The Power Of Intrinsic Motivation

 / 

,
the power of intrinsic motivation

The most powerful habits are those that come completely from within. Read on to know the psychology of intrinsic motivation and rewards.

Over decades of secrecy and solitude, Henry Darger worked obsessively at his art.

He toiled tirelessly across several mediums, but his masterpiece was an illustrated epic novel. Verbosely titled โ€œThe Story of the Vivian Girls in What Is Known as the Realms of the Unreal of the Glandeco-Angelinian War Storm Causes by the Child Slave Rebellion,โ€ the entire document was over 15,000 pages long.

But despite dedicating his life to his art, it was never seen by anyone else until his death. It was only when he died, aged 79, that any of his work was discovered.

He also didnโ€™t have any living relatives or friends. All of his belongings, including his opus of artistic works, fell by default to the ownership of his landlord, Nathan Lerner. On his deathbed, he told him to throw it all in the trash. However, Lerner was a photographer and instantly recognized its artistic value.

Lerner shared his pieces with the greater art world, which became similarly taken in by his work. He slowly accumulated a cult following, and today, a single original piece of his sells for more than $750,000.

Despite no formal training, Dargerโ€™s artistic ability is impressive. But that isnโ€™t what has drawn so much attention to his work. Above anything, the fascination with Darger has to do with the unique motivational state behind his art. How could someone dedicate so much to art that he never wanted anyone to see, much less buy?

Darger and his artwork provide an interesting window into the science of motivation.

Related: 10 Reminders When You Feel Youโ€™re Never Going To Be Enough

The Psychology Of Intrinsic And Extrinsic Motivation

Motivation is complex. Letโ€™s say we went for a run this morning. Why did we do it? Because it feels good? Because we want to be healthy? Because we simply go for a run every morning?

For any given behavior, our motivations for it fall into two general camps: extrinsic and intrinsic.

Intrinsic motivation is the drive that comes purely from within, without any ostensible external rewards. You do it because itโ€™s inherently enjoyable, and not because of any anticipated reward, deadline, or outside pressure. This describes Henry Dargerโ€™s drive for art. He wasnโ€™t trying to achieve anything with it: he wasnโ€™t trying to build a following, win awards, or sell his creative output. Instead, his artwork was done for the act itself.

People who are intrinsically motivated to run do so because they simply love the act of running itself. It feels like an important part of your identity, and you love the act of it itself โ€” regardless of anything that can come of it.

People Are Usually Much More Creative When They Are Intrinsically Motivated

Intrinsic motivation is great. In art, sports, or otherwise, truly loving the behavior itself, will keep you going like nothing else.

But of course, thatโ€™s not always the case with everything we do. We might not love our jobs but we go to work anyway; we might not love running but we lace up our running shoes every morning. This is where extrinsic motivation comes in.

Related: How To Unleash Your Inner Yoda: The 8 Step Plan To Lead Your Team Through Uncertainty

When youโ€™re extrinsically motivated, youโ€™re doing the behavior to gain an external reward. If youโ€™re not a fan of your job, youโ€™re still a fan of getting paid and so the salary serves as extrinsic motivation. If youโ€™re training for a marathon, youโ€™re trying to improve your speed and endurance.

You could also be driven to maintain a personal streak of consecutive days running, or trying to compete with your friends for โ€˜most milesโ€™ on a running app. All of these are extrinsic motivators. Turns out, beyond an activity, motivation can also be a product.

How Extrinsic Motivation Influences Performance

Put simply, people want motivation: to change their behavior, to get better at a behavior, or to develop better habits. These are common in the sports training and wellness apps industry. Apps like Nike+, Strava, and Wahoo Fitness are designed to help consumers do exactly this.

And when it comes to the mechanism, thereโ€™s a clear choice: extrinsic motivation. Extrinsic drivers are simply much easier to implement within an app. These techniques take many forms: from tracking โ€˜running streaksโ€™, to digital rewards such as tokens, to displaying leaderboards so you can feel good about beating your friends.

Each of these provides a simple extrinsic reward, which pushes the behavior along. With the right structure, these rewards can also establish habits as well.

So far so good: they can be easily productized, coded into an app, and they reliably drive behavior. However, the world of extrinsic rewards is not without its downsides.

In certain situations, they can actually undermine performance. Consider the following perspective on marathon running, from Adam Alterโ€™s book Irresistible.

