Why Do Women Need Control Over Their Bodies? Understanding Abortion Laws in India

Published on:

Abortion Laws

The issue of abortion has consistently sparked considerable debate and conversation. Some individuals advocate for the rights of mothers or pregnant women to choose to continue with the pregnancy or terminate it; conversely, others believe that a foetus is more than just a mere collection of cells, viewing it as a living entity with its own life, deserving of individual rights and freedoms separate from those of the pregnant woman. A notable instance when personal freedoms were at risk was when women’s access to safe abortion services was jeopardized. For many years, until 1971, India deemed abortion criminal and referred to it as โ€œintentionally causing miscarriage.โ€ Voluntary abortion, except in cases where the pregnant woman’s life was endangered, could result in a punishment of up to three years in prison, a monetary fine, or both.

Nevertheless, the alarming rates of maternal fatalities and deaths from illegal abortion proceduresโ€”often carried out in unsafe, unsanitary conditions by unqualified practitionersโ€”prompted the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare to take action. This led to the implementation of the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act in 1971, which outlined the legal framework for abortion and addressed critical inquiries regarding who is permitted to terminate a pregnancy, the locations where it may occur, and the necessary consent and opinions required for the procedure. The Act underwent amendments in 2002 and 2003, with proposed changes also considered in 2014. In India, the legal system regulating abortion is heavily influenced by a cis heteropatriarchal framework that employs a punitive criminal justice system to exert control over pregnant individuals.

The Indian Penal Code’s Sections 312-318, along with the POCSO Act and the PCPNDT Act, create a criminal framework that fosters state surveillance, which intimidates both abortion providers and those seeking abortions. Legal cases prove that criminalization has a very harmful “chilling effect” on both the providers of healthcare and the seekers of abortion. Illegal abortions impose a stigma that threatens to curtail individual reproductive decision-making authority by forcing individuals to make harsh choices between safe but prosecutable procedures, unsafe abortions with possible health consequences, or continuing an unwanted pregnancy. All these factors affect disadvantaged groups callously. In this article, I examine the present consequences through a feminist lens and argue how these punitive policies cannot resolve some of the structural barriers in the way of fulfilling reproductive rights.

Women and their rights to abortion- A guide to the right to choose

Women and their ability to make decisions regarding their sexuality, fertility, and reproduction are aspects that have rarely, if ever, been considered in the creation of abortion-related policies. Abortion stands as one of the most contentious ethical dilemmas because it involves the issue of taking a human life. Typically, when examining the traditional arguments for and against abortion, we observe that legal and religious reasoning often underpin each side, respectively. Proponents of abortion advocate the idea that it embodies a womanโ€™s “right to choose” whether to continue or end her pregnancy. Opponents of abortion commonly base their arguments on religious beliefs, which serve as the main foundation of their collective resistance to abortion.

Historically, women have utilized various methods of birth control and abortion. These practices have sparked fierce moral, ethical, political, and legal discussions since abortion transcends a medical/technical concern and represents “the fulcrum of a much broader ideological struggle.

This viewpoint is backed by the historical context of international human rights treaties. Throughout the discussions that led to the creation of various international and regional human rights agreements, only a limited number of nations suggested including provisions that would recognize the right to life from the moment of conception. In most instances, these suggestions were turned down. the United Nations have. While the declaration reflects the collective understanding of the international community regarding human rights, it does not impose any legal obligations.

The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) reinforces the right to life stated in the declaration. The law shall protect this right. In contrast to the term โ€œperson,โ€ which, due to judicial interpretation in the United States (US), has excluded the unborn from protection, โ€œhuman beingโ€ is a scientific term for a living human organism. Therefore, one perspective holds that the fundamental human rights documents oppose abortion; they certainly do not establish a right to abortion.

Feminism and Womenโ€™s Right to Abortion

Equality, which is the fundamental objective of feminism, is central to the Indian Constitution. Nevertheless, there is a significant gap between this constitutional promise and the actual situation. Issues such as unequal wages, inadequate representation in public sectors, and restricted educational opportunities highlight the urgent need for reform. The Indian judiciary has made notable contributions toward this issue. A prime example is Anuj Garg v Hotel Association of India (1). This case questioned the constitutionality of Section 30 of the Punjab Excise Act, a law from the colonial era.

