You Can’t Use 100% of Your Brain and That’s a Good Thing

 / 

,
Cant Use Brain Good Thing

In Part 2 of this post, we examine what your brain’s activity really looks like. In the first part of this series, I discussed the idea that we only use 10% of our brains.

I showed recent neuroscientific evidence that there is a substantial number of neurons that don’t seem to have any usefulness we can discern.

The number of unused neurons is probably less than 90%—I suggested it may be closer to 50%. But I still think the 10% value is a useful reference point.

Why?

The 10% myth is helpful because it turns out that there is a subtler and more consequential way in which its value is closer to the truth than the 100% value. It has to do with a phrase I used in the previous post: brain usage over time. This brings us to an important concept called sparseness. It’s a term coined by Cornell neuroscientist David Field to describe large-scale patterns of neural activity.

Read 5 Powerful Mind And Body Hacks For A Limitless Brain

Sparseness

Sparseness is about patterns that go beyond the mere sum of activity. It is really about how activity is distributed across neurons and over time.

In a sparse system, a few units in the population are very active at a time, while the rest are quiet. Over time, most units participate. This pattern of activity would be said to have high population sparseness. In contrast, a system that uses most units at least a little bit at any given moment would have low population sparseness.

The same framework is used for characterizing single neurons over time. In this case, high lifetime sparseness means that a neuron is only active in rare bursts of high activity, while low lifetime sparseness would indicate that a neuron is active at a low level almost all the time.

It’s helpful here to make an analogy with written language. We can communicate a given thought by writing it in English, or pretty much equivalently in Chinese. Yet the coding systems of these two languages are quite different. To express almost any idea in written English, we would be using nearly all coding units—the 26 letters—at least once. Analogizing the letters with neurons is like using all neurons in the brain at a low level for a given task. We can say that a system like written English has low sparseness.

In Chinese, only a handful of the thousands of characters would be needed to express the same thought. Each character’s use would be emphatic since characters come in a wide variety of quite distinct forms, and most are not repeated in a single thought. This is like using a few neurons at a time at a high level. Chinese, then, corresponds to high sparseness.

Neither system is inherently better than the other—both have advantages and disadvantages. What we want to know is, which written language is most like the pattern of activity in the brain?

Through empirical and theoretical research over the last 35 years, it has become clear that the brain’s activity is quite sparse.

Read Untreated Depression Can Change the Brain Over Time – Study Says

Why brain’s activity is quite sparse?

It behaves this way for two main reasons.

First, it is due to the way neurons work, meaning the biochemical and biophysical rules that govern their operation.

This is the case both across neural populations and over time. Limitations on blood flow—which restrict how much energy can be delivered to many neurons—push the system toward high population sparseness. In the time domain, neural machinery is fundamentally based around emitting a brief, sharp burst of pent-up energy, then spending longer periods recharging for another burst.

They can’t be just a little active most of the time. The best theoretical estimates of the situation—though they make substantial assumptions about and simplifications of a very complex system—converge on a limit of about 10% usage in the mammal brain (1, 2, 3). Sound familiar?

Second, sparseness is demanded because the world is sparse.

In our environment—and, correspondingly, in our heads—things happen in bursts, rather than at a low level all the time. This includes events, objects, attention, action, meaning, and decisions.

David Field, working with UC Berkeley neuroscientist Bruno Olshausen, followed this line of thinking in a landmark 1996 paper about sparseness in the visual system. They used computational models to show that our brains assume sparse structure in the spatial patterns of the world around us.

Essentially, they built a computational system that was forced to learn a sparse code. The code or “alphabet” is much like a written language, except it encodes pictures (small chunks of natural images) rather than words. What they found was that the visual alphabet that the computer model learned strongly resembled the alphabet used in our visual system.

In other words, in a system trained to simply be sparse, the brain’s basic strategy for analyzing the visual world pops out “for free” and without being explicitly pre-programmed. As it turns out, sparse coding also has strong connections to the current “deep learning” revolution in artificial intelligence, which I will discuss in future posts.

Getting back to the recent study led by Saskia de Vries of the Allen Institute, which I mentioned in the first post, one of the researchers’ main goals was to measure sparseness. With this information, we can estimate what proportion of the brain is active at the same time.