Since running performance exists on a normal distribution, we might expect that marathon finish times would as well. But they look very different in actuality. The times arenโ€™t normally distributed but clustered around these โ€œgoal times,โ€ and followed by significant drop-offs. The distribution of marathon times looks like this:

Why is that? In the form of finish times, these goals pushed runners that extra bit further. If that 3 hour finish time is just within reach, youโ€™ll run that extra bit faster to get there. Weโ€™ll enjoy that accomplishment for the time being, but once we reach it, we start all over with the next one. As you can see, these extrinsic goals only take us so far.

Related: 8 Inspirational TED Talks For Parents

Oliver Burkeman spoke about this phenomenon in a recent article for The Guardian:

โ€œWhen you approach life as a sequence of milestones to be achieved, you exist โ€œin a state of near-continuous failure.โ€ Almost all the time, by definition, youโ€™re not at the place youโ€™ve defined as embodying accomplishment or success. And should you get there, youโ€™ll find youโ€™ve lost the very thing that gave you a sense of purposeโ€”so youโ€™ll formulate a new goal and start again.โ€

This constant strain is similar to the concept of the โ€˜hedonic treadmill,โ€™ a feature of our consumer behavior. We feel certain weโ€™ll finally be happy once we meet our consumer goals. Whether itโ€™s getting the newest car, the newest iPhone, or our millionth follower on Twitter, we feel convinced that once we get this, weโ€™ll finally feel content.

But just like marathon finish times, achieving them feels good for the time being. But once we reach them, weโ€™re left in the same place: looking for the next goal to strive for.

Related: 7 Ways To Motivate Kids To Get Things Done

The Psychology Of The Overjustification Effect

In a word, extrinsic rewards are fleeting. They’re great in the short term, but they tend to dissipate long-term. But the downsides of extrinsic rewards donโ€™t end there: they can also have a negative impact on our intrinsic drive.

This can be seen, for example, in childrenโ€™s art. Most kids simply love to draw. Leave a child with a stack of blank papers and a coloring set, and theyโ€™re all set. Some will draw for hours on end, without interruption and without any need for prodding. Like Darger, their motivation is completely intrinsic; they do it simply because they enjoy it.

How can you get a child to stop drawing? Tell them youโ€™ll give them a dollar for every picture they make.

Thatโ€™s right. The most efficient way to stop this behavior is to give them an extrinsic reward. There’s a slight uptick when the money is first given, but itโ€™s all downhill from there. As the dollars start to accumulate, their drive steadily declines. And before long, the child loses interest in the activity altogether.

This is known as the overjustification effect:

If a child is already intrinsically motivated to do something, and then you layer on an extrinsic reward for it, the behavior decreases. Studies have found this not only with childrenโ€™s drawing, but with music, dance, and sports as well.

The same is often true for adults. Think of the classic Jerry Maguire storyline: a young athlete who plays and competes for the love of the game (intrinsically motivated). When they go pro and finally get paid to play (extrinsically motivated), their drive to play goes down. Or artists who were originally driven by their own curiosity, only to become jaded when theyโ€™re rewarded for their art with fame and fortune.

Related: Why a Growth Mindset is Essential Throughout Life

Final Thoughts On Intrinsic Rewards And The Psychology Of Motivation

All in all, extrinsic rewards can drive behavior, especially in the short term. But whether in art, sports or life, if that behavior is already intrinsically motivated, adding in a reward can have the opposite effect on it. Extrinsic motivation is a fickle thing.

In contrast, intrinsic motivation is like an endless wellspring. It drives behavior from within. We engage in the behavior because of a love for it itself, irrespective of its instrumental value. In that sense, the behavior becomes integrated with our identity.

Compared to extrinsic rewards, the difficulty lies in our inability to directly give someone an intrinsic drive. Itโ€™s much easier to program external rewards into a running app than it is to program in a genuine love of running. Intrinsic motivation is rarer and more difficult to harness.

In the running world, these are people who simply love to run; running for runningโ€™s sake. And in the art world, these are people like Henry Darger: the rare ones who simply create for the sake of creation.

References

Burkeman, O. (2014) Want to succeed? You need systems not goals, The Guardian

Cerasoli, C. P., Nicklin, J. M., & Ford, M. T. (2014). Intrinsic Motivation and Extrinsic Incentives Jointly Predict Performance: A 40-Year Meta-Analysis. Psychological Bulletin. Advance online publication. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/a0035661

D'Alessio, F.N. (July 29, 2008). "Posthumous fame grows for artist Henry Darger". The San Francisco Chronicle. Associated Press. Retrieved November 24, 2018.

"Henry Darger Room Collection". Art.org. Archived from the original on October 27, 2017.

Warneken, F. & Tomasello, M. (2008). Extrinsic Rewards Undermine Altruistic Tendencies in 20-Month-Olds. Developmental psychology. 44. 1785-8. 10.1037/a0013860.