The contested Act prohibited individuals licensed to sell liquor from hiring women in establishments where liquor or intoxicating substances were consumed by the public. In 2008, this case reached the Supreme Court after being overturned by the Delhi High Court in 1999. The Government of Delhi contended that the law aimed to shield women from the hazards of working in the liquor sector. The Supreme Court firmly dismissed this argument, ruling that the law fostered โ€˜invidious discrimination that perpetuated sexual differences.โ€™ In landmark rulings such as Anuj Garg, Shayara Bano (2), and Navtej Johar (3), the Court has rightly rejected the idea of inherent differences and endeavoured to view gender-based discrimination as a construct of socio-cultural institutions. However, the case of Air India v Nargesh Meerza (4) presents an alternative (and more troubling) perspective on sex discrimination.

This case challenged Regulations 46 and 47 of the Air India Employeesโ€™ Service Regulations, which facilitated the unequal treatment of male and female flight attendants concerning promotions, retirement age, and service termination. In Nargesh Meerza, the โ€˜separate-spheres theoryโ€™ legitimized discriminatory practices by assigning family planning, child-rearing, and population management as womenโ€™s specific duties.

Thus, the entire discussion surrounding gender equality reduces to the principle of self-determination. Presently, the most relevant issue concerning women’s right to self-determination pertains to abortion laws. As Raj Pal Mohan states in โ€˜Abortion in Indiaโ€™, โ€œAbortion has been part of Indian civilization since its inception. Despite the universality of abortion, all societies endeavour to regulate it through cultural standardsโ€ (5). Ancient Hindu texts regard abortion as sinful. Drawing from these texts, a predominantly patriarchal Indian society exerted control over women, denying them their right to choose. For example, Manu in his Dharmashastra asserted that where women are disrespected, no rituals can achieve the desired outcomes, equating the denial of abortion with a womanโ€™s dignity. These historical contexts reflect the evolution of abortion laws in India.

Initially, abortion was deemed a criminal act for both the woman and the abortion provider, except in cases where it was essential to preserve the woman’s life. To address these issues, the Shah Committee, chaired by Shantilal Shah, was formed in 1964. The purpose of this committee was to propose changes in the abortion legislation. In 1966, having thoroughly examined the socio-cultural, legal, and medical dimensions of abortion, the committee put forward several recommendations to liberalize the abortion laws.

The Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act of 1971 was established based on the Shah Committee’s recommendations. The MTP Act permitted (conditional) abortions performed by a medical professional, provided it was conducted in good faith and by the Act’s stipulations and within the first 12 weeks of pregnancy. If two registered medical practitioners collaborated, the pregnancy duration could be extended beyond 12 weeks, but not surpass 20 weeks. However, upon analyzing these laws, it becomes clear that they primarily view women as mothers. This perspective faces extensive critique from Gauri Pillai. Essentially, Pillai argues that the MTP Act permits abortion only under exceptional situations.

However, upon examining these laws, it becomes clear that they primarily view women as mothers. Gauri Pillai critiques this standpoint extensively. In essence, Pillai contends that the MTP Act permits abortion only under special circumstances, suggesting that, as a default, women should carry their pregnancies to term. The Act does not recognize abortion as an autonomous right, instead tying it to specific conditions. Furthermore, the Act frames abortion as a medical procedure (as indicated by the name itselfโ€”Medical Termination of Pregnancy) rather than using the term โ€˜abortionโ€™. The Act’s Statement of Reasons and Objects characterizes abortion as a โ€˜health measureโ€™ intended to prevent โ€˜wastageโ€™ of life. It prioritizes the viewpoints of medical practitioners, regarding them as โ€œco-decision makers alongside women.โ€ โ€œWomenโ€™s choices to have an abortion can be disregarded if the Medical Board concludes that carrying on with the pregnancy is โ€˜less hazardousโ€™ than terminating it at that point. Consequently, the medical risks associated with termination become the foremost concern when decisions are made under the Act,โ€ writes Gauri Pillai.

Thus, a detailed examination of Indiaโ€™s abortion legislation shows how inadequately it aligns with the Constitutionโ€™s vision. The Constitution was meant to catalyze substantial social and cultural transformation. The restrictive nature of abortion laws does not correspond to the Constitution’s transformative ethos. According to these laws, the ability of women to bear children is interpreted as a mandate that they must do so. In this context, women seeking abortion are regarded similarly to any other patients. Abortion laws should empower women to rectify historical injustices and reclaim authority over their bodies and lives. Ongoing efforts are necessary in the realm of abortion legislation. The mere existence of legal protective measures does not guarantee access to safe abortion services. The India Facility Survey reveals that by 2005, 94% of primary health centres and 69% of community health centres were not offering abortion services. Even today, the financial burden of abortion is a significant issue for rural and lower-middle-class women. While abortion procedures in the public sector are ostensibly free, they incur additional expenses such as travel or loss of daily wages. The private sector establishes its pricing, which is often prohibitively expensive and out of reach for the women who need it most.

