What Happens When Men And Women Reverse Dating Roles?

 / 

Men Women Reverse Dating Roles

When it comes to dating, there is still a lot of traditionalism regarding who should approach whom. But imagine if men and women reverse dating roles? What if the dating roles are reversed, and instead of the man approaching the woman, it’s the other way round?

Two people are out at a party. One is standing with friends, while another person approaches from across the room to strike up a conversation. Chances are, in this scenario, you imagined that it was a guy approaching a girl. Whether it’s in a social setting or online, we seem to expect men to make the first move.

Why? Well, we all have what psychologists call โ€œbehavioral scripts,โ€ which are a sequence of events that we expect to typically occur in social situations. You have a script for how to act in a job interview, how to place an order at a restaurant, and how to cheer for a sports team. 

Related: 3 Frustrating and Ridiculous Ways Men Test Women While Dating 

Dating is no different. In most cultures, expectations about male and female dating behavior (such as โ€œguys approach girlsโ€) are fairly entrenched. A study of nearly 300 undergraduates found that if a man initiated a date, students felt both partners were interested (Reid et al., 2011). However, if the woman initiated the date, many (around 40%) saw the man as only doing it out of pity. When a woman initiates, it appears to violate some type of unwritten rule.

But we donโ€™t always follow those rules. There are exceptions. For example, there are special days or events where we intentionally flip the script. On Sadie Hawkins Day (traditionally observed in early Novemberโ€”it falls on November 13th in 2020 and 2021) or at a Sadie Hawkins Dance, women have the opportunity to invert social convention by asking men out on a date or to a dance. 

Researchers have examined speed dating to help them better understand datingโ€™s underlying scripts and expectations (Finkel & Eastwick, 2008). Speed dating is a structured way for daters to meet a lot of people quickly. The typical speed-dating event features women sitting at various locations around a room, often a coffee shop or bar, while men circulate and chat with each woman for a few minutes. A signal will then indicate that time is up and the men should move along to the next woman.

The process repeats until everyone at the event has โ€œdatedโ€ each other. Later, the male and female participants let the event organizer know which partners they would like to see again. If the male and female indicate mutual interest, the organizer gives them each otherโ€™s contact information. If done efficiently, a speed dater could meet over a dozen potential dating partners in less than an hour.

The typical speed-dating event relies heavily on the โ€œmale approaches femaleโ€ norm. Consistent with the norm, speed-dating research reveals that women are pickier than men when indicating interest in potential partners (Todd et al., 2007). That is, women say โ€œyesโ€ much less frequently than men, with men indicating interest in roughly half the potential partners and women indicating interest in only a third (Kurzban & Weeden, 2005). 

However, other researchers wondered if what seems like a clear-cut gender difference, truly was a gender difference, or if the social situation was the actual cause (Finkel & Eastwick, 2009). Specifically, they investigated whether women were pickier because they got to sit in one place, while men had to work their way around the room.

To test this, they had more than 300 undergraduates participate in speed-dating events. In half of those events, participants engaged in the standard speed-dating procedure where men circulated while women stayed in one place. For the other events, men and women performed a Sadie Hawkins-like role reversal: men stayed in one place while women circulated around the room. 

In the standard โ€œmen rotatingโ€ events, the researchers replicated previous findings (and the prevailing stereotypes) that women were pickier about who they liked relative to men. But in the non-standard โ€œwomen rotatingโ€ events where men and women reversed roles, the researcher found the exact opposite pattern: men were picky, whereas women were less selective. Put another way, there was a โ€œSadie Hawkins Effect.โ€ 

When women were forced to go from man to man during the speed-dating event, they debunked the gender stereotype by showing an interest in more of the potential partners.

These findings show how a widely assumed gender difference โ€” women are picky about who they date, while men arenโ€™t โ€” maybe an artifact of social situations. Men may be less picky not because they are men, but because societal norms require them to do most of the approaching in dating scenarios. Womenโ€™s selectivity, meanwhile, might arise from their essentially arbitrary role as โ€œselectors.โ€ In other words, when lots of potential suitors regularly approach you, itโ€™s a lot easier to be picky.

Related: The Top 9 Biggest Turn-Offs For Men When Dating

This brings up a much broader point: itโ€™s simple to assume that men and women behave very differently because of evolved, inborn differences. Research on the Sadie Hawkins effect shows how careful we should be to avoid assumptions about gender differences, and how we may not need to look far for other potential explanations. Situations are powerful influencers that we too easily overlook.

Check out the new book of Gary W. Lewandowski Jr., Stronger Than You Think: The 10 Blind Spots That Undermine Your Relationshipโ€ฆand How to See Past Them, to know more about relationships, and how to handle them.

References:

Reid, J., Elliott, S., & Webber, G. (2011). Casual hookups to formal dates: Refining the boundaries of the sexual double standard. Gender and Society, 25(5), 545-568. 

Finkel, E. J., & Eastwick, P. W. (2008). Speed-dating. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 17(3), 193โ€“197. 

Todd, P. M., Penke, L., Fasolo, B., & Lenton, A. P. (2007). Different cognitive processes underlie human mate choices and mate preferences. PNAS Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of The United States of America, 104(38), 15011-15016. 