Written by: Matt Johnson, Ph.D
Originally appeared on:Psychology Today
Republished with permission
the power of intrinsic motivation pin

— Share —

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply



Up Next

Focus Like A Monk: What Is Monk Mode And 10 Ways It Can Help You Succeed In Lifeย 

What is Monk Mode and How Can It Transform Your Life?

Do you find it hard to focus on a task? Do you get easily distracted? Not sure how to enter a flow state and do your best? If you are looking for ways to focus amidst the chaos and find some inner peace, then let me introduce you to the fascinating concept of “Monk Mode.” What is monk mode, you ask?

If you have been on social media lately, you must have heard about monk mode, a concept that has been gaining a lot of attention on TikTok. Based on the mindset and lifestyle of disciplined monks, this process allows us to reach our peak productivity.

So let us delve into the depths of monk mode, explore the myriad monk mode benefits, and provide practical tips on how to get into monk mode to transform your life.

What is M



Up Next

What To Say When Someone Dies โ€” And 7 Things Not To Say

What To Say When Someone Dies? Best And Worst Things

Death is hard. Finding the right words to say when someoneโ€™s hurting can be even harder. Wondering what to say when someone dies? Below are some do’s and don’ts for you to note down!

“I’m sorry for your loss” is a classic line, but it might not always hit the mark. Sometimes, it can feel like a generic response rather than genuine comfort. There are many other comforting words to say when someone dies. Let’s break it down below.

Related: How To Overcome The Fear Of Losing Someone You Love: 10 Tips



Up Next

Who Run The World? Girls: 11 Most Successful Women In The World

Most Successful Women who inspires you

If you’re in your 20s or 30s and still feel like a failure in life, let these 11 of the most successful women in the world be your boost of inspiration. In their early 20s, some of the most remarkable women of our time were also struggling just like you. But now look at them! They’re running the world.

According to research, the majority (57%) of people tend to lose all hope in landing their dream jobs at the average age of 30. However, there are successful women out there who did not let go. They still managed to do great things by becoming powerful people who became successful later in life.



Up Next

5 Things That Hold You Back From Achieving Your Dreams

Things That Hold You Back From Achieving Your Dreams

Do you feel like you’re stuck in a rut, and no matter how hard you try, you just can’t seem to get out of it? Achieving your dreams and achieving your goals can feel intimidating when there are things that hold you back, more like, obstacles. Read on to know more about the things that stop you from achieving your goals.

KEY POINTS

Five main obstacles stop people from achieving their career dreams.

Fear of failure is high on the list.

There are workable strategies for overcoming the main career obstacles.



Up Next

How Can I Become More Confident: 10 Effective Tips To Gain Confidence and Boost Self-Esteem!

How Can I Become More Confident in Transformative Ways!

Confidence, in the vast theatre of life, is like a bright floodlight that shines on everything we do. Itโ€™s as if itโ€™s a magic ingredient that changes ambiguity to attractiveness, indecision to elegance, and doubt to faith.

When people ask how can I become more confident? It often feels like they are asking how do I stop being scared and worried.

If you are going through similar struggles, donโ€™t worry we have got you covered!

This article is just like a friendly guide that looks into everything affecting your confidence level. We will give you simple tools for breaking free from self-doubt and finding your self-confidence.



Up Next

Finding Your Way: 10 Steps To Move Forward When You Feel Stuck

When You Feel Stuck: Steps For Moving Forward In Life

When you feel stuck, it can make you feel like you are caught in quicksand and you are sinking and no matter how hard you try, you just can’t seem to get out of it. But there’s always a way out of every sticky situation in life. Whenever you are feeling stuck in a rut, remind yourself of these 10 things you can do to stop feeling so bogged down.

Let’s explore what to do when you feel stuck and how to stop feeling stuck in life.

KEY POINTS

The sooner you can free your thoughts, the better you will feel.

Work on a different



Up Next

7 Reasons Why People With Difficult Childhoods Soar In Resilience: The Phoenix Effect !

Causes People With Difficult Childhoods Soar In Resilience

Growing up is not always an easy journey to be in, is it? And especially for some people, it can be particularly difficult, and traumatic even. However, people with difficult childhoods, more often than not, are the ones who grow up to be extremely resilient. The situations that could have knocked them down for good, they use those situations to become even stronger.

Every time they are knocked down, they get back up and do what they need to do to thrive. It’s nothing less than a superpower! Resilient adults overcoming a cruel past is one of the most inspirational things to witness.

This article is