Conclusion

Additionally, abortion remains a stigmatized subject within Indian society. Women often feel pressured to proceed with their pregnancies. As previously noted, pregnancy and childbirth are closely associated with the patriarchal notion of โ€˜family honourโ€™. Most importantly, the interpretation of abortion laws fundamentally contradicts the ideals of Constitutional Morality. Therefore, ongoing interventions, reforms, and legislative changes are necessary until all these obstacles are decisively eliminated. Indiaโ€™s abortion laws exemplify the disparity between the law as it is written and its application in practice.

-Hridya Sharma

REFERENCES

[1] Anuj Garg v Hotel Association of India, (2008) 3 SCC 1
[2] Shayara Bano v Union of India, (2017) 9 SCC 1
[3] Navtej Singh Johar and Others v Union of India, (2018) 10 SCC 1
[4] Air India v Nargesh Meerza, (1981) 4 SCC 335

— Share —

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • 9 Toxic Fighting Habits That Are Slowly Killing Your Relationship

    9 Toxic Fighting Habits That Are Slowly Killing Your Relationship

  • Mel Robbinsโ€™ Viral โ€˜Let Them Theoryโ€™: Can It Really Transform Your Life?

    Mel Robbinsโ€™ Viral โ€˜Let Them Theoryโ€™: Can It Really Transform Your Life?

  • Take This Abstract Art Quiz To Discover Your Dream Career!

    Take This Abstract Art Quiz To Discover Your Dream Career!

  • 5 Ways To Find Peace When You Are Taking The High Road

    5 Ways To Find Peace When You Are Taking The High Road

  • 14 Billie Eilish Song Lyrics That Deserve A Grammy!

    14 Billie Eilish Song Lyrics That Deserve A Grammy!

  • How to Handle Valentineโ€™s Day When Youโ€™re In a Situationship

    How to Handle Valentineโ€™s Day When Youโ€™re In a Situationship

  • Reclaim Focus: Overcome the Pitfalls of Shallow Learning

    Reclaim Focus: Overcome the Pitfalls of Shallow Learning

  • 10 Fun Galentineโ€™s Day Ideas for the Best Night With Your Girls!

    10 Fun Galentineโ€™s Day Ideas for the Best Night With Your Girls!

  • Unconventional Valentineโ€™s Day Date Ideas: Skip the Dinner, Try These Instead!

    Unconventional Valentineโ€™s Day Date Ideas: Skip the Dinner, Try These Instead!

  • Break Up On Valentines Day? 16 Self-Care Tips When You’ve Been Un-Valentined

    Break Up On Valentines Day? 16 Self-Care Tips When You’ve Been Un-Valentined

— Follow Us —

Up Next

Medusa’s Symbolism: A Reflection on Gender Roles

Medusa's Symbolism

Despite being one of Greek mythology’s most infamous monsters, Medusa’s story has always been unique. As one of the fiercest predators in the genre, she might have survived the storms of time. However, the story can be interpreted through a feminist lens. Medusa was more of the prey than the predator. As a follower of the goddess Athena, Medusa made a vow to live chastely, but when Poseidon sexually assaulted her in the temple, that plan fell apart. To put it briefly, the goddess of war did not find the Greek god Poseidon’s seduction of a lovely young woman in Athena’s temple endearing. Another version tells a darker story in which the god of the sea pursues the innocent woman violently against her will. She rushes across Athens, desperate to get away from her conqueror.

However, as the city is engulfed and drowned by the sea’s mighty waters during the dreadful pursuit, Poseidon and Medusa leave a deluge. Ano

Up Next

How to Shift Your Mindset with โ€œLucky Girl Syndromeโ€

Lucky Girl Syndrome

We’ve all heard well-known proverbs like “luck of the Irish.” Similarly, your parents might have urged you to pick up a four-leaf clover as a child to bring good fortune. Or perhaps wearing a particular colour of socks is a long-standing custom you follow to help your sports team win. Although luck isn’t a novel concept, you may be incorporating it into your life in new ways. The phrase “Lucky Girl Syndrome,” which describes the notion that good things will come to you if you believe you’re lucky, has been used in a recent TikTok trend. As a result, a lot of people are using this phrase to manifest. So, you may be asking: Is there anything wrong with following this trend?

