a divorce, the death of a spouse, and the vast majority of extremely stressful life events. As the gravest outcome, the World Health Organization found that between the years 2000 and 2011, the relative risk of suicides increased as high as 20-30% in the months preceding, during, and following the last economic crisis in 2008.

So while people are dying from the coronavirus, letโ€™s not be mistaken: existing historical data suggest that unfortunately, a sizable number of people may also die from unemployment, at their own hands. Regarding the current news headlines, the unemployment numbers are likely to go up and the impact will be felt for generations to come. We base this rather grim outlook on available social science researchโ€”not on unknown characteristics of COVID-19 or our hunches.

Related: When Itโ€™s Time To Leave Your Toxic Workplace: 5 Red Flags

On March 24, 2020, in reference to the governmentโ€™s recommendations for social distancing, President Donald Trump stated:

I guess by Monday or Tuesday, itโ€™s about two weeks. We will assess at that time and give it more time if we need a little more time. We have to open this country up.

And the world flipped out. The notion that America can simultaneously address the physical and economic consequences of the pandemic felt unconscionable, harrowing, and morally indefensible. A close look at the social sciences shows that in truth, the physical and economic consequences are inextricably tied.

Opening up the country to recharge the economy not only has the obvious and expected financial benefits but also the less-than-obvious health benefits of making us all better off. Weighing the costs and benefits for an entire countryโ€™s population can be a difficult decision and we collectively require all of the available data to make informed decisions.

If you have never experienced poverty, it might be worthwhile to detail what it means to be impoverished in America. In a nationally representative study of over 60,000 adults requiring food assistance, 40% said they cut back on food, delayed or stopped paying utility bills, and avoided medical treatments as a sacrifice to keep their household.

In case you think low-income families are free riders relishing the good life at the governmentโ€™s expense, consider these sobering statistics: 69% skipped washing dishes or doing laundry, 48% delayed changing a babyโ€™s diaper, and 32% reused diapers. When an increasingly large number of the populace is unable to afford hygienic products, it becomes that much easier for a virus to spread. A staggering number of Americans are currently unemployed, and the numbers will grow in the weeks ahead.

In the past three years, the political parties in America split on whether every move taken by President Trump is intelligent and useful, or asinine and harmful. The presidentโ€™s approval ratings rise and fall by month, ranging between 35% and 49%. Many objects to almost everything he says or does. Just like prior presidents, he makes poor decisionsโ€”and good decisions.

In our view, the decision to press the economy forward may be his best yet but the quality of that decision may take years to appreciate. We suggest readers consider both the short- and long-term consequences of a strategic resurgence of businesses and jobs. Instead of a blanket closure of everything, specific decisions to keep carefully sequestered healthy workplaces and workforces in action may prove most useful.

It will require a commitment to unusual guidelines, such as being geographically limited in activity (perhaps short-term lodging in businesses for those who are able). Donโ€™t let the media or social pressure push you into premature closure on a single answer without consideration of the multiple, interwoven factors at play. Magical silver bullets are rare and unlikely. The uncertainty that exists for the coronavirus can be buffeted by a large body of psychological data on the colossal economic, social, and health impact of unemployment.

Related: When Itโ€™s Time To Leave Your Toxic Workplace: 5 Red Flags

We donโ€™t have the answers. We are skeptical when people show absolute confidence in singular answers during uncertain situations. We do hope the policymakers experimenting with solutions are collecting data, upgrading their thinking based on new data, and being unafraid to change directions as warranted.

Todd B. Kashdan and Patrick E. McKnight are professors of psychology and co-lead The Well-Being Laboratory at George Mason University. Kashdan is the author of several books including Curious? and The Upside of Your Dark Side.


References
Boyce, C. J., Wood, A. M., Daly, M., & Sedikides, C. (2015). Personality change following unemployment. Journal of Applied Psychology, 100(4), 991-1011.
Diener, E., Lucas, R. E., & Scollon, C. N. (2006). Beyond the hedonic treadmill: revising the adaptation theory of well-being. American Psychologist, 61(4), 305-14.
Lucas, R. E., Clark, A. E., Georgellis, Y., & Diener, E. (2004). Unemployment alters the set point for life satisfaction. Psychological Science, 15(1), 8-13.
Nordt, C., Warnke, I., Seifritz, E., & Kawohl, W. (2015). Modelling suicide and unemployment: a longitudinal analysis covering 63 countries, 2000โ€“11. The Lancet Psychiatry, 2(3), 239-245.
Written by: Todd B. Kashdanย 
Originally appeared on: Psychology Today
Republished with permission
the aftermath of unemployment last pin

— Share —

,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

The Role Of ‘Resilient Mindset’ In Healing

Resilient Mindset The Healing Power Of A Positive Mindset

Does having a positive, resilient mindset support healing? Discover how hope, and balanced optimism might influence the bodyโ€™s natural ability to heal!

Can we influence our body’s ability to heal through cellular communication?

Key points

It’s important to strike the right balance of optimism, hope, belief, and realism.

A hopeful, resilient mindset could promote positive changes at the cellular level and boost healing.

There are cases of people who have been given a fatal prognosis and changed their outcome using mindset.

Up Next

Why Is Lying Wrong? Morals Are Not The Only Reason

โ€œI must not tell liesโ€œ, this famous line from Harry Potter is more than just a dialogue. Dolores Umbridge, made Harry Potter cut these words as a permanent mark on the back of his hand. But if asked โ€œWhy is lying wrong?โ€ The answer is always moralistic, which is subjective.

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

We have all received punishment

Up Next

Maladaptive Daydreaming: 5 Warning Signs That Your Inner World Is Distracting You

If you frequently find yourself lost in your thoughts, consider learning about maladaptive daydreaming disorder to help yourself from being trapped in your imagination!

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Taking a few moments to daydream can help a person take a break from reality and think more creatively or even solve problems. But when it goes to

Up Next

Is Lifestyle Creep Sneaking Up on You? 2 Key Signs to Reassess Your Spending Habits

Are you familiar with the term lifestyle creep? Even if you are not, you may be a part of it unknowingly. Wondering why? Because it comes very subtly with the upgradation of our lifestyle.

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

You get a raise or a bonus, and suddenly, your daily coffee turns into a pricey latte, your old car feels outdated, and that budget-friendly vacation de

Up Next

Why Itโ€™s So Hard to Admit Youโ€™re Wrong: 7 Surprising Psychological Barriers You Didnโ€™t Know About

Have you ever found yourself in the middle of a heated debate, feeling that gnawing sensation that you might be wrong, but donโ€™t want to admit it? Or maybe you are watching someone double down on their stance, even when all evidence points to the contrary, and wondering, โ€œWhy canโ€™t they just say theyโ€™re wrong?โ€ Itโ€™s a common scenario that plays out in classrooms, workplaces, and even family dinners, leaving many of us puzzled about why it is so hard to admit to being wrong.

Up Next

4 Powerful Ways to Accept Vulnerability and Sensitivity In Your Life

Vulnerability and sensitivity โ€“ are two character traits that are often misunderstood and considered obstacles, but did you know they can be blessings in disguise?

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Our early childhood and formative years, particularly in early infancy, adolescence, and young adulthood are the main times when we get maximum life-altering experiences. This

Up Next

7 Surprising Facts About Boredom: Learn The Science Of Ennui

Do you ever feel like youโ€™re never able to sit still? Boredom may seem like a simple inconvenience, but many surprising facts about boredom might change how you view those periods of listlessness.

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

The Science Behind Being Bored