Why You Underestimate How Much Other People Like You

Written By:

Written By:

Why You Underestimate 1

There are times when you feel unwanted amidst groups and canโ€™t tell if other people like you or not. You underestimate yourself and shy away from conversations.

The โ€œliking gapโ€ explains why you should feel upbeat after meeting new people.

We have all had the experience of walking away from a conversation with an interesting new acquaintance, wondering if the other person liked usย as much as weย liked them.ย All too often, we end up feeling a bit deflated and assume that we made a badย first impressionย by talking too much, not talking enough, or by not coming across as articulate and witty.

As it turns out, you are probably being too hard on yourself.

Why You Underestimate How Much Other People Like You

The โ€œLiking Gapโ€

Researchers have identified something known as the โ€œliking gap,โ€ which is our tendency to underestimate how much other people like us following an initial conversation.

Psychologistย Erica Boothbyย and her colleagues recently publishedย a series of five studiesย in which strangers had conversations with each other and then evaluated how much they liked their conversation partner, and also how much they thought their partner liked them back.ย Repeatedly, the researchers found that people reported liking their partners significantly more than they thought their partners liked them in return, and they also found the conversations to be more enjoyable and interesting than they thought their partners did.

This finding occurred in laboratory situations, as well as in real-life workshops attended by people who wanted to learn โ€œhow to talk with strangers,โ€ and the effect was especially pronounced among people who scored high on measures ofย shyness.

It was clear from Boothbyโ€™s studies that the problem was due to a failure to correctly read the signals that were being sent by oneโ€™s conversational partner because individuals who viewed videotapes of the conversations weโ€™re able to more accurately judge the degree of liking that people had for each other than were the participants themselves!

So, what is going on here?

Related: 9 Psychological Tricks To Attract People And Make Them Like You Immediately

Conversations Are Funny Things

Conversations with new people can be tricky to navigate. Other people do not yetย understand your sense of humorย (or lack thereof), and neither of you knows how much common knowledge you share or how closely your attitudes line up.ย Consequently, the conversation becomes a dance in which two people probe for feedback that can help to manage the awkwardness between them. Boothby describes conversations as โ€œconspiracies of politenessโ€ in which people abide by social norms and advance socially desirable versions of themselves. Needless to say,ย conversations involving more than two people become even more complicated.

And conversations require that we successfully balance the โ€œpushโ€ forces that keep people apart and the โ€œpullโ€ forces that bring them together.ย On the one hand, we want to get to know the other person, and we want them to like us (the โ€œpullโ€ย forces), but at the same time, we may be afraid of social rejection or of revealing too much, which may leave us in a vulnerable position (the โ€œpushโ€ forces).

In such conversations, other social psychological traps, such as the โ€œspotlight effect,โ€ can lead us to become too self-critical. The spotlight effect occurs when we overestimate the extent to which other people are focusing on us, especially on our shortcomings. We beat ourselves up over every physical imperfection, every awkward question, and every lame joke โ€” and we think that other people remember these things more vividly and judge us more harshly than they actually do. Becoming aware of the spotlight effect can help put you at ease in social situations and make you more interpersonally effective.

Related: The Mirror Effect Of An Empath: Why Some People Dislike You Instantly

Hence, Boothby and her colleagues concluded that other people we converse with are in fact communicating how much they like us, both verbally and nonverbally, but ourย fearย ofย embarrassmentย and our preoccupation with the minutiae of self-presentation gets in the way โ€” causing us to miss the very signalsย that we do hope to see.

Part of becoming a good conversationalist is accurately deciphering how others feel about us. Coming to terms with the liking gap may be a good first step.

Written Byย Frank T. McAndrew
Originally Appeared Inย Psychology Today

Most of the time, you might believe that you like someone more than they like you. Even though that might be true in some cases, that wonโ€™t be the case every time. The moment you know and understand how the other person feels about you, you will be able to detect what they are thinking, and how they perceive you.


Underestimate Other People Like You Pin
Why You Underestimate Pin

— Share —

Published On:

Last updated on:

,

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Up Next

Why Relationship FOMO Shouldn’t Define Your Love Life

Impacts Of Relationship FOMO To Your Love Life

Are you settling for love just because everyone else seems to have it? Is relationship FOMO driving your choices? Hereโ€™s why it shouldnโ€™t define your love life!