Across the visual areas, they sampled, and in different layers of the cortex, the de Vries data imply that around 20% of neurons are typically active at the same time. Although about three-quarters of visual neurons respond regularly, only about one in five is active at a time. And over time, individual neurons were active only during about 20% of the length of the recordings. Clearly, these values are closer to the 10% value, which I suggested as a rule of thumb than they are to the 100% myth.

What does all this have to do with your internet brain? The key is that the internet is also sparse. It is active in bursts, both across the network at a given time and within communication channels over time.

Read What Near-Death Experiences Reveal about the Brain

You can get a sense of the activity by monitoring your computer’s wifi signals. Macintosh users can open the application Activity Monitor (in the Utilities folder) and examine the Network tab. You will see a plot of message chunks (packets) sent and received by your computer over time. Unless you are using a great deal of bandwidth, the trace will generally appear sparse and bursty, like this:

Brains and the internet share sparse operating conditions. But we can go further. Another lesson of the internet metaphor for the brain is that occasional brief signals are crucial for making the system work. We are naturally attracted to strong, consistent signals in the brain, and to the bright flashes when the brain “lights up.” But following the internet metaphor, short spurts of activity are also crucial.

On the internet, there are a variety of brief signal bursts that allow routers to stay in contact. Importantly, these signal bursts don’t carry any message content. The signals include ACKs or acknowledgments, which tell a sending router that a set of messages was received at its destination. Routers also periodically send keep-alives, which are small messages that tell network neighbors that a router is ready to transmit messages.

If the brain used a similar strategy, these kinds of tiny messages would be missed or misunderstood if we were only concerned with situations where lots of neurons are active together. Like the internet, many signals in the brain probably relate to keeping the communication system working, rather than performing a specific task or behavior. It is about keeping the whole brain network “reachable,” which is something the internet excels at.

The brain has the same limitations on activity as the internet—in both systems, we can’t have all components active at once, even at a low level.

Crucially, both systems are fundamentally designed to pass messages across a vast and highly interconnected network.

I explore this parallel between the internet and the brain (and many more) in my new book, An Internet in Your Head. I will discuss some of these parallels in future posts.

Read 22 Tips to Keep Your brain Sharp and Young At Any Age 

So what level of sparseness should we aim for?

Though the de Vries study is a big step forward, we are still a long way from having a good picture of large-scale brain activity in our own brains. At present, we can’t say what the ideal value of sparseness would be for humans, let alone how to achieve it. The most we can say now is that some substantial degree of sparseness is required.

But perhaps less is more? I’ll conclude with a short passage from An Internet in Your Head:

David Field, who was my Ph.D. advisor, has taken the principle of sparse coding to heart, or to brain as it were. Given the limit of 10 percent or fewer cells highly active at a time in the brain, David likes to joke that he is trying to get his personal total down to 5 percent. He may be on to something.


References

  • Attwell, D., & Laughlin, S. B. (2001). An energy budget for signaling in the grey matter of the brain. Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow & Metabolism, 21(10), 1133-1145.
  • de Vries, S. E., Lecoq, J. A., Buice, M. A., Groblewski, P. A., Ocker, G. K., Oliver, M., … & Koch, C. (2020). A large-scale standardized physiological survey reveals functional organization of the mouse visual cortex. Nature Neuroscience, 23(1), 138-151.
  • Lennie, P. (2003). The cost of cortical computation. Current Biology, 13(6), 493-497.
  • Levy, W. B., & Baxter, R. A. (1996). Energy efficient neural codes. Neural Computation, 8(3), 531-543.
  • Olshausen, B. A., & Field, D. J. (1996). Emergence of simple-cell receptive field properties by learning a sparse code for natural images. Nature, 381(6583), 607-609.

Written by: Daniel Graham, Ph.D., the author of An Internet in Your Head: A New Paradigm for How the Brain Works
Originally appeared on: Pyschology Today
Republished with permission.
Cant Use Brain Good Thing pin

— Share —

— About the Author —

Response

  1. Samuel Espinal Avatar
    Samuel Espinal

    Makes sense. I mean the brain does so much more than what we use it for. Our brain makes everything in our bodies function without us using it. We don’t use our brains to breathe, to make our hearts beat, to make our eyes see, to make our noses smell, to make our stomach digest, to make our bladders to urine and etc… Our brains are constantly working to keep us alive. So yes I do believe that 90% of the brain operates in that manner.