Kurzban, R., & Weeden, J. (2005). HurryDate: Mate preferences in action. Evolution and Human Behavior, 26(3), 227-244.

Finkel, E. J., & Eastwick, P. W. (2009). Arbitrary social norms influence sex differences in romantic selectivity. Psychological Science, 20(10), 1290-1295. 

Written By Gary W. Lewandowski Jr. 
Originally Appeared In Psychology Today
Men Women Reverse Dating Roles pin
What Happens When Men And Women Reverse Dating Roles

— Share —

— About the Author —

Leave a Reply



Up Next

Are You Hesitant To Commit? 6 Warning Signs Of Lack Of Commitment In A Relationship And How To Navigate Them

Signs of Lack of Commitment in a Relationship: Red Flags

Do you always find yourself in short-term, casual relationships? Does the idea of committing in a relationship make you nervous? Are you showing signs of lack of commitment in a relationship?

Commitment issues can be a significant barrier to building a healthy and fulfilling partnership, affecting both individuals involved. Today, let us explore what are commitment issues, the signs that may indicate their presence, the underlying causes of commitment issues, and effective strategies to overcome them.

By understanding these factors, you can empower yourself to navigate the complexities of relationships with greater confidence and clarity.

Are You Afraid of Commitment?



Up Next

6 Signs Of Soft Ghosting: Decoding The Art Of Disappearing

Signs Of Soft Ghosting: Decoding The Art Of Disappearing

Imagine a scenario where you’re texting someone you like, and everything seems great. Then, out of nowhere, they stop replying, and you’re stuck not knowing what’s really going on. This is just one of the signs of soft ghosting.

Soft ghosting is usually a bit different from the usual ghosting because it’s more gradual. Imagine being left hanging without any explanation; it feels like a half-hearted response. You aren’t completely ignored, but you’re clearly not at the top of their list.

So, what is soft ghosting, really? And how to deal with soft ghosting? Let’s first try to understand what is soft ghosting.<



Up Next

How To Move On From A Situationship? 3 Things That Can Help You

How To Move On From A Situationship? Things That Can Help

If you have ever been in a situationship, you know that it still hurts when it ends. So, how to move on from a situationship? In this article, we are going to talk about some of the best things to do if you’re trying to move on from a situationship.

A โ€œsituationshipโ€ is a romantic and/or sexual relationship that isnโ€™t formally defined. You may know it by its other pop culture references like โ€œfriends with benefits,โ€ โ€œfun buddies,โ€ or โ€œbooty call.โ€

People in situationships generally arenโ€™t exclusively committed to each other and typically arenโ€™t expected to fork over a ton of emotional investment.



Up Next

6 Things Single People Are Tired Of Hearing: Hearing It On Repeat

Things Single People Are Tired Of Hearing: Enough Already

Being single is not a crime, nor is it something to feel sorry about. There are so many things single people are tired of hearing, and they just want all those “well-wishers” to just zip it. Let’s explore 6 of the most annoying things single people are sick of hearing, and the things single people hate hearing.

KEY POINTS

Despite their good intentions, family and friends often give harmful advice to single people.

It’s important for daters not to get so overwhelmed that they ignore their own values.

Relationships can progress at different speeds and intensities and stil



Up Next

11 Types Of Dating Trends Popular Among Gen-Z: Stay Up-to-Date with the Latest Lingo!

Types Of Dating Trends Popular Among Gen-Z In

Welcome to the wild and wacky world of Gen Z dating trends! Itโ€™s bound to be a rollercoaster. In this digital age, where swiping right is as customary as saying hi, thereโ€™s a certain way Gen Z has perfected the art of connecting, through their different and dare I say interesting types of dating trends.

With situationships thatโ€™ll have you scratching your head to love hazes thatโ€™ll have you say โ€œbeen there!โ€ weโ€™re diving into 11 popular gen z dating trends that will leave you feeling confused and intrigued at the same time.

So buckle up for the ride ahead and get ready to navigate the dicey wor



Up Next

5 Signs Of Dating Burnout:ย Hitting The Wall in Love?

Signs Of Dating Burnout: Hitting The Wall in Love?

Ever felt like you’ve hit a brick wall in your love life? That’s dating burnout for you, and it’s more common than you think. It’s that overwhelming feeling when the search for “The One” starts to feel more like a chore than a journey of the heart. Let’s dive into the five telltale signs that you might be experiencing this modern love dilemma.

KEY POINTS

Burnout is usually characterized by a feeling that no matter what one does, nothing will improve, often leading to feelings of apathy.

One study found that 78 percent of adults aged 18-54 have experienced online dating burnout.



Up Next

Dating With Low Self Esteem? 6 Tips For Navigating The Dating Scene with Confidence

Dating With Low Self Esteem? Tips For Being More Confident

Ah, the exciting universe of dating! Dating in the modern world can feel like a rollercoaster filled with thrilling emotions and fluttering hearts. But what do you do when you suffer from low self esteem? What does it look like, dating with low self esteem?

Dating with low self esteem can feel as difficult as trying to solve a Rubik’s cube with one hand tied behind your back. Interactions may be marred by negative self-perceptions which can make you doubt your worth and desirability. However, donโ€™t let that scare you, because low self-esteem does not necessarily mean doom.

In this article, we are going to t