Lagging behind whose timeline? Here’s how anxiety can spoil relationship pacing.

Key points

Take time to understand the true motivations behind relationship pace.

It’s important to avoid perceived expectations and define success on one’s own terms.

โ€œExpected timelinesโ€ or โ€œgreener pasturesโ€ can create a sense of urgency and distress.

Up Next

5 Clear Signs You Possess The World’s Most Go Getter Personality

Amazing Go Getter Personality Traits: Do You Relate?

Not everyone wakes up ready to chase their dreams like their life depends on it, but you? Youโ€™re different. Having a go getter personality means that youโ€™ve got that spark, that unstoppable drive that makes people take notice. 

If youโ€™ve ever caught yourself wondering why youโ€™re the one always making moves while others are still talking about “someday”…

Here are five clear signs youโ€™re rocking the worldโ€™s most go-getter personality. Letโ€™s dive in and see if youโ€™ve got what it takes to claim the title.

Up Next

Learn To Honor Your Feelings: Your Hard Week Mattersโ€”Even If Others Have It Worse

Learn To Honor Your Feelings Great Ways To Do It

It’s okay to feel overwhelmed, even if others seem to have bigger struggles. Learn how to honor your feelings – they are valid, and you deserve acknowledgment!

How to honor your feelings without comparing them to othersโ€™ challenges.

Key points

Your emotions are valid no matter their scale or how they compare to othersโ€™ challenges.

Acknowledging your emotions builds your strength to support others with authenticity and genuine care.

Comparison of struggles creates a false hierarchy that undermines the importance of your own experience.

Research shows that acknowledging th

Up Next

How To Stop Being Judgmental 5 Ways to Undo a Critical Mindset

How To Stop Being Judgmental? Ways to Undo a Critical Mindset

Hereโ€™s the deal: learning how to stop being judgmental isnโ€™t just about being nice; itโ€™s about freeing yourself from a critical mindset that holds you back. If youโ€™ve been looking for ways to stop judging others (and yourself), these five tips will help you chill out and see the world through a kinder lens. Let’s find out what you can do to stop being critical!

KEY POINTS

Judging others doesnโ€™t just harm our relationshipsโ€”it also takes a toll on our mental health.

Minimizing our judgments and critical thoughts of others is something everyone can work on.

Science-based tips include controlling biases, practicing empathy,

Up Next

15 Important Benefits of Keeping Your Life Private

Keeping Your Life Private? Important Benefits of It

Social media makes it tempting to share everything, from your morning coffee to your biggest achievements, but have you ever stopped to wonder what it would be like to keep some things just for yourself? Below are 15 benefits of keeping your life private.

Sure, social media helps you stay connected, but is constantly being “on display” actually helping us? Could overexposure be adding unnecessary stress or even complicating your relationships?

So, take a look at the benefits of keeping things private…

Up Next

8 Excuses That Are Holding You Back From Success

Excuses That Are Holding You Back From Success

Have you ever caught yourself procrastinating, saying โ€œIโ€™ll do it tomorrowโ€ or โ€œIโ€™m just not ready yetโ€? These words may feel harmless, but theyโ€™re excuses that are holding you back and keeping you from achieving your goals.

Itโ€™s not your circumstances, or bad luck. Itโ€™s you. Yep, all those excuses youโ€™ve been making, theyโ€™re the chains keeping you stuck.

We all have dreams and aspirations, but the path to achieving them is often blocked, not by insurmountable challenges, but by the bad excuses we make.

So, letโ€™s dive into the 8 most common excuses that keep you away from success and how to break free from them.

Up Next

Discovering The Family Within You

Discover The Family Within You Important Points To Know

Did you know your mind has a family within you? There are “parts” known as sub-personalities that need care, and a wise Self ready to guide and heal. Let’s explore to learn more!

IFS founder Richard Schwartz on the children โ€” and the parents โ€” in our minds.

Key points

Our minds are naturally made up of “parts” or sub-personalities.

We also have a Self, a center of calm, clarity, compassion, and connectedness.

The Self has the ability to parent and heal the other parts.

Spirituality has negatively construed o