The ‘Lucky girl syndrome’ trend has reappeared as 2025 approaches, which is to be expected given that this is the season most frequently linked to goal-setting, resolution making, and planning. The idea behind the craze is that if you tell t

Up Next

Mental Health in the Workplace: Dr. Vโ€™s Top Tips for Stress and Self Care Management

Stress and Self Care Management

If you are currently employed, you know that stress in the workplace is a part of professional life. When unmanaged, common stress can lead to larger issues like burnout, decreased productivity, and a whole host of mental health challenges, including costs to society.

According to Mindshare Partnersโ€™ 2021 study on the State of Mental Health at Work Report, over 76% of U.S. workers reported work-related stress. 1 Their more recent study in 2023 shows that although the percentage of U.S. workers reporting work-related stress has shrunk (possibly in response to relatively more stability in a post COVID world), workersโ€™ views of their mental health has in fact decreased. In 2023, a whopping 61% of U.S. workers reported experiencing at least one symptom of mental health, including burnout, anxiety or depression. 2 In light of the prevalence of work-related stress, taking the time to address mental health in th

Up Next

The Voices of Comfort Women: Stories from the Past

Comfort Women

Even though the first women were coerced into sexual slavery for Imperial Japan almost a century ago, the specifics of their enslavement are still painful and contentious in Japan and the former occupied nations. There are few records of women’s subjugation; an estimated 90% of “comfort women” did not survive the war, and there are very few survivors. Although military brothels had been a part of the Japanese military since 1932, they became much more widespread following the Rape of Nanking, one of the most notorious events in imperial Japan’s campaign to conquer the Republic of China and a large portion of Asia. The Chinese city of Nanking was virtually destroyed by a six-week massacre that Japanese troops started on December 13, 1937. Emperor Hirohito was worried about how the mass rapes would affect Japan’s reputation, and they appalled the entire world. He directed the military to increase its so-called “comfort stations,” or military brothels, as legal hi

Up Next

Understanding The Relationship Between Psychoneuroimmunology and Childhood Trauma : Why It Matters

Childhood Trauma

Childhood psychosocial stressors can impact the development of the immune system, which can then affect the development of the brain and its long-term functioning due to the two-way relationship between the immune system and the brain. Psychoneuroimmunology of early-life stress can provide a novel framework for comprehending and treating psychopathology associated with childhood trauma, based on observational human studies and experimental animal models. Remarkably, several incidents involved once-healthy people who became mentally ill despite not having any physical injuriesโ€”the so-called “railway spine.”

A contentious discussion was sparked by these odd observations. On the one hand, proponents of organic explanations believed that train accidents might have resulted in psychopathology due to invisible brain damage. Conversely, proponents of functional explanations believed that psychopathology could resu

Up Next

Discovering Happiness: Six Things to Look Forward to in 2025

Discovering Happiness

Everybody posts about their accomplishments of success, competence, grit, and determination at this time of year. How beautifully their vision boards have come to life in the splendour of their captivating lives! Even though it is a wonderful accomplishment for everyone who had a year full of love and happiness, it is crucial to keep in mind that the life that is portrayed on social media is the culmination of a person’s greatest moments throughout their entire life. Putting oneself out there and sharing their happiness on their platform is fantastic, but in a society where comparison is so widespread. 2024 has been a challenging year for me, as it has been for many others.. Everybody has experienced their share of setbacks and victories this year, and each person’s level of pain varies.

Even though 2024 has been challenging, I am thankful for what I have managed to maintain amidst the chaos of change all aro

Up Next

Life In Its Brevity Often Feels Burdensome

Feels Burdensome

Life in its brevity often feels burdensome, yearning for us to be free of all the turbulence that stirs up its breaths in our hearts. How beautiful would life be if we let go of pain, anger, sadness, grim! I wish we had built-in programming that would delete all the moments and experiences that stirred catastrophic fires and raged war and kindled and whooshed the fire within us simultaneously! Human minds behold the capability of inventiveness, of loving, of living and yet with so much to be blissful about, we are inherent in our ounces to be boggled about negativity, to be enveloped in the traumatic flashes of our photographic memory. I know it is vital to be grateful for the goodness of life, the light that exists in our strides, the privilege and the beauties that we possess, the existence that we lead is a dream for many, that all consorts to be the gospel truth and cannot be denied. But at the end of every second we spend in this mortal realm, in the most