Helicopter Parenting: How Keeping Children From Failing Can Promote Failure

Helicopter Parenting 1

Parenting can be a tough job at times, and every parent deserves the benefit of the doubt. But helicopter parenting sometimes ends up making things worse, for both the parent and their children. It might seem harmless from the outside, but too much of it can naturally be a bad thing.

The experience of having children is something that many of us have in common. In fact, in the United States, about 66 percent of women between the ages of 30 and 34 have children, and that number jumps to 80 percent if youโ€™re between the ages of 35 to 39, and 85 percent if youโ€™re over 40. Despite having this shared experience, no two parents approach raising children in exactly the same way.

There are many modern terms for different types of parenting styles; perhaps you identify with โ€œfree-range parenting,โ€ or โ€œattachment parenting,โ€ or maybe you like to think of yourself as a โ€œtiger mom.โ€ Among these new terms, the one that you are likely to hear the most about is called โ€œhelicopter parenting.โ€

The term helicopter parenting was coined in the 1990s and generally applies to parents who are overly involved in their childrenโ€™s lives

Parents who are involved especially in their childrenโ€™s academic and achievement-related activities. A textbook helicopter parent tends to remove obstacles that their children face in order to encourage them to succeed (Odenweller, Booth-Butterfield, & Weber, 2014).

Helicopter parents are generally well-educated, well-resourced parents who are incredibly well-intentioned, looking to both protect their children from trouble and provide them with as many opportunities as possible.

Having involved parents is generally a good thing, and, in fact, helicopter parenting has been associated with some positive parenting behaviors, such as frequent advice-giving and providing children with emotional support (Odenweller, Booth-Butterfield, & Weber, 2014). But constantly hovering can also come at a cost.

As children get older, they seek out more independence, and it can be a challenge for any parent to slowly relinquish control. This is especially difficult for helicopter parents, who tend to claim a large amount of control over their childrenโ€™s academic lives.

Related: 6 Signs You Are Raising An Overprotected Child

However, research suggests that inflexibly trying to maintain the same level of control over children regardless of whatโ€™s developmentally appropriate can be problematic (Schiffrin et al., 2014).

In fact, despite some of the positives of helicopter parenting, it has also been associated with negative child outcomes, such as higher levels of anxiety and depression, lower ratings of psychological well-being (LeMoyne & Buchanan, 2011), as well as a lack of independence and ineffective coping skills (Odenweller, Booth-Butterfield, & Weber, 2014).

And while the term โ€œhelicopter parentingโ€ is relatively new, research on the negative outcomes associated with over-control is not. Back in the 1960s, Diana Baumrind from the University of California at Berkeley famously identified three distinct parenting styles.

The โ€œauthoritarianโ€ parents she observed 60 years ago were a lot like the helicopter parents of today: They had very high standards for their childrenโ€™s behavior and exerted a large amount of control, allowing children very little autonomy. In contrast, the โ€œpermissiveโ€ parents were warm, claimed very little control over their childrenโ€™s behavior, and were relatively uninvolved with their childrenโ€™s everyday activities.

Finally, the โ€œauthoritativeโ€ parents occupied the sweet spot in the middle; they were supportive yet demanding. And perhaps most importantly, authoritative parents were flexibleโ€”they changed the rules as their children matured, which resulted in children who could also flexibly deal with the challenges they faced.

In fact, Baumrind found that children of authoritative parents were the most well-adjusted, and the most likely to be independent and well-socialized (Baumrind, 1966).

Although Baumrindโ€™s work isnโ€™t new, its message still rings true: Autonomy helps children learn how to deal with challenges on their own. By denying children independence, parents deny them the ability to develop the flexibility to learn from their mistakes (LeMoyne & Buchanan, 2011). In fact, cognitive flexibility is one of the best predictors of academic achievement (e.g., Blair & Raver, 2014).

And despite the good intentions of most over-involved parents, children of helicopter parents donโ€™t necessarily perform well in school. In fact, helicopter parenting is associated with lower academic performance in children, more extrinsic or reward-based motivation, and avoidance of goals for learning (Schiffrin & Liss, 2017).

In other words, these children donโ€™t develop the motivation to master new skillsโ€”they mostly just work hard to get a good gradeโ€”and they avoid feedback, as criticism or failure can lead to embarrassment or shame.

Related: 5 Kinds Of Fear-Based Parenting Every Parent Should Steer Clear Of

It turns out that children need to make mistakes to learn. For example, every typically developing baby will one day face the challenge of learning to walk. Importantly, walking isnโ€™t something babies learn to do in just one dayโ€”it takes days and weeks and months, with a lot of steps and falls along the way.

In fact, research has shown that infants between the ages of 12 and 19 months take an average of over 2,000 steps in a single hour of walking, and fall about 17 times during that same time period (Adolph, Cole, Komati, Garciaguirre, Badaly, Lingeman, Chan & Sotsky, 2012). Thatโ€™s a lot of mistakes, but every fall presents an opportunity to correct those mistakes and learn from them.

So what do we do? We do perhaps the most difficult thing a parent can doโ€”we let our children fail once in a while. By not allowing them to fail, we prevent them from learning how to flexibly deal with problems, and perhaps even how to deal with difficult emotions (Perez-Edgar, 2019).