Leave a Reply



Up Next

6 Benefits Of Walking: Why It’s One Of The Best Things You Can Do For Your Mental Health

Brilliant Benefits Of Walking For Your Mental Health

Walking is so underrated when it comes to ensuring mental well-being. There are so many powerful benefits of walking that can do wonders for our mental and emotional health. This article is going to talk about some of the best mental health benefits of walking.

Boost your mood, energy level, confidence, and more simply by getting your steps in.

Taking a brisk walk is a great way to clear your head, calm your mood, and keep you healthy. It may seem simple, but walking can have a powerful effect on your mental health, and the good news is that it’s free.



Up Next

Neuro-Ninja Training: 10 Indoor Brain Strengthening Games For A Sharp Mind

Powerful Brain Strengthening Games For A Sharp Mind

Do you want to exercise your brain in the most fun, interesting, and most importantly, enjoyable way possible? Then you have come to the right place! Keeping your mind sharp and your brain alert is one of the most powerful things you can do. That’s why, we have compiled a list of brain strengthening games for you to try.

These brain strengthening games will boost your brain, keep you entertained and also increase your intellect. No more of those boring games to improve memory and concentration, because these are designed to be fun and exciting.

So, ready to explore how you can train your brain with games? Le



Up Next

15 Provocative Questions To Trigger Curiosity And Help In Creative Problem-Solving

Provocative Questions To Trigger Curiosity

If you are have ever thought how to trigger your curiosity, then you have come to the right place. Embracing curiosity is one of the best things you can do for yourself, and the curiosity questions mentioned in this article will help you achieve that goal. Check out these 15 questions to trigger curiosity and see how it works for you!

KEY POINTS

The ability to be curious generally declines in adulthood.

Curiosity is a portal to increased innovation.

Curiosity can be relearned with the right questions.

Today’s curiosi



Up Next

How Do Some People ‘Hear’ Colors And ‘See’ Sounds? — A Look Into Synesthesia

What Is Synesthesia? Interesting Types Of Synesthesia?

What does the color red sound like? Only those with the power of synesthesia can truly “hear” it. It is a secret power that about 4% of people have – their senses make unexpected connections.

Researchers are now diving into this new world to understand more about these sensory experiences where one is hearing colors and seeing sounds. So let’s dive in and learn what is synesthesia actually.

What Is Synesthesia?



Up Next

What Is Counterfactual Thinking: The Psychological Forces and Life-Altering Impact of ‘What Ifs

What Is Counterfactual Thinking? Psychological Insights

Have you ever wondered, ‘If only I had done something differently, then the results would be different’? This thought process is an example of counterfactual thinking in action. Understanding what is counterfactual thinking involves exploring our minds’ ‘what if’ scenarios.”

We will look at four real-life situations that show how thinking about “what if” can change how we see ourselves and the world around us.

But before exploring the examples, let us first understand what is counterfactual thinking.

What is Counterfactual Thinking?   



Up Next

Understanding The Mind Body Connection Definition: 3 Compelling Benefits of This Holistic Approach to Well-Being

Mind Body Connection Definition | Powerful Benefits

Have you ever felt that the constant noise of modern life drowns out the whispers of your inner self? By understanding the mind-body connection definition you will be able to forge a path of self-discovery and holistic well-being.

Mind Body Connection Definition  

The mind body connection is a fundamental concept that emphasizes the link between our mental and physical well-being. It’s all about understanding that our minds and bodies are not separate entities but work together as a unified system.



Up Next

Understanding Solastalgia Meaning: The Subtle yet Profound Emotional Impact of Environmental Change

Solastalgia Meaning: Environmental Change's Emotional Impact

Have you ever felt a profound sense of loss and disconnection, even while standing in a place you once called home? It is more than just nostalgia! Understanding solastalgia meaning helps us to understand our relationship with our environment.

We will delve into three primary causes of solastalgia. These insights will not only inform but also leave you with a deep appreciation for the relationship between your emotions and the ever-changing landscapes of your lives.

What is Solastalgia?  

Solastalgia, a term born from the fusion of ‘solace’ and ‘algia,’ carries profound significance in our understanding of the emotional impact of environmental chang