Babies donโ€™t mind making mistakes, but as they get older, children eventually learn to associate making mistakes with feeling ashamed or embarrassed (Duckwork, 2016; Lewis, Alessandri, & Sullivan, 1992).

To avoid promoting these emotions, when children do mess up, gentle discipline coupled with support and feedback can help provide them with the right expectations and support autonomy at the same time (Baumrind, 2013; Grolnick & Pomerantz, 2009; Grusec, 2011; Stifter & Augustine, 2019).

Researchers have even suggested that parents try to model mistake-making for their kids, and some school interventions teach teachers to make grammatical mistakes on purpose and let children catch them (Bodrova & Leong, 2006).

Despite differences in parenting style, what all parents wantโ€”helicopter, tiger, and free-range alikeโ€”is whatโ€™s best for our kids. And sometimes whatโ€™s best for promoting their success is letting them experience their own failures.


Written By Vanessa LoBue
Originally Appeared In Psychology Today
Helicopter Parenting Fosters Failure pin
Helicopter Parenting PIN

— Share —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

Divorce And Holidays: 5 Co-Parenting Tips To Help Kids Enjoy Christmas

Helpful Divorce And Holidays Coping Tips For Parents

The festive season is often described as the most wonderful time of the year. However, divorce and holidays can be tricky to navigate for some families, itโ€™s not only challenging for kids but also for their parents.

Children deserve to be in happy and healthy homes, a safe space to enjoy and make memories rather than facing bickering fights and drama.

If youโ€™re co parenting on Christmas, create a holiday season thatโ€™s joyful and comforting for your children. Below are five practical divorce and holidays coping tips to help your kids enjoy the festivities, even after a separation or divorce.

Up Next

How To Deal With A Disrespectful Grown Child: 10 Parenting Moves That Work

How To Deal With A Disrespectful Grown Child

Itโ€™s one of the toughest pills to swallow: a disrespectful grown child. Whether theyโ€™re dismissing your advice, talking back, or just acting like they couldnโ€™t care less about you or your feelings, it hurts. But how to deal with a disrespectful grown child without feeling like youโ€™re losing your mind?

Today, we are going to talk about the signs of a disrespectful grown child and how to deal with one. Spoiler: Itโ€™s not about โ€œgetting back at themโ€ โ€” itโ€™s about creating change together, so that you can have a healthy relationship with each other, that’s based on mutual respect.

First, let’s start with the signs of a disrespectful grown child.

Related:

Up Next

Give Your Mom A Break: 5 Ways To Pamper Her This National Lazy Momโ€™s Day

Give Your Mom A Break Ways To Pamper Her

Motherhood is a non-stop role, with no time-outs or scheduled breaks. From managing household chores to balancing work and family life, moms are always on the go. This National Lazy Mom’s Day, it’s time to give mom a break and show her she deserves a day to relax and recharge.

Moms constantly juggle numerous tasks, leading to mental exhaustion and a lack of personal time. Just like anyone else, moms need a break to decompress and regain energy. A day of rest not only refreshes them but also helps them continue being the loving, attentive figures theyโ€™ve always been.

Up Next

The Parentified Daughter: 10 Signs Your Childhood Was Burdened With Responsibilities

Parentified Daughter Childhood Was Burdened With Responsibilities

They say girls โ€œmature too fast,โ€ but for some parentified daughters, itโ€™s a reality driven by the heavy responsibilities for their families, well beyond their years. This phenomenon is known as child parentification.

It occurs when a child is burdened with tasks and emotional support roles that should belong to their parents or guardians. When the parentified eldest daughter takes on responsibilities early in life, it can profoundly shape her personality and relationships.

If this sounds all too real, letโ€™s learn the common signs of a parentified daughter, so you can understand the unique challenges and childhood experiences that continue to influence their lives as adults.

Up Next

When Grandparentsโ€™ Love Goes Sour: 8 Signs Of Toxic Grandparents And How To Survive Them

Signs Of Toxic Grandparents

Have you ever noticed certain behaviors that make you wonder if your grandparentsโ€™ love might be a littleโ€ฆ off? Spotting the signs of toxic grandparents can be tough, especially when society paints them as the ultimate source of unconditional love and support.

But sometimes, grandparents might cross boundaries, show favoritism, or create a stressful environment that doesnโ€™t quite feel right. If youโ€™ve ever felt uneasy about their behavior, youโ€™re not alone.

In this article, weโ€™ll dive into the subtle and not-so-subtle signs of toxic grandparents and give you some strategies regarding how to deal with toxic grandparents, without causing family drama.

First, let us try to understand what are toxic grandparents.

Up Next

Unlocking The Pain Of The Past: 10 Signs Of Repressed Childhood Trauma In Adults

Signs Of Repressed Childhood Trauma In Adults 1

Ever find yourself reacting strongly to situations and not quite sure why? Either you hear echoes of your past, or itโ€™s probably because you listen to your inner child. In this article, weโ€™re delving into the signs of repressed childhood trauma in adults โ€“ those subtle whispers from your younger self that can shape your present.

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Up Next

The Hidden Toll of Childhood Emotional Incest: Identifying Signs and Effects

Signs of Emotional Incest In A Parent Child Relationship 1

Emotional incest confuses parent-child dynamics, creating emotional dependency. Letโ€™s look at the signs and effects of this incomprehensible relationship to gain a better understanding.

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Emotional incest has been compared to actual incest because it similarly creates long-lasting effects on psychosocial developme